
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Show Notes
Summary
Chris Moreno - Primary Venture Partners
Special mentions
* Company: NMHC, IPA, Marcus & Millichap, CBRE, Cushman & Wakefield, UDR, WOOD Partners, Greystar, Fordham University, KKR.
* People: Jay Parsons, Scott Wesson, Caren Maio, Brad Hargreaves, Ravi Bhatia, Stephanie Fuhrman, Karen Hollinger, Peter H. Diamandis.
Transcript
(Disclaimer: Please be advised that this transcript may contain unintentionally confusing, inaccurate, and/or amusing transcription errors.)
[00:00:00]
Matt Knight: Hey guys, Matt here, another quick chat today with Chris Moreno. And this one it's actually from a couple of weeks ago, back when this was fresh, but I think it's all still very relevant because he just gotten back from New York and from NMHC event in San Diego. So we talked about trends and interest rates and centralization and a few other things you can hear for yourself, but it's another, just quick chat with he and I, and I'm sorry, that's taken me a couple of weeks to get it out.
I had to get the accelerator thing and a couple other things published first, but this should be a fun little jaunt down what's going on in multifamily tech, and I hope you enjoy it.
Matt Knight: All right, Chris. Glad to have you here, man. Round three. I think today we are talking about events in PropTech, right?
Chris Moreno: Yeah. Yeah, I just got back from New York this [00:01:00] week and from San Diego and NMHC yeah, happy to catch up on some of what transpired as well as some of the upcoming events.
Matt Knight: So NMHC has always been a little perplexing to me because it strikes me as almost like the ULI fall meeting where it's a bunch of owners and acquisitions crew doing deals, right?
But then when I got people pinging me saying, Are you going to San Diego? It was 90 percent startups. So I love to hear sort of, I think most people know what Optech is and Optech is where I spend most of my time. But what is this conference and how is it different?
Chris Moreno: Yeah, so NMHC, which stands for, and people really mess it up a lot but it stands for National Multifamily Housing Council, for those who don't know, and that's their advocacy group, right, that focuses on developers owners, and management companies, as well as supplier partners for the apartment industry in the US, and this event is what's called their annual meetings. It's broken up into three events. They have the women's event, On Monday, they [00:02:00] have the apartment strategies on Tuesday with speakers. And then on Tuesday night, Wednesday and Thursday, they have broader meetings and sessions. So there are no booths at this event.
There are no suppliers per se selling at you at a booth or whatnot. It's more focused on, I think, number one is advocacy. So political activity with topics like rent control REMS, Insurance law, things like that, development laws. And then you have secondarily a lot of focus on deals getting done to your point, right?
It's the brokers, you know, you have the IPA, the Marcus & Millichap, the CBREs the Cushmans, everyone coming together to make deals happen. So you have a lot of owners. Partnering with other owners and the brokers trying to make those deals happen in an environment like this. Thirdly, you do have suppliers and leaders because you have management companies.
And at this show, a lot of times it's the management companies connecting with each other. I think 1 of things we can talk about. There was. There's a decent amount of M&A happening. So that was [00:03:00] interesting to see among the management companies and people. You know, where are they going to focus their energy moving forward?
I think there was a lot of collaboration. And then there's a lot fewer actual like PropTech companies per se, because they're not actively selling, they're more there to support, more to have meetings with each other where it strategically makes sense. And I'll say there's a fourth audience, Matt, that shows up for this one, which are some of the PropTech funds.
So many of the PropTech funds raising capital and or seeing some of their LPs and or their companies will also host meetings or host session. So that's kind of a breakdown high level. And I'm happy to go a little bit deeper.
Matt Knight: Yeah, I don't think we need to dig more into attendees or the content.
I'm curious if you have any takeaways or sort of big themes you heard this year while you were there, because I didn't go and you did.
Chris Moreno: I think there's definitely a few things. So number one was around interest rates, right? Interest rates essentially guide , purchasing power. They guide [00:04:00] developments and new starts. And so there was a lot of optimism. I think we use that word cautious optimism, but much more optimism from last year. What people are looking for, in real estate is consistency. So the biggest discussion was around, can we get interest rates away from increasing or decreasing, 500, 750 basis points to just smaller, 25%, you know, or 250 basis points that helps people to plan the future.
And then a big piece on the supply. So people were talking about areas, Arizona, where you live, as a good example, where there was this, feeling of too much too many new not just housing starts, but too many units coming on the market, right, over the last year, year and a half, two years.
Whereas now, people who completely exited the market that I spoke to are now looking to get back in the market. Because what happened is, you know, the cycles. Is that the units get absorbed pretty rapidly, but when the minute [00:05:00] people see too many units coming on the market, the insiders stop developing there and they move to other markets.
Well, that just creates a chain reaction. So that was another topic that, the people like Jay Parsons and many other people who are economists who break down these markets daily, we're sharing on stage that everything's cyclical. So the minute there's too many developments, they move to other markets and then there's a massive need a year or 2 down the road.
So even though interest rates have scared away a lot of developers. They're seeing 2025 2026 as going to be years where there's going to be a massive shortage of housing and we'll see rents increasing. Prognostics or the crystal balls say that rents will be increasing dramatically in those years.
There were a lot of people trying to sell off assets at this event, and I think you're seeing buyers and sellers coming together closer. So, hearing some of where people are making deals happen at the show. That was really good to see. And I saw some deals come across my desk. I think 1 of the other things that was a [00:06:00] hot topic was AI.
And the technology effect. So one of the big things that stood out like Scott Wesson at UDR spoke about, centralization. And is centralization actually a thing? Absolutely. And AI is really making an impact there. So the people who choose to start using AI and technology are going to become more profitable.
And they're going to outperform those who don't or who think it's just a fad. So, he shared an example. I think he's moved 40 of his properties away from having leasing staff on site, which is pretty incredible and is saving the company tens of millions of dollars a year. So that that helps him be more profitable.
Whereas other people are doubling down on hospitality, but just in different ways. So a lot of removal of certain tasks. And I think things that didn't people are sharing things that didn't make sense 2 years ago are now really starting to make sense today.
Matt Knight: define centralization in this context, just to make sure people are on the same page what he's talking about.
Chris Moreno: Absolutely. So, I think there's many ways to think about it, [00:07:00] but generally centralization can be viewed as taking any of the tasks of an on site staff, whether it's answering phone calls, responding to emails, scheduling, maintenance inquiries to accounting right and monthly accounts payabl…
Show Notes
Summary
Chris Moreno - Primary Venture Partners
Special mentions
* AR Vacuuming App - Daniel Beauchamp.
* Company: SUMSEI, Rise Buildings, Lowercarbon Capital, Fifth Wall, Moderne Ventures, NMHC, Trammell Crow, Camden Property Trust, The Bozzuto Group, XPRIZE, Equity Residential, Comunidad Partners, Greystar Real Estate Partners.
* People: Roger Breslin, Laurie Baker, Ken Valach, Julie Smith, Jay Parsons, Susan Rice, Peter H. Diamandis, Barry Altshuler, Bernard Fulton, Antonio Marquez.
Transcript
(Disclaimer: Please be advised that this transcript may contain unintentionally confusing, inaccurate, and/or amusing transcription errors.)
[00:00:00]
Matt Knight: Hey guys, Matt here. Round two with Chris Moreno, my buddy. We're talking this time about CES hardware and this was back before NMHC, which is now a couple weeks ago. So it's a little dated, but it's still pretty, hopefully pretty timely. So this is me and Chris just chatting again. I'll have another one up in a couple of weeks where he reviews NMHC.
And so just keep your ears out for that. Otherwise, enjoy me and Chris chatting round two for about 20 minutes.
All right, Chris. Thanks for being here. Round two. Excited to dig in more. And I think it is your turn to ask the kickoff question.
Chris Moreno: Yeah. Thanks for always connecting and sharing, your thoughts, Matt. I know you can go down rabbit holes and prop tech and real estate. And I love that. You went down to CES, which is, I think one of the biggest shows of the year around [00:01:00] the world.
So I'd love to hear your thoughts around what you saw at CES that pertained to real estate and technology. And maybe even what you saw around things that are must haves versus things that are pie in the sky.
Matt Knight: So, the thing about CES is it's so big that the layout is hard to understand, right?
Like, you kind of know where the cars are. The cars were over at the Vegas Convention Center. But in every single, I'd say there were eight, like, main exhibit halls. Two at the Venetian, three at the Convention Center, one at ARIA, like, they're all over, right? And each one of them had at least one section where they had these signs hanging from the ceilings that says Smart Homes, right?
And so, how is Venetian Floor 2 Smart Home section different than Venetian Floor 1 Smart Home? Like, they're all over the place. So I couldn't, maybe just because I'm new, but I couldn't gather a rhyme or reason to sort of why things were laid out where they were. Right. [00:02:00] And so you would go and see a smart home section and you would see Sam has sung, right.
And here's the new, you know, Google offerings. And here's the things that whatever, you know, people are doing IOT for your sprinklers and that's all great. Right. But it made it sort of hard to synthesize any one theme or trend other than IOT is massive, right? Here's a bunch of internet enabled stuff that you can put in your house, which could be dishwashers, right?
I saw one. There's a cool demo online. We can Google and probably put a link in the show notes to where there's like an AR augmentation to a vacuum where you can see what area you've covered or not. So you sort of gamified vacuuming, right? And so stuff like that, where there was a ton of it, but I didn't discern any one theme because I would see it in the three hours later, see very similar things three miles away.
Okay. Right. And so part of what I did, and I think I said this last time was I tried to find things that weren't necessarily obviously for us. There was one guy I've been talking to that's a [00:03:00] wifi signal booster. And I said, have you ever thought about selling the multifamily? Cause they have issues with that.
And he's like, we'd love to, right. There was another one called SUMSEI, which I loved. And they had this blacked out booth where you walk into this it's almost like a shipping container and they hit you with scents and sounds and lights where it feels like you're in nature, like the ideas are supposed to be in nature.
And so I kind of went over to their booth and their director of partnerships and I was like, Hey, there's some cool common areas in hotels, in apartment buildings, maybe even an office where having a little more green nature, like experience would be interesting. Would you be open to that? And he's like, absolutely.
And so I know that's a long winded way of saying, but like, it's hard to draw parallels when the smart home stuff is so disparate and all over the place. And a lot of what I was there to do is say, Hey, this would be super cool if commercial building owners could use this to improve the lives or experience of their tenants.
So that was the bulk of what I spent [00:04:00] my time on.
Chris Moreno: Got it. And what would you say from the things you saw there, what percentage were. Like actionable things you thought, you know, everyone thinks they can come to market. Everyone thinks they can raise capital and get sales on day one or early.
What would you say is the percentage? Was it like 70 percent was like, this could be in multifamily or this could be in real estate, or was it more like. 10 percent that you saw that could actually happen in the next three to six months.
Matt Knight: You mean of the whole of all exhibitors or of the ones that I thought were relevant to our space.
Chris Moreno: Probably more relevant to our space, like what percentage even then, like was relevant to our space, number one, maybe number two.
The second way to answer the question is, within what was relevant, what percentage was pie in the sky versus, you know, now.
Matt Knight: I'm going to guess five to 10 percent was relevant and it's probably closer to five if I had to guess. There's a lot of cool pet tech and health tech and new robotics that have nothing to do, you know, maybe I should tell you that I define [00:05:00] PropTech as something you sell the landlord.
The person that owns the building. So if you have a really cool inventory robot, right, or outdoor delivery robot, that's probably not prop tech, right, because inventory is going to deal with the person that owns the inventory, not the person that owns the building, right, and outdoor delivery, but what I look at like indoor deliveries, I was like, Well, that could be interesting from your formal world.
Could I take things from a package room or from a mail room and deliver them via elevator up to my tenants on the sixth floor, right? There's a use case there, right? So I think it's five to 10%, probably closer to five. And most of it is ready because it costs so much to get hardware to Vegas and display it.
You're probably not outside of the country and university specific booths. You're probably not going to bring tech that doesn't have some commercial ready applications. Does that make sense? Yes. Yeah. I'm not going to pay 7, 500 to put my robot on a boat or a truck and then pay [00:06:00] the unions in Vegas, unload them and set up my booth.
If I can't make a sale today, like you, you kind of have to be market ready. And there's, I think tens of thousands of vendors there. So there's a lot of people there and it's, I think they're all in varying degrees of market ready. And some of what it's famous for, as you see on YouTube or Twitter, whatever is here's a prototype car, right?
Here's a prototype, you know, Caterpillar had a cool booth with a prototype dirt mover. Like there's some stuff there like that, that is prototype, but those are massive companies that have things they can sell you today. And they're, they're using that eye candy to hook you. Right. Most of them are, here's a new smart leash for your dog or whatever.
So it's, all hardware. And it's all ready to do something. And depending on the size and stage of the company, it's varying degrees of market readiness, is what I would say.
Chris Moreno: Great. Yeah, that's, you know, I think what's interesting too, like to get your thoughts around, you know, the hot topics of AI, you know, whethe…
Show Notes
Summary
Chris Moreno - Primary Venture Partners
Special mentions
* Company: Macy's, Luxer One, Assa Abloy, On Deck, Y Combinator, Xeal, CBRE, Marcus & Millichap, South Downtown, Bozzuto, RangeWater, RADCO, Blackstone, BlackRock, Invesco, Wellstar, Atlanta Braves, Figma, Adobe, Yardi, RealPage, Entrata, Airbnb, Loom, Saltbox, Tyler Scriven, WeWork, Switchyards, Industrious, Deskpass, Codi, Atlanta Tech Village (ATV), Fifth Wall, A16z, Flock Safety.
* People: Erik Torenberg, David Cummings, Jon Birdsong, David Lightburn, Warren Buffett, Brian Chesky, Brendan Wallace.
Transcript
(Disclaimer: Please be advised that this transcript may contain unintentionally confusing, inaccurate, and/or amusing transcription errors.)
[00:00:00]
Matt Knight: Hey guys, happy new year. Hope your 2024 is off to a wonderful start. First episode of this year is going to be me chatting with my buddy Chris Moreno, who you guys probably know he's a friend of mine from Atlanta, PropTech guy. I think they call him Mr. PropTech, but what I wanted to do was have sort of an ongoing conversation that's a little more Freewheeling a lot up to this point have been specific topics for people we've been trying to introduce and this is going to be a little more broad, wide ranging just kind of chatter between him and I about a variety of prop tech topics and prop tech adjacent topics.
So this is my first episode with Chris. It's about 20 minutes and we'll do these every few weeks going forward and just sort of stay on top of trends and ideas and reflection. So I hope you enjoy. This is Chris, my buddy, [00:01:00] and give me feedback if there's anything else you think we should cover. Thanks.
Matt Knight: All right, Chris, thanks for being here, man. Glad to have you with us. And if you don't mind, since I know we're going to do Several of these. I'd love if you give us a quick background on you just so people know who we're talking to here.
Chris Moreno: Sure. Well, I think number one people love to earned this acronym or a name, nickname, Mr. Prop tech. So a lot of people tend to call me because I really focus on technology in the property space and love the physical world. So I real quick, I'm from California, born and bred. And left California just a few years ago to relocate to Atlanta, Georgia. But before that I went to school in UC Santa Barbara, I played a lot of golf in high school and college and worked my way through college.
And so my first career job was actually out at Macy's corporate and why it's relevant is I worked on a procurement. And implementation into our stores, building brands, and then I got to work on our tech team and that [00:02:00] working with our tech team around remote work around utilizing technology for teams in the field is what got me excited about technology, joined a startup.
So I left, I joined a startup in 2010 that was building lockers for dry cleaning and laundry. For apartment buildings and we, I joined that team and then we ended up building two new startups essentially pivoting to take software around the world for real estate owners and retail owners and then for delivery of goods and services.
And then our 3rd company was called Luxer and Luxer One focused on package delivery. So we had this thesis on the world that. Packages would become more prevalent back then buildings were getting maybe two or three or four packages a day. We said, there's going to be a real problem. This company named Amazon is going to be massive.
And so ended up we were correct in our thesis. We actually thought we, but we didn't realize how big it would become. And so we scaled that business Luxer and sold in 2018 to a company called Assa Abloy. And that was a really enlightening for me both because I could then start investing in other great founders.
So [00:03:00] that was a big goal for me. And that changed my life. And I was able. To start doing that in 2018 and then number two to learn about other technologies and other spaces. And so that's what I jumped into, ended up joining a, you know, I got to meet you, got to know you. And then I ended up joining Erik Torenberg and the team over at On Deck.
And so we built an Ollie, an early stage accelerator, which was a blast and got to focus on very early stage companies, even at idea stage or revenues, similar to Y Combinator. And my focus is really on. Early stage prop tech. So real estate prop tech logistics and got to make over a hundred plus investments.
And many of those companies are still operating today. And then I joined a company called Xeal energy and that was focused on the transition of EV into commercial real estate. And more recently I had my third child born and he actually had a little bit of a heart issue. So I took some time off and I'm now doing really full time investing in prop tech and then also doing some coaching and my wife and I started a [00:04:00] consulting business and advisory group for CEOs and founders. So that's where I'm at today. And really I spend my time connecting with really smart people like yourself and VCs, family offices, as well as founders and operators in real estate.
Matt Knight: I forgot some of that. I forgot you went to UCSB. So, you know, go Gauchos. It's probably a good way to start. And what's the I mean, I think what's different about this with you and I is we know each other well enough that we can probably keep this pretty casual and freewheeling, but I'm curious.
Looking forward, what does 2024 look like? I know you took some time, you got the consulting, you have some gigs that you're working on, but I'm curious how do you view this year and PropTech and the people you touch?
Chris Moreno: So I'm very bullish. I've. Tended to be an optimist, but I am extremely bullish.
This reminds me, you know, for those, I just had a coffee this week with an icon in the real estate world here in Atlanta. And we were talking about how he said many of the people he meets with have not been through a cycle. Right. They've made a ton of money in the last three, four or five years, but they have not seen a cycle yet.
They're [00:05:00] now living into a cycle. So we are definitely going into a cycle. It's been tough on a lot of people. You're going to, I think number one, obviously we have trillions of dollars. That will be going. And if you read these reports from CBRE, from Marcus & Millichap, you know, Barkhati, all these others, I think the thing you and I are probably both seeing a lot of, are going to see is transactions are going to be forced.
So transactions have not been happening over the last year in real estate because you're not getting buyer and seller coming together. So number one hottest elephant in the room is interest rates and because three year terms are going to be coming up. You're going to see transit dollars that are going to be forced to transact, whether someone buys it, like the South downtown project here David Cummings, Jon Birdsong, David Lightburn, Ali and the team over there, that was a forced transaction, right?
That was a transaction that probably sold for much less than what the previous people bought it for, and they got in a bad position. So, or you can, you're going to see it on the courthouse steps and the banks taking over and then someone buying it at even a lower discount. So that's part of the outlook on the real estate world.
I'm very [00:06:00] bullish because , I've been sitting on the sidelines for a couple of years. I'm excited to be able to invest. And I think this is the best time. I think downturns are a great time to invest as people are scared. You know, we need people who are ready to make investments. I think you're going to see more and more founders.
People who are laid off, or people who had great jobs are now like, I'm gonna build, I'm not gonna go back to a company I'm gonna build right now. This reminds me of the downturn of 2009, 2010, and also the downturn of 2000, 2001, 2002, where people started companies and they built incredible c…
Show Notes
Summary
Spencer Rascoff - Pacaso
Special mentions
* Company: 75 & Sunny, Zillow, Hey Libby, dot.LA, Hotwire, Expedia, Queue, Recon Food, Redfin, Realtor.com, CoStar, Tomo.
* People: Austin Allison, Greg Schwartz, Whitney Curry, Errol Samuelson.
Transcript
[00:00:00]
Matt Knight: Hey everyone, Matt here. Episode of the podcast. This time we have Spencer …