Rabbi Joseph Dana hosts classes every day at 6:50 AM at West Deal Shul.
This class on Berachot 20b examines the question of women's obligations in various mitzvot, including mezuzah, Talmud Torah, Kiddush, and Birkat HaMazon. The Gemara explores why women, who are generally exempt from time-bound positive commandments, are nonetheless obligated in Shabbat observance, and how the principle of zachor u'shamor — that whoever is obligated in shmirat Shabbat is equally obligated in zachor — brings women into the obligation of Kiddush. The class then turns to the central question of whether women's obligation in Birkat HaMazon is biblical or rabbinic, examining Rashi's position that since women do not have brit milah and did not receive a direct portion in Eretz Yisrael, their obligation may only be rabbinic. The practical halachic difference is whether a woman can fulfill a man's obligation in Birkat HaMazon, which hinges on whether her obligation is at the same biblical level as his. The class concludes with the ruling that if a woman is only rabbinically obligated, she cannot fulfill the biblical obligation of a man.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
(0:00) Intro: Women & Mezuzah
(1:32) Women & Talmud Torah Obligation
(3:16) Women & Birkat HaMazon
(5:12) Women & Kiddush
(6:22) Deriving Kiddush from Shabbat
(7:48) Kiddush: Rabbinic vs Biblical
(10:54) Gemara's Challenge on Women
(13:14) Shmirat Shabbat & Women
(15:24) Zachor & Shamor Connection
(18:26) Question: Women in Birkat HaMazon
(19:00) Rashi: Land & Brit Milah
(20:00) The Miracle of Bread
(21:18) No Milah, No Chelek in Israel
(22:05) Why the Difference Matters
(23:12) Women Fulfilling Men's Obligation
(24:10) The Curse of Rabbeinu Yerucham
(25:06) Rabbinic vs Biblical: Final Point
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Visit: westdealshul.org
Sponsorships: [email protected]