This week, Jordan and Cara watch the 1996 Chris Farley and David Spade movie Black Sheep. They try their best to remember anything that happened in the movie and talk about the effect that 90s male comedians may have had on them.

On this week's episode, Jordan and Cara play a quick round of What Am I Chewing, then talk about what they're thankful for (and also Vermonter cosplay). Happy Chewsgiving!

On this week’s episode, Jordan and Cara revisit Dick, the 1999 alternate history comedy about the Watergate era of the Nixon administration. They talk about the perfection of Dick and its wonderful cast, its presidential portraiture, and get personal about nostalgia and learning to be their truest selves.

On this week’s What Am I Chewing? Cara has the most elaborate snack to date and Jordan eats another questionable breakfast food.

Jordan and Cara ring in political season with the aptly titled Election, the 1999 Alexander Payne film starring Reese Witherspoon and Matthew Broderick. They talk about unreliable narrators, how driven women are perceived, and their love of Tracy Flick.

On this week’s What Am I Chewing?, Jordan and Cara are joined by Brian Rodriguez of High School Slumber Party to guess What Am I Chewing?

Jordan and Cara are joined once again by High School Slumber Party’s Brian Rodriguez as they revisit the iconic high school witch movie The Craft. They discuss the enduring allure of these witches and the enduring allure of Skeet Ulrich, while Cara recaps some of the many horror movies she’s been watching in anticipation of Halloween.

Welcome to What Am I Chewing?, a very self-explanatory off-air game that Jordan and Cara like to play, now recorded for your listening pleasure. Play along as we eat snacks and try to guess what they are! It's harder and more fun than it sounds. Folks with misophonia beware: we are as unoffensive with our chewing as possible, but there are some mouth noises.

This week, Cara and Jordan dive into Halloween season with the early 90s classic Hocus Pocus and learn that it probably shouldn't be considered a classic. They discuss the movie's weird obsession with virginity, its problematic witches, and then take a long detour into current events.

On this week’s episode of Wistful Thinking, Jordan and Cara wrap up their musical series with the 1975 cult classic, The Rocky Horror Picture Show. Joined by CageClub co-founder and host of Third Time's A Charm, Mike Manzi, they do the time warp again and talk about revisiting this teenage rite of passage as adults in what is now a very different world.