Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share Why "Who Do You Know?" Still Crushes AI in Modern Recruiting with David Jaramillo on Shally's Alley
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
Why "Who Do You Know?" Still Crushes AI in Modern Recruiting with David Jaramillo on Shally's Alley
David Jaramillo brings fifteen years of cross-industry recruiting wisdom to challenge everything you think you know about modern talent acquisition. From hospitality to finance to tech startups, he's seen how the fundamentals of human connection consistently outperform the latest recruiting technology. His insights on referrals, metrics that mislead, and the dangerous trap of culture fit will make you question your entire approach.
In this episode we talk about transforming referral programs from afterthoughts into strategic powerhouses, why most executives obsess over meaningless metrics while missing what actually drives results, and the critical difference between hiring for culture fit versus culture add. David shares battle-tested frameworks for non-employee referrals, reveals which metrics actually mislead leadership teams, and explains when "people like us" thinking becomes toxic to innovation.
Key Takeaways
➡ 90% of referrals come from the same 5-10% of employees in most companies
➡ Non-employee referrals often outperform employee referrals because they have no vested interest
➡ Time-to-fill is fundamentally flawed because it varies wildly based on role complexity and external factors
➡ Applicant-to-interview ratios mislead executives who focus on efficiency over quality outcomes
➡ Companies depending on single sourcing channels face catastrophic risk when that channel disappears
➡ Culture fit hiring led to product stagnation when entire teams couldn't adapt to rapid development methods
➡ Gamification of referral programs with point systems increased quality while reducing quantity
➡ Dashboard metrics show real-time data for operators; scorecard metrics show strategic progress for executives
➡ The "big red bus theory" applies to sourcing: lose your main channel, lose your pipeline
➡ Hiring for tomorrow's growth requirements beats filling today's immediate seat needs
Chapters
00:00 - Intro and David's Background
02:47 - Why "Who Do You Know" Still Rules Recruiting
08:17 - Common Referral Mistakes Recruiters Make
12:30 - Reference Checks as Referral Goldmines
16:48 - Non-Employee Referral Strategies
24:32 - Metrics vs Meaning: What Misleads Executives
32:03 - Dashboard vs Scorecard Philosophy
41:04 - Culture Fit vs Culture Add Dilemma
52:27 - Who Should Be Our Next Guest
54:44 - Closing Question: Hire for Tomorrow
Sound Bites
"We're not hiring widgets. These aren't machines. We're hiring people, and people trust recommendations from people they know."
"Better to find out it's not working at three months than twelve months. Better now than later."
"Are we hiring for tomorrow's growth or just filling today's seats? That's the question that separates strategic recruiting from reactive seat-filling."
Guest Info
Name: David Jaramillo
Company: Canyon Rach (Talent Acquisition Leader)
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/davidjaramillo
Expertise one-liner: Cross-industry TA veteran who transforms referral programs and builds metrics frameworks that drive strategic hiring decisions across hospitality, finance, IT, and healthcare sectors.
View all episodes
By WRKdefined Podcast NetworkDavid Jaramillo brings fifteen years of cross-industry recruiting wisdom to challenge everything you think you know about modern talent acquisition. From hospitality to finance to tech startups, he's seen how the fundamentals of human connection consistently outperform the latest recruiting technology. His insights on referrals, metrics that mislead, and the dangerous trap of culture fit will make you question your entire approach.
In this episode we talk about transforming referral programs from afterthoughts into strategic powerhouses, why most executives obsess over meaningless metrics while missing what actually drives results, and the critical difference between hiring for culture fit versus culture add. David shares battle-tested frameworks for non-employee referrals, reveals which metrics actually mislead leadership teams, and explains when "people like us" thinking becomes toxic to innovation.
Key Takeaways
➡ 90% of referrals come from the same 5-10% of employees in most companies
➡ Non-employee referrals often outperform employee referrals because they have no vested interest
➡ Time-to-fill is fundamentally flawed because it varies wildly based on role complexity and external factors
➡ Applicant-to-interview ratios mislead executives who focus on efficiency over quality outcomes
➡ Companies depending on single sourcing channels face catastrophic risk when that channel disappears
➡ Culture fit hiring led to product stagnation when entire teams couldn't adapt to rapid development methods
➡ Gamification of referral programs with point systems increased quality while reducing quantity
➡ Dashboard metrics show real-time data for operators; scorecard metrics show strategic progress for executives
➡ The "big red bus theory" applies to sourcing: lose your main channel, lose your pipeline
➡ Hiring for tomorrow's growth requirements beats filling today's immediate seat needs
Chapters
00:00 - Intro and David's Background
02:47 - Why "Who Do You Know" Still Rules Recruiting
08:17 - Common Referral Mistakes Recruiters Make
12:30 - Reference Checks as Referral Goldmines
16:48 - Non-Employee Referral Strategies
24:32 - Metrics vs Meaning: What Misleads Executives
32:03 - Dashboard vs Scorecard Philosophy
41:04 - Culture Fit vs Culture Add Dilemma
52:27 - Who Should Be Our Next Guest
54:44 - Closing Question: Hire for Tomorrow
Sound Bites
"We're not hiring widgets. These aren't machines. We're hiring people, and people trust recommendations from people they know."
"Better to find out it's not working at three months than twelve months. Better now than later."
"Are we hiring for tomorrow's growth or just filling today's seats? That's the question that separates strategic recruiting from reactive seat-filling."
Guest Info
Name: David Jaramillo
Company: Canyon Rach (Talent Acquisition Leader)
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/davidjaramillo
Expertise one-liner: Cross-industry TA veteran who transforms referral programs and builds metrics frameworks that drive strategic hiring decisions across hospitality, finance, IT, and healthcare sectors.