Something isn't right in the cabin.

With Evil still missing and the sun seemingly refusing to rise, Rottin' Roger is trying to hold things together and get an episode out for the Deep Cut audience… even if that means letting Walter co-host.

Walter insists on discussing one of his favorite horror movie topics — possession.

Walter chooses The Shining.
Roger chooses Evil Dead.

But as the episode goes on, Walter keeps pushing Roger toward something far more dangerous… reading from the Necronomicon.

Roger refuses.

Until Walter suggests playing a reel-to-reel tape that supposedly contains a brand new outro song for the show.

It wasn't just music.

And whatever was on that tape may have just changed everything.