Rabbi Joseph Dana hosts classes Monday through Friday at 6:50 AM at West Deal Shul.
In this class on Berachot 23a, Rabbi Dana continues the sugya of what to do with Tefillin when one needs to use the bathroom. He traces the historical progression of rabbinic decrees: from leaving Tefillin in windowsills near the bathroom, to moving them to public-facing windows to deter rats, to ultimately requiring one to hold them in hand after theft became a problem. The Gemara then records the ruling of R' Miyasha, son of R' Yehoshua ben Levi, that one should wrap the Tefillin like a book, hold them in the right hand against the heart, and enter the bathroom — with an important discussion about the kedushah of Tefillin straps, which carry holiness because they complete the mitzvah and spell out the divine name Shakai. Rabbi Dana also addresses the distinction between entering the bathroom during the day when there is still time to put Tefillin back on — in which case one holds them against the chest — versus end of day, when one should place them in a proper bag before entering. The class closes with two Talmudic stories about Amoraim who carried Torah books into the bathroom rather than handing them off, affirming the permissibility and even preferability of bringing holy items in under proper conditions rather than leaving them unguarded.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
(0:00) Intro: Tefillin & the Bathroom
(1:27) Barishona: Original Practice
(2:11) Problem: Rats Steal Tefillin
(2:37) Solution: Move to Public Window
(3:48) New Problem: People Steal Tefillin
(5:14) Rabbinic Decree: Hold in Hand
(5:41) R' Miyasha: Wrap Like a Book
(6:02) Hold in Right Hand, Against Heart
(7:25) Kedushah of Tefillin Straps
(8:42) Spelling Shakai with Tefillin
(10:36) Straps Must Not Touch Floor
(12:14) Mekubalim: Tuck Into Belt
(12:42) Only When Time Remains in Day
(13:40) End of Day: Use the Bag
(17:53) Wearing Tefillin All Day
(19:11) Tefillin Bag Needs a Tefach Space
(21:33) Abaye: Special vs. Regular Bag
(22:27) Tumah and the Tefach Rule
(23:44) Story: R' Yochanan & Torah Book
(25:02) Story: Rav Nachman & Torah Book
(25:48) Final Ruling: Bringing In With You
(27:55) Airport Scenario & Practical Cases
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Visit: westdealshul.org
Sponsorships: [email protected]