Why the Washington Commanders Stink

Why the Washington Commanders Stink

Download on the App Store

Why the Washington Commanders Stink episodes

  • Head Coach Already? Daronte Jones' Defense Is 22nd.

    A Washington fan site says defensive coordinator Daronte Jones is about to get head-coaching interviews. His defense is 22nd in the NFL in points allowed. It also has 14 takeaways in nine games, after 10 all of last season. So is he the real thing, or is the ball bouncing our way? Some of both. Missed tackles are cut in half, from 8.4 a game to 4.3. The last five opponents have averaged 20.2 points after the first four averaged 30.5. But we send five or more rushers the third most in the league and sit 28th in sack rate, and we have recovered 67% of opponent fumbles a year after recovering 11%. Then the question that worries a fan: if Dan Quinn goes, do we lose Jones too?

    In the episode
    0:00 Cold open
    0:34 Intro
    0:51 The claim
    2:10 Last year against this year
    4:58 Two seasons in one
    8:20 The last three
    9:15 Where he has been
    13:24 Quick break
    13:58 The Flores playbook
    18:03 Takeaways: coaching or luck?
    20:37 Where it still stinks
    21:49 The head-coach talk
    23:55 If Dan Quinn goes
    26:13 The verdict

    The receipts

    • The claim: "Daronte Jones' prime-time success puts Commanders on coaching carousel alert", Dean Jones, Riggo's Rag, 13 November 2026.
    • Nine games into each season, 2025 against 2026: points allowed per game 26.2 (24th) and 24.8 (22nd); yards per play 6.31 (30th) and 5.43 (18th); explosive plays per game 7.0 (27th) and 5.4 (14th); missed tackles per game 8.4 (30th) and 4.3 (8th); takeaways 6 and 14.
    • Rank of 32, last year to this year: yards per run 19th to 8th, third down allowed 24th to 15th, pass defense per dropback 29th to 22nd.
    • Games 1 to 4 (Eagles, Cowboys, Seahawks, Colts): 30.5 points allowed a game, 9.4 more than those offenses average against everyone else. Games 5 to 9 (Giants, 49ers, Eagles, Rams, Giants): 20.2 a game, 3.7 fewer.
    • The last four: 49ers 23 (they average 32.2), Eagles 10 (17.2), Rams 20 (25.3), Giants 21 (22.8).
    • Last three games: 17.0 points a game (7th), third down 12 of 41 (6th), red zone touchdowns on 6 of 12 trips (11th). First six games: 28.7 points (30th), red zone 20 of 24 (last).
    • Steve Wilks joined as a part-time game-planning assistant in mid-October. Daron Payne and Javon Kinlaw are on injured reserve.
    • Jones' Vikings pass defense in 2025: fewest completions of 20+ yards allowed (32), 2nd in passing yards allowed (178 a game), 2nd per dropback. Per dropback by season: 24th (2020), 24th (2022), 14th (2023), 4th (2024), 2nd (2025).
    • LSU, 2020 to 2021: points allowed 34.9 to 26.6 a game, total defense 124th to 64th, passing yards allowed 127th to 81st.
    • Five or more rushers: Washington 42% of dropbacks (3rd), up from 27% in 2025; Vikings 73% (1st). Pressure rate: Vikings 37.6% (1st), Washington 24.6% (16th). Sack rate: Vikings 12.0% (1st), Washington 4.8% (28th).
    • Blitzes through eight games: Frankie Luvu 40, Sonny Styles 38, K'Lavon Chaisson 22, Odafe Oweh 18, Nick Cross 11. 18 sacks in nine games, five in the Eagles win.
    • Over nine games Washington ranks 22nd when it sends five or more and 17th when it sends four. Thursday: 1 sack and 6 hits on 40 dropbacks; five or more rushers on 16; 3 of the Giants' 5 completions of 20+ yards came against it.
    • Takeaways through nine games: interceptions 5 (2025) and 6 (2026); fumbles recovered 1 and 8. Share of opponent fumbles recovered: 11% (last) in 2025, 67% (tied 2nd) in 2026; league average 47%. Minnesota 7 of 9, Washington 8 of 12, Indianapolis 4 of 6.
    • Still stinks, rank of 32: points allowed 22nd, expected points per play 21st, success rate 27th, red zone 27th (72% of trips end in touchdowns), second half 25th, fourth quarter of one-score games 22nd, sack rate 28th.
    • Head coach after one season calling a defense, by points allowed: Brandon Staley's 2020 Rams 1st, Steve Wilks' 2017 Panthers 11th, Vance Joseph's 2016 Dolphins 18th. Jones' 2026 Washington: 22nd through nine games.
    • Dan Quinn in Washington: 12-5 in 2024, 5-12 in 2025, 3-5-1 in 2026. Jones was hired on 30 January 2026.

    Sources: nflverse play-by-play, schedules and FTN charting (CC BY 4.0), each team's first nine games, through Week 10, 2026. Pressure, blitz and missed-tackle counts: Pro Football Reference charting via nflverse, through Week 9. LSU ranks: cfbstats.com. Quinn quote: Commanders Wire, 11 November 2026.

    More at wtwcs.com

    30 min
  • We Had a 7% Chance to Win. We Won.

    With two minutes left Thursday night Washington had a 7% chance to beat the Giants. By the win-probability model it is our least likely win since December 9, 2012. So did we win it, or did the Giants hand it to us? Both. The offense went 7 of 14 on third down after sitting last in the NFL at 31%, all three touchdowns came on third down, and we took four flags for 17 yards. The defense gave up 400 yards and nine big plays and held them to 21. Then came a 12-yard punt, a 33-yard flag and Stefon Diggs.

    In the episode
    0:00 Cold open
    0:29 Intro
    0:46 The question
    2:12 The 7%
    4:22 How it got won
    5:12 Quick break
    5:45 Third down
    8:14 The middle rounds
    9:44 Jayden Daniels
    10:42 The defense
    13:07 What it means

    The receipts

    • Washington's chance to win in the fourth quarter: 79% up 17-14 with 10:25 left, 30% after Isaiah Likely's 66-yard touchdown, 9% after the second interception, 7.4% with 2:00 left, 71% after Stefon Diggs scored with 0:57 left.
    • Least likely Washington win since 9 December 2012 against Baltimore (5.4%). Fourth-least likely since 1999, behind 2005 at Dallas (2.5%), 2001 against Carolina (2.6%) and that Baltimore game.
    • Across the league, 346 of 7,085 games since 1999 were won from 10% or lower in the fourth quarter, about 1 in 20. Seven this season.
    • The winning drive: 71 yards, 4 plays, 49 seconds. 33 of the 71 came on pass interference.
    • Third down: 7 of 14 Thursday; 31.1% in the first eight games; league average 38.9%. Average distance to go: 5.1 yards Thursday, 7.5 before.
    • Success rate: 56% Thursday against 41% in the first eight games; 60% against 42% on first and second down.
    • Flags: Washington 4 for 17 yards, the fewest of our season (7.6 for 58 in the other eight). Giants 6 for 62.
    • All three touchdowns came on third down. Third-and-1: 6 of 7. Third-and-4 or longer: 1 of 7.
    • Jayden Daniels: 23 of 33, 249 yards, 3 touchdowns, 2 interceptions. More than 200 passes this season before his first interception.
    • Antonio Williams played 59 of 69 snaps. Ben Sinnott caught all 4 targets for 42 yards and a touchdown. Diggs' touchdown was the 80th of his career.
    • Defense: 400 yards allowed, 6.35 a play, 9 explosive plays (5 in an average game before Thursday), 21 points, Giants 4 of 12 on third down, 2 takeaways.
    • J.J. McCarthy: 23 of 36, 293 yards. Isaiah Likely: 9 catches, 127 yards. Sonny Styles: 13 tackles on all 65 snaps. Rasul Douglas: 18 snaps and the interception that ended it.
    • NFC East: Giants 5-3-1, Dallas 4-5, Washington 3-5-1, Philadelphia 2-7. Next: Cincinnati at home, Monday 23 November.

    Sources: nflverse play-by-play, win probability, snap counts and schedules (CC BY 4.0), through Thursday of Week 10, 2026. Box score and career totals: ESPN.

    More at wtwcs.com

    15 min
  • We Can Draft the Middle Rounds. We Traded Them Away.

    I told my friends the Commanders stink because we can't draft in rounds 2 through 5. Then I checked. From 2021 to 2023 Washington turned 8 of 14 mid-round picks into starters, ninth in the NFL. So why are only four of them starting for us today, when Tampa Bay has 11 and Buffalo has 10? Because in the last two drafts we made four mid-round picks, the fewest in the league, after trading six of them for Marshon Lattimore, Laremy Tunsil and Deebo Samuel. Those three have played zero snaps for us this season.

    In the episode
    0:00 Cold open
    0:20 Intro
    0:37 The claim
    1:50 Big picture: 2021–2026
    3:19 What a middle class looks like
    4:07 Quick break
    4:43 Zoom in: 2021–2023
    5:31 The boards
    7:03 Where they went
    7:40 Where is the middle class?
    8:21 The last two drafts
    10:20 Where the picks went
    11:50 Are they any good?
    14:49 The depth
    16:00 More picks
    16:40 The verdict
    17:21 Being fair
    18:10 The way out

    The receipts

    • Rounds 2–5 picks, 2021–2026: Washington 25, league average 27.6, San Francisco 36.
    • Regulars this season from those picks: Washington 4 (27th), Tampa Bay 11, Buffalo 10.
    • 2021–2023 picks who became starters within three years: Washington 8 of 14 (9th); league 51%.
    • Rounds 2–5 picks in the 2025 and 2026 drafts: Washington 4 (32nd); league average 9.2.
    • Snaps this season from the 2025–2026 mid-round picks: Washington 644; league average 1,584.
    • Lattimore cost a third and a fourth (521 snaps in 2025, released March 2026). Tunsil cost a second, a third and a fourth (802 snaps in 2025, injured reserve). Samuel cost a fifth (713 snaps in 2025, now in San Francisco).
    • Opta: Sam Cosmi 5th of 102 interior linemen in pass blocking; Brandon Coleman 9th of 68 tackles in run blocking; Quan Martin 8th of 74 safeties in tackling and 70th of 76 in coverage; Antonio Williams 35th of 91 receivers in catching.

    Sources: nflverse draft picks and snap counts (CC BY 4.0), through Week 9, 2026. Opta data via Opta Analyst, read 12 November 2026. Trades: NFL.com. Lattimore's release: Pro Football Rumors. Tunsil's injury: CBS Sports.

    More at wtwcs.com

    20 min
  • Washington Is Dead Last at Finding Undrafted Players

    The Chiefs have an undrafted rookie starting at left tackle, so I checked how Washington does with the players nobody drafted. Since 2021 the undrafted rookies we signed have played 772 snaps for us. That is last in the NFL. The average team has 4,057 and the Rams have 8,982. You don't need undrafted players to win. You need them when you've traded your draft picks, and we traded ours.

    In the episode
    0:00 Cold open
    0:52 Intro
    1:10 The question
    2:28 Big picture: 2021–2026
    6:07 Quick break
    6:37 Our whole list
    8:15 The Chiefs
    10:05 Who is the best at this?
    12:28 Are they any good?
    15:03 The Chiefs' tackle
    16:18 Our undrafted veterans
    17:03 Does it win?
    17:43 The money
    19:28 The verdict

    The receipts

    • Undrafted rookies who made a roster or practice squad, 2021–2026: Washington 59 (27th), league average 73, Seattle 108.
    • Of those, players who took a snap for the team that signed them: Washington 15, league average 16.5, Tennessee 25.
    • Snaps from a team's own undrafted players, 2021–2026: Washington 772 (32nd), league average 4,057, LA Rams 8,982.
    • This season: Washington 111 (28th), league average 513, LA Rams 1,812, Seattle 1,581, Kansas City 1,127.
    • Own undrafted players with 100+ snaps this season: Washington 0, LA Rams 5, Kansas City 4.
    • Washington's list: Colson Yankoff 190, Jaret Patterson 184, Armani Rogers 158, Tyler Owens 66, Ricky Barber 47, Sammis Reyes 39, Brycen Tremayne 21.
    • Kansas City: Kahlil Benson 510 snaps at left tackle, every offensive snap in eight games. Christian Roland-Wallace 200, Mike Caliendo 146, Jack Cochrane 135.
    • Opta: Ja'Quan McMillian 3rd of 101 corners in coverage; Jaylen Warren 3rd of 29 backs in elusiveness and 6th in catching; Drake Thomas 6th of 75 linebackers in coverage; Jalen Coker 6th of 91 receivers in catching; Alaric Jackson 11th of 68 tackles in run blocking; Kahlil Benson 64th of 68 tackles in pass blocking and 65th in run blocking.
    • Washington's undrafted veterans this season: Jeremy Reaves 467 snaps, Frankie Luvu 386, Lucas Patrick 345, Shy Tuttle 209.
    • Buffalo has the best record since 2021 and is 23rd in snaps from its own undrafted players. San Francisco has the 4th-best record and is 30th.
    • The 2026 minimum salary for an undrafted rookie is $885,000, on a three-year contract.

    Sources: nflverse weekly rosters and snap counts (CC BY 4.0), through Week 9, 2026. Opta data via Opta Analyst, read 12 November 2026. Minimum salary: Stick to the Model, Legion Report.

    More at wtwcs.com

    23 min

About Why the Washington Commanders Stink

From the publisher's feed

One fan. One argument from the group chat. Settled with data. Two new episodes a week. Not affiliated with the Washington Commanders or the NFL.