Ready to dive into creep city? Well, either way, you're here! Today, Komal takes us to Oklahoma to recount the Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders and Kelsey takes us to Ohio to tell us the story of  Circleville Letters mystery. Who ate the donuts? Why is everyone so obsessed with Mary? What do these have to do with the stories? Well, there is only one way to find out! Join us in discovering why on earth everyone is writing these creeeeeepy letters!