Avoid the mirrors and grab the salt, this week we're tackling Bloody Mary! Brooke breaks down the episode's emotional depth, digging into themes of grief, guilt, and what makes a person feel responsible for death in the Supernatural universe. Ed dives into the folklore behind Bloody Mary, explores the mystical link between mirrors and souls, and unpacks just how many years of bad luck you're signing up for when you break one (and where that idea came from).

Join us on Patreon for bonus episodes, The Archive Addendum, bloopers, behind the scene content, and access to our Discord community! patreon.com/winchesterarchivespodcast

Have your own supernatural story? Send it to [email protected]

Socials: TikTok and Instagram: @winchesterarchivespod and YouTube: Winchester Archives Podcast

This week, we're boarding Flight 2485 and taking on Season 1, Episode 4: Phantom Traveler. Brooke dives into behind-the-scenes choices, character quirks, and how this episode helps shape early Dean and Sam. Ed unpacks the demon mythology, shares why this is one of his early favorites, and breaks down what makes this case a turning point in the series. Fasten your seatbelts, the lore is turbulent.

Join us on Patreon for bonus episodes, The Archive Addendum, bloopers, behind the scene content, and access to our Discord community! patreon.com/winchesterarchivespodcast

Have your own supernatural story? Send it to [email protected]

Socials: TikTok and Instagram: @winchesterarchivespod and YouTube: Winchester Archives Podcast

Put on your bathing suit and take a swim in Lake Manitoc, if you dare. This week we're in Wisconsin diving into S1 E3: Dead in the Water, where locals are vanishing without a trace and the lake may be hiding more than just fish.

Brooke breaks down the difference between standalone and mythology episodes, while Ed dives into haunted lake lore.

Join us on Patreon for bonus episodes, The Archive Addendum, bloopers, behind the scene content, and access to our Discord community! patreon.com/winchesterarchivespodcast

Have your own supernatural story? Send it to [email protected]

Socials: TikTok and Instagram: @winchesterarchivespod and YouTube: Winchester Archives Podcast

Grab your flare guns and M&M's - this week we're headed into the Colorado wilderness for Supernatural Season 1, Episode 2: Wendigo.

This week Brooke breaks down the visual storytelling, suspicious ID slips, and that emotional Winchester moment, while Ed dives into the lore behind the Wendigo and what makes this monster so smart and terrifying.

Join us on Patreon for bonus episodes, The Archive Addendum, bloopers, behind the scene content, and access to our Discord community! patreon.com/winchesterarchivespodcast

Have your own supernatural story? Send it to [email protected]

Socials: TikTok and Instagram: @winchesterarchivespod and YouTube: Winchester Archives Podcast

Welcome to the very first episode of The Winchester Archives: A Supernatural Podcast! In this deep dive into the series premiere, Brooke breaks down the scene-by-scene visual storytelling and continuity errors, while Ed explores the ghostly lore of the Woman in White. They also unpack behind-the-scenes trivia, all the crimes the Winchesters committed, and the emotional gut-punch that kicks off their journey.

Join us on Patreon for bonus episodes, The Archive Addendum, bloopers, behind the scene content, and access to our Discord community! patreon.com/winchesterarchivespodcast

Have your own supernatural story? Send it to [email protected]

Socials: TikTok and Instagram: @winchesterarchivespod and YouTube: Winchester Archives Podcast