Who Decides?

Who Decides?

By Roland MonséguGovernment
Download on the App Store

All Who Decides? episodes

  • Ep. 3 – Admiral Byng: shot to encourage the others?

    On 14 March 1757, Admiral John Byng knelt on the deck of HMS Monarch, dropped a white handkerchief, and was shot by a firing squad of marines. He was not a traitor. The court that tried him cleared him of cowardice. He was shot for not doing his "utmost".


    Last week, the Children's Hospital: nobody decided, and nobody paid. This week, the opposite extreme: one man paid for everybody.


    Roland Monsegu tells the story of the loss of Minorca in 1756: a fleet sent too weak and too late, an indecisive battle, a government under pressure, and a report edited to make the admiral look like a coward. Then the court martial, where the judges sentenced Byng to death and, in the same breath, asked for mercy, because the rule left them no choice. And a King who said no.


    Voltaire summed it up in Candide: in this country, it is good to kill an admiral from time to time, to encourage the others.


    So who decided? And what does fair accountability look like: the right person, a consequence that fits, and judgement left with people, not rules?


    Next episode: the Brexit referendum. When everybody decides, who owns the decision?


    📖 The End of Decision by Roland Monsegu is on Amazon in Kindle and paperback.

    💬 Have a question for Season 2? Find me on LinkedIn: Roland Monsegu.

    11 min
  • Ep. 2 – The Children's Hospital: who decided?

    In 2016, an Irish minister said the new National Children's Hospital would be finished by 2020, "short of an asteroid hitting the planet." No asteroid came. In November 2026, the hospital is still not open, and nobody can say when it will be.


    In this episode, Roland Monsegu tests the argument of his book, The End of Decision, on one real case: the National Children's Hospital in Dublin.


    We follow the story from the first calls for a single children's hospital in 1993, through the site at the Mater turned down by An Bord Pleanála, the switch to St James's, a cost that grew from €650 million to over €2.2 billion, and a completion date the contractor moved nineteen times.


    Every step followed the proper process. There were reports, reviews, approvals and hearings. So why can nobody say who is responsible? And who paid the price: the decision-makers, or the taxpayers, the staff and a whole generation of sick children?


    Finally, Roland asks what real judgement might have looked like: one named person with the power to act, and who could be removed if they got it wrong.


    Next episode: Admiral Byng, executed in 1757 for failing to win a battle. If we've gone from that to nobody paying anything at all, have we gone too far the other way?


    📖 The End of Decision by Roland Monsegu is on Amazon in Kindle and paperback.

    💬 Have a question for Season 2? Find me on LinkedIn: Roland Monsegu.

    11 min
  • Ep. 1 – The End of Decision: who decides, and who pays the price?

    In 2023, the Irish parliament spent €336,000 on a bicycle shelter. Who decided? Probably nobody – and that is the problem.

    In this first, solo episode, Roland Monsegu sets out the argument of his book The End of Decision: modern politics hasn't failed because of bad people or bad ideas, but because we replaced judgement with management. Decisions now pass through so many layers – a political mille-feuille – that nobody really decides, and nobody pays the price when things go wrong.

    With the National Children's Hospital in Dublin and the Lower Thames Crossing in England as examples, he explains the two kinds of checks we keep confusing, and why the answer is "fewer brakes on acting, strong brakes on staying".

    The book: The End of Decision – Why Modern Politics Replaced Judgement with Management, on Amazon in Kindle and paperback: https://amzn.eu/d/0gVXbjAG

    Disagree? Have a story about a decision nobody made? Find Roland Monsegu on LinkedIn.

    9 min