Scripture: LUKE 15:1-3, 11B-32 More than any other Bible story, I think, I am overwhelmed by this one. As a person and as a Christian, I so hope it’s true and I wonder how it possibly can be. As a preacher, I wonder how to make sense of it, how to approach it, how to let its depths unfold. There is something unbelievably grand and magnificent about it, something beyond my ability to grasp, something that so urgently needs to be said, and something, at the same time, that just doesn’t make any sense at all. We hope against hope that it’s true. And we wonder, at the same time, whether things really can be the way the story says they are. When I was in seminary, one Sunday morning a minister from Brooklyn, New York came to preach as a guest in the university chapel. His name was Gardner Taylor, and he preached that day on this parable. I don’t remember a single word or image he used. All I remember is the riveting cadences of his voice, and the fact that, as he preached, the tears just rolled down my cheeks. I may not remember the specifics of what he said. But I do know this. The Rev. Mr. Taylor certainly told the story that day of the young man who had sneered at and dismissed his father, who had blown the family fortune, who had shown an abhorrent lack of judgment and respect. He conveyed, I’m sure, that this young man didn’t deserve anything in the way of affection or care. The Rev. Mr. Taylor also conveyed, I’m sure, how terribly difficult it would be to love someone who had done that to us. Why would you love such a person? Why would you forgive such a person? Wouldn’t that just encourage him or her to do the same sort of thing again? Another great preacher named Fred Craddock says that forgiveness, in a scene like this, looks an awful lot like condoning. For the father to forgive may seem tantamount to saying, “What you did is fine.” And it isn’t. What the young man did is a travesty. And it should never be allowed to happen. The father should tell that young man: “What you did is a sin. It ruined this family, and it embarrassed me. And this is how you’re going to make it right.” No punishment? Are you kidding me?! No being forced to make amends? It’s ridiculous! And all of that is right. The younger son was a total ingrate. No one should be allowed to get away with what he did. And in a broader context, no society could possibly succeed if that’s the way we treated people who were that irresponsible, that selfish, that disreputable. There are innumerable reasons to object to what that father did. And yet, as the Rev. Mr. Taylor must surely have said that day in the chapel, something incredibly grace-filled is what actually happened between father and son. And for countless ones of us over the centuries who hear that story, there is something gorgeous and moving about it. While the son is off carousing, living a “dissolute” life—a word that, in the original Greek means, as Richard Lischer points out, “beyond saving” (Reading the Parables, p. 98)—his father sits on the front porch of their house, staring intently out at the road they live on, hoping against hope that his son will return. And when, one day, he sees that son coming, slumping in abject guilt, dreading this encounter with his father—when he sees his son coming, that father leaps off his chair and, counter to all social customs of the...