Whole Reason
Download on the App Store

Whole Reason episodes

  • How to misunderstand scripture: Matthew 19:16-26

    To download How to Misunderstand Scripture, please subscribe to the podcast feed.

    Here’s the complete sermon outline:
    A. Good Teacher

    The Mistake:  Jesus is denying his deity

    The Truth: Jesus is challenging the man’s idea of ‘good’

    The Problem: The man is a self-made success and now wants to excel in spiritual matters.

    B. Keep the commandments

    The Mistake:  Jesus is teaching that salvation comes through obeying the commandments

    The Truth:  Jesus is setting him up to see that no one does or can keep the commandments, hence the need for faith and obedience.

    C. Which Ones?

    What is happening here:

    1. This man is either a religious person who has been very observant, better than the people he knows, and wants praise for such.

    2. He is a good person who is impressed by his goodness, and is daring enough to believe that any commandment Jesus can name, he has kept well.

    3. Darker Motive:  He knows there are many commandments, and that no one can keep them all.  This intellectual and moral dilemma can be used as an excuse to not obey God.

    a. Dietrich Bonhoeffer – The Cost of Discipleship

    Once more the young man tries to evade the issue by posing a second question: “Which?”…Of course, he knows the commandments.  But who can know, out of the abundance of commandments, which apply to him in his present situation?  The revelation of the commandments is ambiguous, not clear, says the young man….He neglects the unmistakable command of God for the very interesting, but purely human concern of his own moral difficulties.

    His mistake lies not so much in his awareness of those difficulties, as in the attempt to play them off against the commandments of God…All his difficulties are shown to be ungodly, frivolous and the proof of sheer disobedience.

    We often use our moral and intellectual questions and difficulties as excuses to not obey the clear commandments of God.

    On Asking Questions

    1. We all wrestle with the harder questions of existence that challenge our faith in God.

    2. Asking questions is OK, but the problem comes when the answers are not what we would like, or hard to understand, or impossible to figure out.

    Honest questions and doubts are part of growing in faith, deepening our understanding.

    When we turn to blame God and use these difficulties as an excuse to reject God’s claim on our lives, we are on the wrong path.

    Why I left Christianity

    1. I had experienced a very narrow, controlling Christianity that I had to UNlearn.

    2. Some questions really bothered me, like

    – eternal hell, seems too harsh
    – what about ‘good’ people of other faiths or those who have never heard?

    I know what it is like to have hard questions, and you can’t play along anymore.

    Don’t use unanswered questions as an excuse to blame God.  Make sure that, even though you are asking questions, you are also LISTENING to what he is telling you.

    On Atheists

    NOTE:  I frequently listen to podcasts on Common Sense Atheism, where philosophers of religion are interviewed.  Many are ex-Christian atheists.

    While they often start out with good and meaningful questions, they eventually get caught in a cycle of rejecting God because of the intellectual difficulties that the Bible and obedience present.

    They get into this cycle of trying to UNDERSTAND what often goes beyond reason.  They BLAME God.

    SCRIPTURE:  Always learning, never coming to the knowledge of the truth (2 Tim 3:7)

    They should eventually say like Job:

    Job 42:1-6

    Then Job replied to the Lord:

    I know that you can do anything, and no one can stop you. You asked, “Who is this that questions my wisdom with such ignorance?” It is I – and I was talking about things I knew nothing about, things far too wonderful for me. You said, “Listen and I will speak! I have some questions for you, and you must answer them.” I had only heard about you before, but now I have seen you with my own eyes. I take back everything I said, and I sit in dust and ashes to show my repentance.

    QUOTE:

    “Now we see how the astronomical evidence supports the biblical view of the origin of the world….the essential elements in the astronomical and biblical accounts of Genesis are the same. Consider the enormousness of the problem : Science has proved that the universe exploded into being at a certain moment. It asks: ‘What cause produced this effect? Who or what put the matter or energy into the universe?’ And science cannot answer these questions.

    “For the scientist who has lived by his faith in the power of reason, the story ends like a bad dream. He has scaled the mountain of ignorance; he is about to conquer the highest peak; as he pulls himself over the final rock, he is greeted by a band of theologians who have been sitting there for centuries.”

    From God and the Astronomers (1978), by Robert Jastrow, (1925 – 2008) American astronomer, physicist  and cosmologist, Founding Director of NASA’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies in 1961, and served until his retirement from NASA in 1981.

    D. Jesus’ List of the Commandments
    1. You shall have no other gods before me
    2. You shall not make for yourself an idol
    3. You shall not make wrongful use of the name of your God
    4. Remember the Sabbath and keep it holy
    5. Honor your father and mother     
    6. You shall not murder
    7. You shall not commit adultery     
    8. You shall not steal
    9. You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor
    10. You shall not covet anything that belongs to your neighbor
    11. You shall love your neighbor as yourself.

      The Mistake:  The essence of all real spirituality boils down to loving others.  All the specifics about God don’t really matter that much.

      The Truth:  Jesus is again setting him up, knowing that the sins he left out are the ones in this young man’s way.

      – covetousness
      – does not love God, but rather, loves his own excellence

      Matt 22:35-40

      Then one of them, a lawyer, asked Him a question, testing Him, and saying, “Teacher, which is the great commandment in the law?” Jesus said to him, “‘You shall love the LORD your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.’ This is the first and great commandment. And the second is like it: ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ On these two commandments hang all the Law and the Prophets.”

      E. All these I have kept

      This was really a ‘good person’ compared to others.  But Jesus is about to actually answer his question.

      F. One thing you lack

      One thing you lack if you want to be perfect.  Sell all you have and give it to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven.

      The Mistake:  Jesus is teaching voluntary poverty as part of real faith and salvation.

      The Truth:  Jesus is asking him to give up his God of money and security.

      In the story of the Tax Collector Zaccheus, he tells Jesus that he will pay back four fold to anyone he has cheated.  Jesus does not make these same demands on Zaccheus.

      Another Mistake:  Jesus is telling him that if he adds this to what he is already doing, he will be keeping the commandments perfectly.

      The Truth:  Jesus is asking him to abandon his life of being a self-made, self-righteous, covetous person, and start fresh.  It is the life of FAITH and OBEDIENCE that he is lacking, and all of his efforts at building a self-styled spirituality that he can brag about must be replaced by simple obedience.

      G. Come and follow me

      This is what it means, in the Christian sense, to be spiritual, and to inherit eternal life.

      H. One last mistake

      We don’t see ourselves in the rich man, but everyone of us who lives in the west must consider the fact that we are rich and unwilling to follow Him aright.

      In other countries, people don’t have 401K’s and retirement accounts, nor even health care.  Yet we often fail to follow God because we are so focused on getting the big house, the Mercedes, the fat savings account.

      These things are not bad, but are they keeping you from doing what you believe or know God has asked you to do?

      This year, I lost both my house and most of my retirement savings.  This keeps me awake at night, esp. since I have debt.  Yet God is asking me, will you do my will rather than spend the next twenty years trying to get all that back?

      What has God asked of YOU?  Do you know?  If not, find out.  That’s where the real joy is.

      0 min
    12. Why no empirical test for God? Perhaps quantum science will provide it
      Atheists are full of good questions, one of which was recently broached at Common Sense Atheism in the post A question online theists refuse to answer? – that question is
      ‘Can you prove to me that God exists in a way that will also show that Zeus does not?’
      I initially responded by citing my series on Pascal’s Wager, explaining that, while there is no direct empirical evidence for the existence (or non-existence!) of God, there are plenty of other methods for showing a difference in the believability of the various Gods.
      One atheist responded that I had missed the point, writing:
      What you *really* want here is an experimental test. Show us this goddy thing, and let us fire protons at it.
      So let me take another stab at it – rather than giving him the sensible argument I gave (there is no empirical test, but that does not mean that we don’t have other methods by which to distinguish between metaphysical claims), I’ll try another valid one – that is, empirical science is not yet able to measure the spiritual – it can barely quantify, measure, or understand the psychological realm, so what makes us think we can evaluate the spiritual?

      Hubris abounds in metaphysical discussions – both sides calling the other idiots for what is patently obvious (God exists, god does not exist), and neither admitting the limits of their own reason, empirical methods, and experience.
      Atheists have a very good objection, however, to Christian faith and experience – how come you can’t measure it to show that it is more than imaginary?  Appealing to authority (“the Bible says so”) or to experience (“God is real because He changed my life”) are not really valid logical arguments.
      That does not mean that such claims are untrue, only that this is not really proof.  But I would like to suggest that empirical proof for God may be around the corner, and atheists need to suspend judgment.
      I’ll add that experiments that have seemed to show that prayer does not change things may be premature, and in and of themselves are not entirely damning or conclusive.

      Simple Science
      In the beginnings of science, very little of the actual mechanisms behind reality was known. And before instruments were invented to view objects far away, very small, or otherwise invisible to our senses, the existence of such things as galaxies, DNA, or cosmic rays was unknown, and even if postulated, was not confirmable with empirical science.
      But then the microscope was invented, and a host of other methods and instruments in physical science, driven by Newtonian physics and advances in chemistry and biology.  Suddenly a whole new realm of reality was available for empirical evaluation.
      The Relativity Revolution in Science
      Before Albert Einstein, the physical sciences were ruled by the Newtonian view of physics, and Kepler’s laws of planetary motion.   Unfortunately, they did not explain some of the empirical observations we were making.  As it turns out, gravitational effects, and the behavior of light were just not well enough understood, not to mention the implications when including the fourth dimension of time.
      However, Einsteinian theory led to many more discoveries and empirical methods that we could use to explore our reality.  And a whole new realm of reality was now understandable and quantifiable.
      The Quantum Revolution
      Quantum physics, however, is opening up yet another realm of reality.  One of the most interesting expermiments is the Double Slit Experiment,
      0 min
    13. Mark 12:41-44 – At the bottom

      Here is my sermon from 12/06/09 entitled At the Bottom.  Based on Mark 12:41-44, it covers these main points.

      1. Turn towards God, not away
      2. Do not worry
      3. God is doing something new
      4. Put God first
      5. Give what you have
      6. To download At the Bottom, please subscribe to our podcast feed.

        0 min
      7. Why are Jews predominantly liberal?
        One of the most annoying voices on conservative talk radio is Mark Levin, author of the bestselling Liberty and Tyranny: A Conservative Manifesto.  However, it’s all I’ve got some days, and once in a while, he has an interesting guest rather than the lowbrow callers that frequent the more rant-ridden types of shows.
        Today, he had Norman Podhoretz, author of the controversial new book Why Are Jews Liberals?
        You can listen to the 10 minute interview I’ve excerpted from the Levin archive (below). But the main interesting points I got from the interview were:

        * In the mid 19th century, it was liberalism that defended Judaism from the threats of fascism.
        * In 1967, a great shift occurred in American politics.  The left became increasingly anti-Zionist to the point of being anti-Semitic, while the right, esp. the Christian right, began seriously taking up the cause of Israel.
        * However, Jews did not become conservative because

        (a) Converting or turning to conservatism in Jewish culture is as objectionable as converting to Christianity, and most Jews abhor both.
        (b) Liberalism has replaced the values of the Torah for most Jews – where the two disagree, most Jews now side with liberalism and NOT the Torah.  That is, liberalism is now the predominant religious stance of most Jews.
        There’s much more great content in the interview, including Jews’ support for Obama.  Enjoy.
        0 min
      8. Analyzing the 6 C’s of Atheism – Part II

        This post is part of a series

        In Part I, I linked to August Berkshire’s Six C’s of Atheism interview, and discussed points 1-3.  Here’s the audio again, with my commentary on parts 4-6.

        Listen to: The 6 Cs of Atheism

        4. Contradiction-free

        Another benefit of atheism is that it is contradiction-free. We don’t have to try to reconcile an all-loving, all-seeing, all-powerful god with the existence of evil. We don’t have to define love exactly the opposite of how we normally define it in order to make it  applicable to a god. We don’t have to claim that a poor supernatural designer is intelligent.

        As if the atheist world view has no internal contradictions!  Note to ideologues – no world view is entirely contradiction free ;).  To name the most important atheist contradictions, let’s not forget:

        • the lack of foundation for objective morals (no authority outside of human reason = subjective morality) – As I and many others have argued, atheists believe in objective morality because it is real, even though their world view excludes it by definition.
        • the lack of reason to define it’s own limitations (see my short discussion of Emmanuel Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason in Pascal’s Wager – Part II: debunking the ‘all religions are equally improbable’ ruse)
        • proposing the origin of time/space out of nothing
        • non-material minds that allow rationality that would be impossible on materialism/determinism
        • the existence of free-will, when materialism demands chemical determinism
        • Unfortunately, Berkshire also uses the old ruse that “all people are atheists, atheists just believe in one less God.”  I will have to go into why this is a fallacious parlor trick, but essentially, it incorrectly assumes that the reasons that atheists use for rejecting the supernatural are the same or similar to those that Christians use to reject pagan myths.  This false assumption makes their analogy false.

          5. Courage

          Finally, an atheist possesses courage. It is natural for people to have a healthy survival instinct. However, some people have such a fear of death that they feel compelled to believe in an afterlife to alleviate those fears. It takes intellectual and emotional courage to abandon belief in an afterlife because there is no evidence for it (and compelling evidence against it). It also takes intellectual and emotional courage to abandon one’s belief in a cosmic, supernatural ‘protector’ and realize that,  as far as we know, we are alone in our universe and must therefore help each other as best we can.

          The assumption here is that theism is infantile wish fulfillment – people fear death, so they grasp for belief. The problem with this patronizing viewpoint is that some fears are warranted – there is such a thing as a healthy fear.  And while Berkshire may be right that many flock to religion in order to find comfort from their ills and fears, this does not invalidate the reality of God – this is the logical fallacy known as the Genetic Fallacy – saying that something is true or false based on someone’s motives or the origins of the idea.

          While it may take courage to be an atheist in the light of death, and in a Christian culture, it also takes courage to be a Christian in a fallen culture, or even moreso in Communist and Islamic cultures.  Does that therefore make it true?  Um, no.

          And if God does exist, then ‘fleeing to Him’ in times of trouble is intelligent, and not doing so is the idiotic thing!

          6. Conclusion

          One of the arguments of Pascal’s Wager is that a person loses nothing by believing in a god. I beg to differ. Accepting Pascal’s  Wager means saying that we are willing to abandon reason and evidence as our guides to living, and instead make a leap of faith to – where?

          OMG!  I hate such superficial misrepresentations of Pascal.  Please read my series on Pascal’s Wager.

          It’s true that by converting (or deconverting) from theism to atheism a person will lose his or her sense of divine specialness, cosmic meaning in life, and any hope of an afterlife. But you  can’t lose what you never really had.

          The reality of atheism far outweighs the dream of religion. There is an excitement and beauty to perceiving the world as it really is, and not as an illusion.

          In that point, we are agreed.  But if theism is true, than the illusion of atheism is an awful lie.

          In Part III, I will discuss the Seven C’s of the Christian View of History.

          29 min
        • Analyzing the 6 C’s of Atheism – Part I

          This post is part of a series

          Many of us Christians may be familiar with the “Seven C’s” overview of the Christian World View, but it seems that there is a Six C’s of Atheism, as August Berkshire, .  Berkshire also calls his list the ‘virtues’ of atheism.  After the jump, listen to him talk through the points.

          The 6 C’s of Atheism

          Listen to: The 6 Cs of Atheism

          Here’s Berkshire’s explanations:

          1. Conservative

          Yes, atheism is a conservative position. We accept statements only so far as there is reason and/or evidence to back them up. Anything else is speculation. We make no leaps of faith. If there should some day be a compelling reason or piece of evidence for a god, then we would acknowledge it and change our views. This is also known as intellectual honesty.

          Berkshire means that religion is a top down view (argument from revelation), while atheism is a ‘bottom up’ view – that is, atheists argue from the facts and reason on up.  The problem with this position is, though I agree with his use of the word ‘conservative’ here, he is basically arguing for a materialist, empiricist approach.  Not unreasonable, and from an intellectual point, defendable.  However, I think that such a position is conservative to a fault – almost to the point of being fearful.

          2. Clarity

          An atheist possesses clarity in his or her thinking processes. We are able to identify those things for which we have evidence and separate them from other things that are merely wishful thinking.

          This is merely an ad hominem attack on the use of faith and reason together.  It a priori discounts all faith positions, though ignores it’s own lack of faith position and materialist assumptions.  And besides, I’m right because I use Latin phrases in italics.  For a really good explanation of faith and reason, check out these links:

          • The Weslyan Quadrangle III – Scripture and Reason
          • ‘Reason is the Devil’s whore’
          • Faith and Reason – Link Dump
          • 3. Consistent

            An atheist is also consistent. We apply our skepticism equally to all supernatural claims. We do not say, ‘All prophets, saviors, or gods are false – except ours.’ We make no exceptions or special pleadings.

            The problem I’ve seen is a classic atheist error – he says somewhat rightly that people of various faiths are not skeptical of their own faith, but they are of others.  This may be true, but this has little bearing on whether or not theism is true, nor does it validate a blanket rejection of the supernatural.

            And the atheist is making an equally bad logical mistake – he finds all faiths equally implausible, failing to discriminate between supernatural claims.  This is, again, because he has rejected all faith claims that he can not validate with empiricism.

            What he has failed to do is to also use reason to reject the various faith claims – such as using historical and archaeological means of rejecting various faith claims, using rules of internal logic to reject faith claims, etc.  The Christian, who does not share the atheist’s blanket rejection of the supernatural, DOES use these latter tools to reject religious pretenders.

            As I argued in Pascal’s Wager – Part III: Evaluating the gods, you absolutely CAN eliminate pretenders with reason and logic, even if you can not, as the atheist would like, prove the affirmative existence of God – though you can provide reasonable evidence that is outside of bald empiricism.

            Anyway, listen to Berkshire and visit Part II for my continued analysis of points 4-6.

            29 min
          • Grocial Security

            To Paine and the boys at Shire Network News have prepared another superior podcast, continuing their mission to 'protect the Anglosphere through satire.'  I excerpted this short bit on the introduction of government-run grocery stores.  Awesome.

            Download Grocial Security (mp3)

            Grocial Security

            0 min
          • What is truth? John 18:28-38

            In this sermon, I examined Pilate’s exasperated exclamation, “What is truth?”  I discussed three serious objections to the existence of God from this passage, including:

            1. Religious hypocrisy
            2. Injustice and suffering
            3. Personal limitations and failure
            4. I apologize for the background noise, and the places where I had to dub in missing words – the original audio file had some dropouts.

              To download What is Truth? please subscribe to our podcast feed.

              0 min
            5. Christian Parenting – Part I

              This sermon, based on the example of God the Father in the Baptism of Jesus (), includes the following points:

              1. Acceptance: I know you
              2. Affection: I love you
              3. Approval: believe in you
              4. For you hardliners, don’t worry, I cover DISCIPLINE in the second part.

                To download Christian Parenting I, please subscribe to our podcast feed.

                0 min
              5. John 10: The Good Shepherd

                This sermon, delivered over the July 4th weekend, covers a portion of John 10, explaining the different characters in Jesus’ allegory of himself as ‘the Good Shepherd.’  It explores what a good pastor looks like, as well as describing the characteristics of a hireling, wolf, and the sheep.

                To download The Good Shepherd, please subscribe to our podcast feed.

                0 min