Episode #15: Murder! Mystery! Mayhem! It's the Halloween episode you've been waiting for - Nash & Tiff break down the truth & the fiction of a famous Halloween urban legend, tell some Halloween-related true crime cases, share how what you think you know about the origin of Halloween may not be correct, go over a variety of Halloween customs throughout history, & finish off with the story of a remarkable woman who started a festive Halloween trend. (Poisoned candy urban legend, the Trick-Or-Treat murder of Peter Fabiano, Ronald Clark O'Bryan the Candyman, Samhain, Halloween origins, Elizabeth Krebs) 

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |  

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |  

Mini-Episode #5: This Spooky Snack is a little different, because we aren't telling your stories - we're telling one of ours! Tiff gives the rundown on a festival she traveled to that’s all about Wisconsin wendigos, including the history of the event, the things she saw, & people she met. And Nash gives background on the creatures, plus debates going on her own Tennessee adventure. On top of that, there's some much-deserved shout-outs to other podcasts who are awesome. Let us know on our social medias if you like this kind of thing & want to see it come up again in the future! (Road Trip: Wisconsin Wendigo Festival)    

Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggestions for topics they'd like to hear us discuss, and sometimes things we want to talk about that aren’t long enough for a regular episode.    

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |   

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |   

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |   

Episode #14: Nash & Tiff break down the mystery, the history, plus the science behind some scary games people play. (Ouija boards, Bloody Mary)  

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |  

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |  

Mini-Episode #4:  Nash & Tiff talk rogue reptiles per a listener suggestion, then read a listener story that is definitely going to send shivers up your spine. (Listener Suggestion: the Crosswick Monster, and Listener Story: haunted house)   

Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggestions for topics they'd like to hear us discuss. 

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |  

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |  

Episode #13: This time, Nash & Tiff go over a couple of incidents that prompted people to get scared & panic on major scales - but perhaps things weren't exactly as they seemed. (Spring-Heeled Jack, The War Of The Worlds broadcast)  

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |   

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |   

Mini-Episode #3: Nash & Tiff share a follow-up on prison activities, address the many responses to the owl discussion, & read a listener's story about something they once stumbled upon whilst exploring their home. (Listener Story: a creepy basement discovery)     

Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggestions for topics they'd like to hear us discuss, and sometimes things we want to talk about that aren’t long enough for a regular episode.  

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |  

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |   

Episode #12: Nash & Tiff head back to the Civil War era & separate some truth from fiction surrounding spiritualism & a very special First Lady. (Mary Todd Lincoln, William Mumler) 

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |   

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |   

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |   

Mini-Episode #2 : Nash & Tiff explore Mansfield Reformatory, a.k.a. The Ohio State Reformatory, a.k.a. That Prison Where They Filmed Shawshank, a.k.a. This Place Is Haunted AF. (Listener Suggestion: Mansfield Reformatory/Ohio State Reformatory/Shawshank Prison)  

Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggestions for topics they'd like to hear us discuss, and sometimes things we want to talk about that aren’t long enough for a regular episode.    

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |  

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |  

Episode #11: It's back to school time, so what better way to celebrate than hearing Nash & Tiff discuss a haunted campus & some creepy kids? (Clyde A. Erwin High School poltergeists, the Green Children of Woolpit) 

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |  

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |  

Episode #10: Are you alone in the house? Nash & Tiff investigate what might be the cause of those bumps in the night. (Theodore Coneys, Dolly Oesterreich) 

| Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

| Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |  

| Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |  

| Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

| We want to hear your personal & local spooky tales! Email us: [email protected] |