This week on the SNL Hall of Fame: Water Cooler, jD, Joe, and Shari dive headfirst into the legacy, laughter, and loud opinions surrounding Jimmy Fallon, the latest nominee in the SNL Hall of Fame. With Jon Schneider making the official pitch on the main show, the gang gathers by the metaphorical cooler to debate whether Fallon’s giggle-prone persona deserves a plaque—or a polite pass.

Shari brings the skepticism, Joe brings the enthusiasm, and jD tries to keep the water chilled as the trio unpacks Jon’s impassioned defense, including Fallon’s cheerleader energy, his post-SNL advocacy, and his triple-threat status: sketches, impressions, and a stint at the Update desk. Is Fallon a Hall of Famer—or just the guy who couldn’t stop laughing at Debbie Downer?

💥 Next week: Kirsten Rajala joins the main show to present Cecily Strong, the final nominee of Season 7 before the Don Pardo Awards.

👉 Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review. Join the conversation on Facebook at facebook.com/groups/SNLHOF or email us at [email protected].

🎧 Listen now and decide—will Jimmy Fallon crack your top picks, or will he be breaking character in the Hall of “Meh”?

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/snlhof/donations

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy