By
Download on the App Store

episodes

  • September 24, 2017 - Soli Gratia from the Reformation series
    Scripture: MATTHEW 20:1-16 Well, one thing is clear: there’s no way I want that landowner as my boss! Are you kidding me?! Work all day in the heat, do everything a good worker should do, and then, when payday comes, you’re paid exactly the same as these slackers who show up at the end of the day? You’d think, after the latecomers are paid what you’ve been told you’ll get, that you’ll be paid a lot more. And you’re not. So what gives? A first-grader can see that this story isn’t even close to fair. And any worker worth having is going to leave for another job. Employee loyalty? Hardly. Not with that patently unfair management. So what are we to do with this story? We could just write it off as a mistake. Even Jesus, we suppose, might occasionally have missed the mark and laid an egg. Or maybe there’s something more than meets the eye here. Just maybe it’s not Jesus we should be doubting here, but rather ourselves. Maybe Jesus had something deeply right here and we’re invited to enter an odd and somewhat disturbing world. Fairness, of course, is a core value in our culture. If there are three cookies left and two children, we teach them that neither child is entitled to the entire third cookie. They each get one, and they can split the third, or give it to someone else. But neither gets to hog it. At work, too, we expect to be treated fairly. If one employee always shows up late or takes overly-long lunch breaks, we expect them to be reprimanded for it. If one team member does all the heavy lifting, it doesn’t seem right if everyone on the team gets exactly the same bonus or the same raise as the one who did the lion’s share of the work. We instinctively know if a parent has favored one of our siblings over us, or if a boss has given too much leeway to a colleague. And it irks us! Fairness is a great virtue. We rightfully prize it. The thing is, it’s not the only virtue. And it may not even be the central one. The story Jesus tells about the laborers in the vineyard wrenches us out of what we think we know and leads us down a different path. Fairness may be fine, but the story suggests there’s something else that matters even more. And that’s grace. “Grace” is a word that is central to Christian life, but also difficult to define. At our staff meeting this week, Mark Simone reminded us of a pithy phrase: “Grace is getting what you don’t deserve. Mercy is being spared what you do deserve.” That is, grace is a free gift, and mercy is a sort of forgiveness. That’s a clever and evocative distinction, but grace and mercy are really two sides of the same coin. They both represent God startling us with a surprise—overturning our expectations and giving us something that’s neither logical nor merited. Even if we can’t easily define grace, we know ungrace when we see it. It’s all around us. To watch the Ken Burns documentary on the Vietnam War, as Mary and I have been doing this week, is to see a scarcity of grace. There was certainly heroism and bravery in that war, but it is largely overwhelmed by the vying and hatred and destruction that were so prevalent there. I find the series both riveting and distressing. War is so often ungrace. Schools can be laboratories of ungrace, as well. They’re so often a competitive jungle of grades and athletic accomplishment and social standing....
    25 min
  • September 17, 2017 - Soli Deo Gloria from the Reformation Series
    Scripture: ROMANS 14:1-12; REFORMATION: SOLI DEO GLORIA During our church staff meeting on Wednesday morning, I reminded the staff that, in conjunction with our ongoing exploration of the themes of the Protestant Reformation, the theme of our worship this week was going to be God. To which one of our staff members wryly responded, “Isn’t that the theme every week?” And of course I had to give grudging consent! But I tell you, it’s one of my crosses to bear to work with colleagues who are exceedingly pithy and perceptive, but also impudent! She was right, of course. The theme of every worship service should properly be God. Or, if not the theme, at least the focus. We come here every week because of something different from us that is at the heart of life. We come because we want to know that there is something beyond us that grounds us and give us hope. We come to be reminded that there is a power that does not belong to us, a power of goodness and love. Despite how central the subject is, though, it’s a difficult one to talk about. No matter how hard we try, words fail and easy formulas elude us. The poet Mary Oliver has a prose poem called “The Word,” and it begins like this: “How wonderful! I speak of the soul and seven people rise from their chairs and leave the room, seven others lean forward to listen. I speak of the body, the spirit, the mockingbird, and the hollyhock, leaves opening in the rain, music, faith, angels seen at dusk—and seven more people leave the room and are seen running down the road. Seven more stay where they are but make murmurous disruptive sounds. Another seven hang their heads, feigning disinterest though their hearts are open, their hope is high that they will hear the word even again.” The thing I wonder over and over again is: why couldn’t things be clearer? Why must talk of God always be shrouded in a kind of mist? If God were a weather condition, I suspect it would be fog. What it always comes down to is that what we don’t know about God is breathtaking. The theologian Michael Jinkins quotes a friend of his as saying, “If you have understood, what you have understood is not God” (Called To Be Human: Letters to My Children on Living a Christian Life, p. 69). As we began talking about God at our staff meeting on Wednesday—and I have to say what a blessing it is for me to work as a part of a staff in which talking about God is par for the course—I said that what irks me about God is precisely this lack of clarity. If I could change one thing, I said, it would be that. It’s so odd to me that the things of God are not clear in the same way to everybody. I have strong convictions about who God is. The God I know in Jesus Christ wouldn’t stand for any notion of white supremacy; that God wouldn’t tolerate a world in which people of various sexual orientations and gender identities are shunned and disdained; that God becomes known to me in a book, the Bible, whose metaphor and poetry open up worlds of imagination and beauty and grace that can never be accessed by a flat and literal reading of those words and dreams. Why is it, I mused, that other people, equally ardently, worship a God who stands for just the opposite passions and values—people who think that God sanctions racial whiteness as somehow superior, that God condemns people for sexual and gender qualities that could not possibly...
    26 min
  • September 10, 2017 - Sola Ecclesia from the Reformation Series
    Scripture: MATTHEW 18:15-20 You may know the story about the little boy who was looking up at a plaque full of names on the wall of his church one day. The minister came by and looked up at it with him. When he asked her why these names were listed there, she said, “They’re the people from this church who died in the service.” Suddenly wide-eyed, he paused and said, “Which one? The 9:00 or the 11:00?” This is not what we want from the church! But, on a more serious note, what do we want from our church? In the last church I served, in Rhode Island, a woman came to me one day saying she wanted to join the church. As the conversation unfolded, she said to me, “It suddenly came to me one day that when I die I won’t have anyone to bury me. I need to be part of a community that cares for each other and that is there for each other until the day we die.” What we hope is that the church is there, not to kill us, but, as a family, to nurture life. Today we begin a series of worship services focused on the great themes of the Protestant Reformation. That Reformation came to a head on October 31, 1517 when Martin Luther nailed to the church door in Wittenberg, Germany, his 95 theses objecting to the ways of the Roman Church, the only church anyone in that part of the world knew. In the eyes of Luther and a number of his contemporaries, the church had come off the rails and it was crucial that it find its bearings again. And in the wake of those reformers’ efforts, we’ve all—Protestants and Catholics, fundamentalists and progressives, those with high, formal liturgy and those with low, free-church liturgy—we’ve all struggled with how we might best be the church and how we might discern the presence and the truth of God in this complex, challenging, fraught time in which we live. What the Reformation did was to re-center us. It recalibrated us and, like a good compass, pointed us once again to our true north. Because we’re coming, at the end of October, to the 500th anniversary of that pivotal moment, as worship leaders we thought we’d look this fall at some of what made the Reformation so distinctive and world-changing. First a caveat. For some here, it would be richly satisfying to explore in great historical detail what went on during that time 500 years ago. A careful retrospective about the events of the 16th century would be, for you, stimulating and rewarding—church history illuminating the past. For others of you, though, that sort of historical re-creation would be like a hot poker in the eye, the last thing you want to hear about in worship. So let me say that I am mindful of both perspectives. I want to be clear that we don’t come to worship simply to learn historical lessons. Harry Emerson Fosdick, a great preacher of the last century, once quipped that no one comes to church hoping to find out what happened to the ancient biblical tribe of the Hittites. Recognizing that, we will let the lion’s share of the historical details be explored elsewhere. At the same time, though, it’s also true to say, as the philosopher George Santayana once pithily put it, that “Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” So we will make reference to some of those long-ago events in hopes that they will shed light on who we are now and where we’re going. Historically, the Reformation had several notable...
    32 min
  • August 27, 2017 Rejoice & Renew Commitment Sunday
    Scripture: MATTHEW 16:13-20 On Wednesday evening, Mary and I went with some friends to the Indians-Red Sox baseball game. Not a good game. The Indians lost decisively. But we had great fun being there on a beautiful night. As it happened, it was Terry Francona bobble head doll night, and I had hoped to get my very first bobble head doll! Unfortunately, by the time we got there, they had all been distributed. An inning or two into the game, I suddenly realized, and said aloud, that I hadn’t actually seen a single doll. Just as I said that, I turned around and noticed a box which had a doll in it. The woman behind us heard me say that and she said, “Here, take this one. We have three and we certainly don’t need them all.” And she handed me one of her bobble heads. So, on a losing night, with friendship and a gift, a little grace came my way. Right there at Progressive Field. Progressive Field, the Q, and FirstEnergy Stadium are the site of special events here in Northeast Ohio. So are countless school athletic fields and auditoriums. And they’re remarkable facilities. They allow us to gather and share in a thrilling experience—well, not so thrilling on Wednesday evening, but generally an exciting event. And all these sporting events need a place for them to happen. There would be no games were there not fields and arenas in which they could be played. And for the experience to be a good one, those sites have to be maintained and freshened up regularly. The sites themselves matter. The same is true for the arts. Severance Hall is crucial for the Cleveland Orchestra, and the music is enhanced by the splendor of the architecture. The Cleveland Museum of Art provides a space for, and hugely complements, the art that hangs there. The museum atrium sets the stage for everything you see when you go there. These buildings matter. The same is true also for us as families. All of us have a home of some sort. It may be a big house in the suburbs, or an apartment in a retirement community, or a condo in a nearby neighborhood. We go home to kitchens and living rooms and dens and bedrooms and garages that make our lives easier and more fun. Our houses matter. And we accept all that as necessary in those areas of our lives. Not too many people would argue that we don’t need sporting arenas or arts venues or homes. Places to live and recreate and gather are fundamental to us. We prize them. And generally we work hard at keeping them up. And what of our churches? Strangely, there is sometimes a sentiment that church buildings are unimportant. Here’s what’s said: The real work of church happens outside its doors. The real work of church is to serve and make a difference. It’s frivolous, so goes this way of thinking, to put resources into a building when people are starving and hurting and dying. Let’s put as little as we can into the building, or even get rid of it, so we can put as much as we can into what’s said to be the real work of the church. And there is much to this way of thinking. A church that doesn’t have a strong sense of mission has lost its moorings. A church that sits around and gazes at its navel has foreclosed on living out the gospel mandate. A mere pretty palace would be but a soul-less shell. We dare never forget that we are sent to those who are hungry and displaced and aching, to be vessels of God’s love. This is central to what it means to follow...
    22 min
  • August 20, 2017 The Mercy of God
    Scripture: GENESIS 45:1-15 When my brother Tim and I were young—he’s two years younger than I am—we were not always the most lovey-dovey brothers you ever saw. In fact, my mother will say we fought all the time! I remember standing on our porch one day, my brother facing me, with a drinking glass in his hand, poised to throw it at me. I was petrified. He could tease me like nobody’s business. He knew just how to get under my skin—I guess that’s what younger siblings do to level the playing field. As adults we’ve had our moments, too. Some of you know that, when I was in my mid-twenties, my mother left her position as a local church pastor in Bangor, Maine, to move to an entirely new position with the UCC. This was at a time in my life when I had no idea what I was doing. When we arrived at the church on the day it was to celebrate my mother’s ministry there, the greeter at the door said to my brother, “Hi, Tim.” And then she turned to me and said, “You must be the other son.” Maybe it won’t surprise you if I tell you I felt totally erased. Later that day, Tim and I were moving a large piece of furniture in my parents’ house. As we move it through a door, it banged against the door jamb. I was infuriated, and blamed Tim. I pushed him up against a wall, whereupon he threw me back and said, “You don’t want to do that.” It was an ugly scene. It wasn’t until later that I made the connection between the morning snub I had received at church and my afternoon fury. But in any case, it shocked me how angry I could still get at my brother. And while nothing like that has happened since, and we love being together, I am always aware that virtually all relationships are tenuous. I suspect it wouldn’t have taken much for me to be convinced, that day, to sell my brother to anyone who might have wanted to buy him. Get him out of my life! So I get the story of Joseph and his brothers. I suspect many of us do. And even if you’ve never had a cross word with a sibling, maybe you know such an animus toward a neighbor or co-worker or parent or child or spouse. In many settings, relationships crash and burn. Jealousy, snubs, betrayal, political disagreements, financial distress, wildly opposing views on social issues: you name it, lots of forces undermine relationships and lead to estrangement. In my last church, I was sitting in a Deacons’ meeting one night as we debated a thorny issue that had raised hackles on all sides. A guest at the meeting, totally exasperated by my position, suddenly pointed his finger at me and yelled “I thought I could outlast you here, but I don’t think I can any more!” As you probably have, I’ve watched as good friends stopped speaking to each other, as apparently small slights turned into huge chasms, as parents and children have icily drawn their battle lines. We’ve all seen business partnerships dissolve and apparently good marriages come to a crashing halt. Sometimes we can see why it happens, and sometimes we just scratch our heads in bewilderment. So I get the story of Joseph and his brothers. I understand the desire to rid yourself of a nuisance, a thorn in the side. I can fathom that sort of breakdown in a relationship, and how easily and quickly things can go south. I suspect most of us can. And of course we see it culturally, as well. The demonstration and violence...
    28 min
  • June 18, 2017 - Is Anything Too Wonderful for God?
    Scripture: GENESIS 18:1-15 At the heart of this church’s life is our mission statement: God loves us just as we are, and too much to leave us that way. What a gift! What a blessing! No matter what we do, God loves us, and, at the same time, no matter how good we are, there is always more we can do. God loves us just the way we are, and too much to leave us that way. Very cool! Tom Long, though, a wonderful preaching teacher, says that that very image of the love of God is a metaphor that has lost its pep. It’s so over-used, he says, that it has little meaning any more. God loves all of us, all the time. And Long argues that when we hear that, we just figuratively tune out and go about our business, unchanged by what should be the center of our lives. God loves us? Big deal. I have groceries to get and a dog to feed and some prep to do for tomorrow’s work meeting. Tell me something I don’t know, something that will surprise me. The point, says Long, isn’t that God doesn’t love us. It’s just that the phrase has become so bland, so oft-repeated, that it’s lost its power. What we need to remember, he says, what we need to fully take in, is not just a bland, general notion of a kind of amorphous love, but rather a love that embraces me in my way, that holds me in my way, that directs me in my way. Love isn’t some general shapeless force, in other words. It’s a blanket that finds its way to wrap around me in particular. And you in particular. And every single person the world over in a particular and idiosyncratic way. Part of what makes the stories of the Hebrew Scriptures so riveting is that they make it plain that God’s love isn’t just general and shapeless. The love of God is a love that is geared to particular individuals and communities in their specific settings and challenges and needs. Just in the early chapters of the Bible’s very first book, God’s love blesses Adam and Eve after they have disobeyed God (Genesis 5:1). It blesses Cain after he kills his brother Abel (Genesis 4:15). It blesses Noah and his family, as well as all the animals of the earth, when the flood comes and the end seems imminent (Genesis 9:1). And then we come to today’s characters, Abraham and Sarah. The love that comes to them isn’t some formless affection. It’s a love that speaks to their special situation. It’s a love that graces them in their own distinctive way. God has made them a promise. And God comes through—for Sarah and Abraham, in their own unique situation. Abraham and Sarah have been told that they will beget a great nation, and that all the families of the earth will be blessed through them (12:2-3). But here’s the problem: Abraham’s 99 and Sarah’s 90, and all hope of bearing children is, of course, gone. Nobody bears children at that age, so God’s promise must have been “fake news”—a nice hope, but really no more than a pipedream. Pregnancy at 90? I don’t think so! So the two of them are hanging out in their tent one day. It’s a blistering day, not unlike the heat here this past week. And three strangers happen by. We who hear this story know this is God in human form (because the narrator tells us so), but Abraham doesn’t have the faintest idea that these are divine visitors. Abraham is as gracious as he can be with them, though, and, together with Sarah, issues their...
    28 min
  • June 4, 2017 Pentecost
    Scripture: ACTS 2:1-8 Some of the most exciting moments of my life have been at athletic events. When I was in high school, we had a fantastic swim team, and the whole school came out in support. One day, the team faced the best program in the league. We packed the stands. And we found ourselves down going into the last relay, the 4x100 freestyle relay. The winner of the relay would win the meet. As we entered the last leg of the relay, Bruce Goodwin, all six feet, seven inches of him, was behind by a body length. Slowly he inched up on the leader, and, at the last wall, he out-touched him, to win both the event and the meet. It was pandemonium. I don’t think I ever yelled as loud and as long as I did during that relay. And many other sporting moments have been as exciting. Joan Benoit Samuelson winning the inaugural women’s Olympic marathon in 1984. The U.S. women winning the soccer World Cup in 1999. I was at Yankee Stadium when David Cone pitched a perfect game for the Yankees in 1999. Rajai Davis’ game-tying eighth-inning home run in the seventh game of last year’s World Series produced bedlam in our house. Mary and I went berserk at the end of the seventh game of last year’s Cavs-Warriors playoff—a scream we hope against hope to duplicate this year! You who are sports fans will have your own to add to these. There’s a visceral elation in such events that is unsurpassed. But sports is not the only arena in which such excitement happens. I will never forget the thrill of our two sons being born. Nor the magic of my wedding to Mary. Singing and listening to music has moved me to my core. My ordination into the Christian ministry, complete with fireworks that the church set off afterwards, ranks right up there in the pantheon of my life’s exciting moments. Sometimes, when the day of Pentecost comes around each year, I wonder if I’m supposed to feel like that every day, or whenever I come to church, or whenever I pray. I’ve even occasionally wondered if there were something missing in our experience of church because not every moment feels like that. Should we have more spirit? Should life here be more exciting? Is there something we’re not doing that we should be? On the day of the first Pentecost, the disciples are all together in one room; there’s a sound like a gale-force wind; tongues of fire rest on each person there. “All of them,” says Luke, “were filled with the Holy Spirit” (Acts 2:4). It’s a story of such excited energy, such frenetic aliveness. And I sometimes wonder if that’s the way it’s supposed to be for us. Besides certain sporting events and various other high points, where do we sense the Spirit in our lives? Then I look more closely at the story of that first Pentecost, though, and I realize that the high point of the story isn’t really the gale-like sound. It’s not the strange image of fire lighting on each person. In fact, the high point isn’t really some emotional quality at all. No, the high point of the story, the story’s real core lies elsewhere. At the heart of the story Luke tells about the coming of the Spirit is this: that people are able to speak in languages other than their own, and they’re able to understand languages they’ve never ever heard before. As Eugene Peterson puts it, “Then they heard, one after another, their own mother tongues being...
    16 min
  • May 21, 2017
    JOHN 14:15-21 A great New Testament scholar of the last century, Krister Stendahl, a Swedish Lutheran bishop, developed what he called “The Ten Commandments for Biblical Preaching.” I’ve never been able to find the entire list, but I’ve heard a number of them, and they’ve stuck with me. One was that, as a preacher, you are not responsible for what you think you said; you are responsible for what you were heard to say. In other words, it doesn’t really matter what I think I said; if you don’t get it—if it’s not clear enough, not transparent in its meaning—then I have failed in my task. As a preacher, you’re not responsible for what you think you said; you are responsible for what you were heard to say. Another of Stendahl’s preaching commandments is never to use the word “love” in a sermon unless it’s been used in the passage of scripture from which you’re preaching. Stendahl’s point is that it’s too simplistic to reduce all of scripture, all of faith, to love. It’s sometimes tempting, as a preacher and as a person of faith, to get sloppy and to pretend that all of faith is contained in the word love. Love is certainly huge in our relationship with God, but there’s also hope and faith and trust and sin and mystery and sustenance and awe and forgiveness. Love doesn’t capture every nuance of a Christian’s relationship with God. Late in his life, Stendahl wrote an article about why he loved the Bible. It’s a radiant lauding of the richness and beauty of the Bible. Part of what entrances me about the article is Stendahl’s appreciation of the number and variety of witnesses to Jesus. In some circles of the church, historically, the diversity of witnesses has been a source of embarrassment: which story is true; why do the gospels diverge; how can we know what really happened? Stendahl says it’s precisely that diversity that conveys the richness of who Jesus was and is. From your angle, Jesus is different from mine. Through the eyes and heart of a Mexican farm-worker or a Wall Street banker or a cancer-stricken child, the way Jesus is seen is different. And that’s a good thing. Stendahl says that having four gospels is like having four portraits of someone you love. Each portrait shines a light on the person in a different way, and you see different aspects of the person. Just as with a person, so with the Bible and so with Jesus: there are multiple meanings rather than a single meaning. He goes on to say that there are at least three different symbol systems for Christian theology that come through in the gospels. And they have noticeably different emphases. The first is an emphasis on God as judge. The whole focus of this perspective is on judgment and sin and redemption and the cross. That’s an extremely familiar way of seeing Christian faith. If you grew up Roman Catholic or Lutheran, you will probably recognize this perspective: God as judge. A second take on faith is God as Lord. God is ruler and we are God’s subjects, and the world is full of covenants. That, says Stendahl, is the way John Calvin and the Jewish tradition tend to see things—Calvin being the direct ancestor of the United Church of Christ. This is the model that gave us the federal structure of the United States; foedus in Latin means covenant. This is the sociopolitical model of God—God as Lord....
    23 min
  • April 16, 2017 - Easter
    Scripture: MATTHEW 28:1-10 It’s an ordinary day, isn’t it. The sun came up beautifully. It will probably rain later. One couple woke up happy to be alive and in love. Another woke up still not speaking after a spat from hours, or days, before. Someone here was thrilled beyond belief at the treasures in their Easter basket. Someone else was disappointed that their Easter basket didn’t have their favorites. Yet someone else—or maybe it’s the same person—will throw a hissy fit this afternoon. Just an ordinary day. And what about that long-ago day? It, too, was an ordinary day, the day after the Sabbath. Not unlike a regular Monday morning for us. Life for the followers of Jesus had seemed to come to an end two days earlier. This man on whom they had bet everything had been put to death. And they themselves had behaved terribly. They had run from their leader. They had betrayed, denied, and abandoned him. And then he had died an ignominious death. What else could possibly go wrong? Get me out of here, they must have been thinking. This is a disaster. Then in the middle of that ordinary day, something happened. We don’t know exactly what. Despite our endless curiosity, the Bible doesn’t say. The gospels are absolutely silent on the matter. In today’s story from Matthew, for example, we get vivid details about an earthquake, a rock that’s moved, an angel announcing news. The two Marys are there and they talk with the angel. But not a single word about what happens to Jesus. Other ancient writings imagine in detail what might have happened to Jesus during the resurrection. But not the gospels. As tempting as it may be to know exactly how it all unfolded, those who assembled the Bible were wise, I think, to include only the extremely reticent descriptions we have in the gospels. Because there’s something about the spare accounts of scripture that rings true for that magnificent event at the core of our faith. A full and captivating story has led us to this decisive and riveting turning point. Some women who loved Jesus come to the place his body had been laid and they find his tomb empty. We don’t know what exactly happens between the time Jesus’ dead body is laid in the tomb and the time he comes back, alive, to the women who have been distraught at his loss. All we’re told is that “he has been raised” (Matthew 28:6). These grieving, yearning women then leave the tomb, and what happens immediately? They see Jesus again. And they run to tell others this astounding news. And it all happens on an ordinary day, in the middle of their home towns, as they prepare their meals and walk their dogs and build their homes—as they go about their daily lives, in other words. “Jesus . . . even now is going ahead of you to Galilee” (28:7). Galilee is the very place that they live. And it’s the place they’re sent to share the good news of what they themselves have experienced. Jesus will meet you where? Where you live, and where you share the blessing of God’s love with those you encounter. It’s astonishingly simple and ordinary. We may not know precisely what happened to Jesus. But we do know this: Jesus will meet you at home, and where you work, and where you serve. The heart of this story isn’t some showy, never-to-be-repeated tour-de-force on God’s part, a kind of Cecil B. DeMille miracle, as if to say:...
    18 min
  • April 9, 2017 Palm/Passion Sunday
    Scripture: MATTHEW 27:11-66 This is the God I want: I want God to do my every bidding. When, as a small child, I want to catch my brother and beat him to a pulp for so effectively teasing me, God should consider that a righteous and appropriate punishment. When, in grade school, I want a shiny new red bicycle, God should deliver. When, as a teenager, I want my friend’s stunning cousin Nan to find me attractive, God should make that happen. When, as an adult, I want professional success or a winning March Madness bracket or a sunshiny mood, it doesn’t seem too much to expect God to follow through on my every whim. If only God did my bidding, wouldn’t we all be happy, after all!? At the top of my wish list, I would certainly ensure that I never suffer, and that you don’t either. Any God worth worshiping should see the wisdom of my foolproof plan, it seems to me. If good things don’t happen and I can’t get what I want, what’s the point of faith? My guess is that many of us struggle with some variation of this problem: why doesn’t God do what I want, or, if I can’t get my every wish granted, at least make things better for the world? Families crumbling from betrayal and abuse, debt and bankruptcy ruining retirement plans, addictions to substances or gambling sucking the lifeblood out of homes and relationships: why can’t these be stopped? And that’s to say nothing of the death that surrounds us and will eventually claim us all. Horrifying images of Syrian children and adults suffering from nerve gas attacks sicken us and make understandable the response of President Trump. Losses in our own lives make us yearn for the return of someone we’ve adored. Fear of our own deaths can leave us short of breath and dry-mouthed. Can’t you change this stupid system, God? What’s the point? Evil, pain, unanswered prayer: sometimes it all seems too much, and faith a pie-in-the-sky dream. God? Really? Where? Show me! Which is precisely why Matthew and the other evangelists tell this odd and unsettling story about the death of Jesus. Everything in that story goes wrong. One of Jesus’ closest friends betrays him. Another denies knowing him at all, not once but three times in quick succession. The religious authorities are in a fury about him and want him put to death. As he hangs on a cross, he is mocked and goaded and spat upon. And finally he dies. And it doesn’t seem to make any sense. This isn’t what faith should do. Faith should make us wealthy and produce successful marriages and cure cancer. Faith should make things better. Faith should make us happy. It turns out it’s the professional clergy in the story, the scribes, elders and chief priests, who say so clearly just what we so often think. As Handel puts it in one of the lesser-known but brilliant choruses from Messiah: “He trusted in God that He would deliver Him; let him deliver him, if He delight in Him.” Or to put it in the vernacular, as Eugene Peterson does, “He saved others,” but “he can’t save himself! King of Israel, is he? Then let him get down from that cross. We’ll all become believers then!” (Matthew 27:42, The Message). We get this pointed challenge to God, don’t we? Let God deliver Jesus! Let God deliver us! We’re right with those goading clergy. What they have all wrong, though, those religious leaders, and where we...
    19 min