
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


AI is making lazy marketing obvious. In this episode of Will AI Recommend You?, Simon Young is joined by creative director Andy Price to talk about AI slop, brand craft, and why consistency now decides whether answer engines recommend you.
They discuss:
- Why "just good enough" AI content fails with humans and with bots
- How Andy rebuilt the Question.marketing identity by briefing three models like a creative team
- Capital M versus small m, and other tiny inconsistencies that get you dropped
- The Daily Mail AI Overviews CTR story (see note below)
- Fan-out queries, being chosen versus being cited, and agentic sales
- Cleaning decades of brand history so models know the source of truth
- Digitising the knowledge only you have
Read the transcript: https://question.marketing/library/ai-slop-killing-brands-consistency-recommended-2026
Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-1pGHehW-M0
Notes on figures
Simon says the Daily Mail lost "80, 89%" of traffic. The published figure is an 89% desktop CTR drop (25.2% to 2.8%) when an AI Overview is present (DMG Media CMA submission, reported by The Telegraph). Digiday later reported an 80 to 90% CTR drop on affected queries, with overall traffic impact described as very low single digits. Prefer CTR language when you quote it.
Being cited by AI isn't the same as being chosen. Simon Young of Question.marketing talks with Pola Ariel of Stay Branded and Dr Jorge Raziel about how ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews decide which businesses to recommend.
Full transcript and show notes: https://question.marketing/library/will-ai-recommend-your-business-aeo-conversation
In this episode:
- Why a citation is the bibliography, not the recommendation
- The small inconsistencies that quietly knock you out
- A client result: 29 meetings in a month, 11 from AI search, from 20 visits (one unnamed client, as reported by Simon; figures quoted with permission; not a guarantee)
- Why AI-written content won't get you chosen
- Agentic commerce, and an AI agent that negotiated a hotel price
- Voice and local: when your customer just asks their phone
- What an AI visibility review shows
Notes on figures (audio can't show on-screen corrections):
- The 86% figure is from Peec AI's study of 500,000 business-focused prompts (April 2026), not all Google searches.
- The 15% figure is Google's, for daily searches it has never seen before (2023 data), not prompts typed into LLMs.
- The client figures are one unnamed client's results for one month, as reported by Simon, quoted with permission, not a guarantee.
- The "15 80% of new searches" line is garbled as spoken and is not a sourced figure.
- The "web searches down by 50% three months after first using ChatGPT" figure is unverified; we have not found a source for it.
- The "80 to 90 percent of businesses in the US" figure (20:22) is spoken by the guest; no source found, not a figure we have verified.
Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kS8FSBoZp6M
Find out what AI says about your business: https://question.marketing
Chapters
00:00 Search is changing: AI Overviews and fewer clicks
01:21 Agentic commerce and getting chosen
02:12 Cited vs recommended
03:13 The wild west and "hopium"
03:43 Third-party trust and consistency
06:11 The 9 to 12 month window
06:41 Local AI results and natural language
07:41 Why AI traffic converts: 20 visits, 11 meetings
09:27 Why AI-written blogs won't get you chosen
10:05 Your internal knowledge is what AI wants
11:41 How quickly results show
12:12 No guarantees: every AI surface is different
13:07 Maintenance still matters
15:01 The most exciting time in search
16:07 A third big shift in technology
17:11 Agentic commerce: the hotel negotiation
18:26 Agents that shop for you
20:00 What this means for small businesses
22:04 Hyper-local, personalised answers
23:32 Find the knowledge gaps
24:42 Matching the work to the business
25:24 "My business is all relationships"
27:01 Ask your phone: the driving instructor example
27:42 What an AI visibility review shows
29:18 How to get an AI visibility review
Read the full transcript: https://question.marketing/library/seo-isnt-dead-the-name-is
Watch the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LsdM0Bv2MFs
The name of the job has always followed the machine. Search engines gave us SEO and answer engines gave us AEO. Now AI agents shortlist, decide and often complete the booking. Agents don't search, they choose, so what do we call the job?
In this episode: the names in circulation (AEO, GEO, LLMO, AAO, AX), the cited, recommended, chosen ladder, five questions an agent asks about your business, the honest counterweight, and a test you can run today.
Notes on figures
- Research on whether ChatGPT reduces Google searches is split: one study (Lam et al., US panel, hosted by the FTC) found Google searches fell about 31% from 20 weeks after adoption; a Semrush study (Aug 2025) found no change.
- Research on AI referral conversion rates is also split: one study of 94 stores (Visibility Labs, 2025 data) found ChatGPT traffic converted 31% better than non-branded organic; a study of 973 sites (Marketing Science, 2026) found it converted 13% worse than organic.
- Pew Research (July 2025): clicks on 8% of visits with an AI summary vs 15% without.
Simon Young, Question.Marketing. https://question.marketing
Chapters: as YouTube pack.
Read the full transcript: https://question.marketing/library/which-ai-search-visibility-tools-2026
Disclosure: Simon ran this demo on Nimt's free trial. Question.Marketing has no paid or affiliate relationship with Nimt. Nimt saw this video before release and requested no changes.
Which tools track whether ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini, Google AI Mode and Copilot mention your brand, and can you trust the numbers?
In this episode Simon Young of Question.Marketing explains why tracking costs climb with every prompt, competitor and AI engine you add, why local results depend on where the tracking runs from, and why fan-out queries and different models give different answers. He then sets up Question.Marketing live in Nimt, looks at branded and general prompts, and explains why being recommended matters far more than being cited.
Watch the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d3Uo5sPj76k
Chapters
00:00 Which tools track whether AI cites your brand?
01:40 Questions that convert: cited, clicked or recommended
03:30 Why tracking prompts gets expensive
04:50 Local search: where your tracking runs from
06:16 Fan-out queries and different models
07:10 Semrush and Ahrefs Brand Radar
07:43 Setting up my own brand in Nimt
09:14 The prompts the tool suggests
11:35 Conversational search, not hundreds of pages
12:54 Competitors, and why the AI engines aren't competitors
14:00 Branded search: you should at least find yourself
16:02 Don't use AI to produce slop
16:33 Fill the knowledge gaps
18:01 Google's top 10 versus AI citations
18:33 NotebookLM video case studies
19:51 Results: branded prompts
21:38 South Yorkshire and Doncaster prompts
22:18 Can you outrank ChatGPT on ChatGPT?
23:03 Accountancy firms and long-tail prompts
24:49 E-commerce prompts
25:41 Cited versus recommended
28:02 Interpreting the data, and how to get help
Notes on figures as spoken
07:13 Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit is listed at $99 a month per domain, billed annually, on its pricing page (checked 14 October 2026).
18:07 The 13% figure is from Meikai's September 2026 study and is about ChatGPT, not Perplexity: 13% of the domains ChatGPT cited ranked in Google's organic top 10 for the same prompt. Meikai sells a brand monitoring tool.
19:07 Content reaching the top of Google within 48 to 72 hours is from Simon's own case studies, not a published study.
20:14 The 60% AI Mode figure for Question.Marketing is one run on one day for a branded prompt.
15:31 the free audit Simon mentions is a basic free audit for potential clients. Question.Marketing's full AI visibility audit is a paid service.
21:03 Question.Marketing launched at the end of June 2026. Simon says "three months" at 10:43 and "three, four months" at 20:58.
Key sources
Meikai study: https://www.meikai.ai/blog/seo-vs-ai-search-google-ranking-chatgpt-citations
Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit pricing: https://www.semrush.com/pricing/ai/
Nimt pricing: https://www.nimt.ai/pricing
Is Meta's Muse Charm a "surveillance Tamagotchi"? Simon Young of Question.Marketing asks whether we should worry about AI companions that live in our pockets, learn from our conversations and might one day sell to us.
He covers who owns the data you give these devices, whether Big Tech should pay us for it, what happens when your AI companion turns salesperson, the right to opt out, and why society may split over devices that record us. He also explains how he uses an AI recorder himself, and why he still encourages people to teach AI what only they know.
Chapters
00:00 The Meta Muse Charm: should we be afraid of it?
00:33 The surveillance Tamagotchi: you are the data
01:26 From Alexa and Siri to an AI assistant in your pocket
02:29 Keywords out, conversational search in
03:40 Where are we on privacy? Social media and how young people vote
05:06 Are we close to a privacy backlash? Glasses, Android and location data
06:55 A generation that has never known life offline
07:31 Should Big Tech pay us for our data?
08:49 When your AI companion becomes a salesperson
09:37 Devices that listen: Pocket, Claude, Grok and OpenAI's Dots
11:04 Do we have the right to opt out?
12:08 A split in society: people who refuse to be recorded
12:56 Can anyone control AI now?
13:32 Teach the AI what only you know
14:33 Should we be worried? Tell me in the comments
Notes on what is said
03:50 Simon says the 2016 UK general election. There wasn't one: 2016 was the EU referendum, and the general elections either side were in 2015 and 2017.
09:54 If you record calls or meetings with a device like Pocket, get everyone's consent first. Pocket notes that phone call transcription requires consent.
10:43 Simon says dots.com. The domain is dot.com: it is held by xAI and redirects to Grok, while dots.com belongs to a long-defunct company (TechCrunch, 29 Sep 2026). The $20 million price is unconfirmed.
11:05 The Charm is tap to talk. Zuckerberg: tap the fingerprint sensor in the corner and you can start talking (TechCrunch, 23 Sep 2026).
13:57 Teaching AI what you know is Simon's experience, not a guarantee of being cited.
On the record
Muse trains on your conversations by default and you can opt out in Muse settings (Meta): https://research.meta.ai/blog/security-and-safety-for-ai-agents-our-approach-with-muse
The Charm reveal (TechCrunch): https://techcrunch.com/2026/09/23/meta-made-a-tamagotchi-like-wearable-for-its-muse-ai-agent/
Watch the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wA5X8lJczdM
Full article, five signposts to watch and transcript: https://question.marketing/library/surveillance-tamagotchi-meta-muse-charm-ai-companions-privacy-2026
Previous episode on Muse Charm privacy (25 Sep): https://www.buzzsprout.com/2650282/episodes/19863615
Simon Young, Question.Marketing: https://question.marketing
Keywords are no longer the unit of search. The conversation is.
In this episode Simon Young of Question.Marketing explains how search has turned into a conversation. Google AI Mode, ChatGPT and Gemini take one long question, break it into many hidden searches, and write a single answer from what comes back. He covers what Google's People Also Ask box was telling us for a decade, two worked examples (a Doncaster accountant and a South Yorkshire recruitment agency), why a top 10 ranking is now closer to a raffle ticket, and a practical plan for this week.
Read the full article and transcript: https://question.marketing/library/stop-thinking-about-keywords-conversational-search-2026
Watch the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RgOnpI5vxHM
Chapters
00:00 Why stop thinking about keywords?
00:47 From typing keywords to asking questions
01:50 Why so many Google searches are brand new
03:01 What People Also Ask was telling us
04:41 Who writes the People Also Ask answers now?
07:27 Search is now a conversation
08:23 What is a fan-out query?
10:52 Fan-out examples: lawn care and headphones
11:57 Why your keyword tool misses the questions that matter
14:09 Why a top 10 ranking is now a raffle ticket
15:53 How fast is AI Mode growing?
18:10 Longer questions get the machine's answer
19:02 Ad money is following longer searches
20:05 UK searches are getting longer
20:47 How many follow-up questions do people ask?
22:36 Worked example: choosing a recruitment agency
25:44 Is this still just SEO?
28:18 Keywords are no longer the unit of search
28:35 What to do this week: start with questions
30:00 Use People Also Ask as a free map
30:45 One page per conversation
31:15 Say what only you know
32:23 Ask it the long way and check if AI names you
33:07 Sources and wrap-up
Notes on figures as spoken
01:25 Semrush's 23 words is for ChatGPT prompts without web search, against about 3 to 4 words for a Google search (2024 data).
03:41, 06:18 and 32:04 Google's 15% new-searches figure covers Google Search only, not AI platforms or the wider web.
10:57 Google's own lawn example lists herbicides, weeding without chemicals and weed prevention. Grass types and watering are my additions.
11:41 No study shows that queries with a date or statistics get cited more. That's my observation, not a published finding.
15:56 Google's billion is monthly active users of AI Mode, not searches.
27:31 AI referrals were about 1% of traffic on Conductor's 2025 US data and 0.14% on Semrush's 2026 data.
Key sources
Google 15% new searches (Search Engine Journal): https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-revisits-15-unseen-queries-statistic-in-context-of-ai-search/543160/
People Also Ask answers now AI Overviews (Brafton, AlsoAsked data): https://www.brafton.com/blog/seo/google-ai-overviews-are-taking-over-people-also-ask-heres-what-marketers-should-know/
Query fan-out in Google AI Mode (Search Engine Journal): https://www.searchenginejournal.com/query-fan-out-technique-in-ai-mode-new-details-from-google/552532/
Gemini 3 fan-out research (Seer Interactive): https://www.seerinteractive.com/insights/gemini-3-query-fan-outs-research
AI Overview citations from top 10 pages (Ahrefs via Search Engine Journal): https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-ai-overview-citations-from-top-ranking-pages-drop-sharply/568637/
Pew Research Center on AI summaries and clicks (The Decoder): https://the-decoder.com/pew-finds-that-only-1-percent-of-users-click-a-source-link-directly-from-googles-ai-overviews/
How AI Mode is changing search (Google): https://blog.google/products-and-platforms/products/search/ai-mode-us-insights/
Google's AI search guide and scaled content abuse (TechWyse): https://www.techwyse.com/news/ai-search/google-ai-search-guide-seo-geo-hacks
Semrush ChatGPT prompt length study: https://www.semrush.com/news/379285-new-semrush-study-reveals-chatgpt-search-trends-insights-from-80-million-clickstream-records/
Google Search Central guide to generative AI features: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/ai-optimization-guide
AI referral traffic benchmarks (Conductor): https://www.conductor.com/academy/aeo-geo-benchmarks-report/
Traffic channel mix study (Semrush): https://www.semrush.com/blog/traffic-channel-mix-study/
Peec, what is a query fan-out: https://docs.peec.ai/research/what-is-a-query-fanout
RealityMine, UK search behaviour: https://www.realitymine.com/articles/ai-powered-search-how-google-search-behavior-is-shifting
Question.Marketing: https://question.marketing
Simon Young on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/aeo/
I got voice search wrong in 2019. Not the destination. The timing.
People did not want to talk to a speaker in the corner for real search. Weather, timers, radio. That was about it. Smart speakers sold. Ownership is not voice search.
What has changed is the brain behind the microphone. In this episode I cite Google's own August 2026 figure that 63% of Gemini users talk to it, and Gemini past a billion monthly users. Treat those as on-camera cites until we check the primary. Google Assistant is off on Android as of 4 September 2026. Hey Google now means an LLM.
We walk through the recycled "50% voice by 2020" myth, why AEO has been the house category at Question.Marketing since 2019, five guesses I label as opinions, and why every major voice still reads the same web. Publish corroborated niche truth, or none of them will say your name.
Series: Will AI Recommend You?
Full transcript: https://question.marketing/library/voice-search-wrong-on-timing-aeo-2026
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JcbtIi04Sas
Should we be worried about our privacy now that Meta's Muse, and the Muse Charm device, are here? Simon Young of Question.Marketing has spent years targeting ads on Google and Meta. In this episode he talks about who owns the data, what "on by default" means, whether these devices should be anywhere near children, and why he thinks ads inside AI assistants will turn into sales agents that know your budget.
What is on the record:
- Meta hasn't said Muse Charm is always listening. The demo was tap-to-talk (TechCrunch, 23 Sep 2026).
- Muse uses your interactions to train Meta's AI by default. Meta calls that "a good default" in its Muse safety post (Meta, 8 Sep 2026, https://research.meta.ai/blog/security-and-safety-for-ai-agents-our-approach-with-muse; also quoted by Business Insider, 21 Sep 2026). You can switch it off in Muse under Settings, then Data controls (Meta Help Centre).
- Meta says Muse conversations aren't shared with its ad systems (Meta Newsroom, 8 Sep 2026).
- Muse is 18+ (Muse terms and the Apple App Store listing, via Daily Caller News Foundation, 10 Sep 2026). The UK's under-16 social media ban is expected to come into force in spring 2027 (GOV.UK, 15 Jun 2026).
- Muse has no UK launch date yet (as of 25 Sep 2026).
- Meta has launched camera-free Ray-Ban Meta Audio glasses alongside its camera models (The Verge, 24 Sep 2026).
- Instagram head Adam Mosseri said in October 2025 that Meta does not use the phone's microphone to eavesdrop on you (The Verge, 1 Oct 2025). That was a general statement, not about Muse. When Simon says his phone is listening, that is his personal view.
The sales agent scenario is Simon's prediction, not a Meta announcement.
Full transcript and receipts: https://question.marketing/library/muse-charm-privacy-should-we-be-worried-2026
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dC3vAfGNzXE
Would you want your voice built into a training model for an AI?
Chapters
00:00 Should we be worried about our privacy?
00:48 Muse, Muse Charm and the AI assistant race
01:39 Who owns our data?
02:07 Voice assistants and answer engines
02:54 Should these devices listen to children?
03:42 Living with an AI pocket device
05:05 Who's learning everything?
05:34 Influence, elections and social feeds
06:34 When AI assistants become sales agents
08:27 Opt out, not opt in
08:49 Is the phone listening? (Simon's view)
10:12 Controls for kids
10:35 A knowledge race
11:13 Your voice in a training model?
Question.Marketing: https://question.marketing/
Simon Young (Question.Marketing) shows live Google proof from a Stitch AI client knowledge-gap publish: bulk WhatsApp marketing and UK PECR / data-protection content.
On film: a Google Search result for the companion YouTube video showing 9 views · 4 days ago, and Google AI Overviews citing the Stitch blog and video. Queries shown include whatsapp PECR regulations in the uk and the long-tail bulk WhatsApp UK compliance question.
Edit note: this episode audio follows the jump-cut master (tangent ~3:00-10:30 removed; light typing scrub before the long-tail paste).
Soft / spoken-only (not title hard-claims): Simon also says on camera that the video went to the top of YouTube in about 20 minutes. Visual receipt locked for packaging remains Google SERP + AI Overview, not a YouTube.com ranking screenshot. 72 hours is not spoken on this film.
Full transcript: https://question.marketing/library/proof-seo-is-not-aeo-stitch-ai-9-views-ai-overview-2026
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mSAcQXXpxIM
Chapters
00:00 SEO is not AEO or GEO
03:00 Knowledge gaps and multi-property publish
10:01 Live Google proof
10:36 9 views on Google Search
11:54 AI Overview citation
14:31 Broader query: blog + video
14:56 What changes for AEO / GEO
Question.Marketing: https://question.marketing/
From the publisher's feed
Will AI recommend your business, or your competitor's? Will AI Recommend You? is the podcast about AEO (Answer Engine Optimisation): how UK businesses get named by ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews,…
Hosted by Simon Young, founder of Question.Marketing. Thirty years in search, and publishing on AEO since October 2019, 1,153 days before ChatGPT launched.
Each episode answers one question business owners are actually asking. What gets a company cited? What's just SEO with a new sticker on it? What do the numbers say, and where are they still small? Plain English, a receipt for every claim, and guests who have done the work.
Ask an AI about your industry today. Does your name come up?
Full transcripts and show notes at question.marketing.