Step into the chilling case of Lisa Straub and Johnny Clarke, a young couple tragically found murdered in their own Ohio home in January 2011. With their hands bound and bags over their heads, this crime shocked the community and left investigators grappling with crucial but fragmented evidence, including DNA traces from multiple suspects. Despite leads and lingering questions, this case remains with questions. With one suspect behind bars for a life sentence, the question arises were there others involved? New genetic geneologist now a part of the investigation, this case takes many turns! Join us as we dive deep into the mystery, exploring the haunting details, potential motives, and the quest for justice that continues to this day.