In this episode of Weirder After Dark, it’s time for Whispers After Dark: 2 Tales, 1 Lie! We’re diving into two chilling listener-submitted stories and one deviously crafted lie (props to our imagination!). Cathy shares a goosebump-inducing ghost story and two cryptid encounters that will leave you questioning everything. Meanwhile, Chris, Sean, and our listeners try to uncover the truth. Can you figure out which stories are real and which ones are fake?

Join the fun, and let us know how you did! Share your guesses and thoughts on Instagram, Reddit, or Facebook—search @weirderafterdark.

Have your own creepy New England tale? We’d love to hear it! Email us at [email protected] , and you may be featured in a future episode.