Supreme Court Oral Arguments

[22-277] Moody v. NetChoice, LLC


Listen Later

Moody v. NetChoice, LLC

Wikipedia · Justia · Docket · oyez.org

Argued on Feb 26, 2024.

Petitioner: Attorney General, State of Florida, et al.
Respondent: NetChoice, LLC, et al.

Advocates:

  • Henry C. Whitaker (for the Petitioners)
  • Paul D. Clement (for the Respondents)
  • Elizabeth B. Prelogar (for the United States, as amicus curiae, supporting the Respondents)
  • Facts of the case (from oyez.org)

    Social-media platforms collect third-party posts, including text, photos, and videos, and distribute them to other users. Importantly, they are private enterprises, not governmental entities, and thus are not subject to constitutional requirements for free speech. Users have no obligation to consume or contribute to the content on these platforms. And unlike traditional media, social-media platforms primarily host content created by individual users rather than the companies themselves (although they do engage in some speech of their own, such as publishing terms of service and community standards). They are not merely conduits of that content, however; they curate and edit the content that users see, which involves removing posts that violate community standards and prioritizing posts based on various factors.

    The State of Florida enacted S.B. 7072 to address what it perceives as bias and censorship by large social media platforms against conservative voices. The legislation imposes various restrictions and obligations on social media platforms, such as prohibiting the deplatforming of political candidates and requiring detailed disclosures about content moderation policies. It aims to treat social media platforms like common carriers and focuses on those platforms that either have annual gross revenues exceeding $100 million or at least 100 million monthly individual participants globally. Enforcement mechanisms include substantial fines and the option for civil suits.

    NetChoice and the Computer & Communications Industry Association (together, “NetChoice”)—are trade associations that represent internet and social-media companies like Facebook, Twitter, Google (which owns YouTube), and TikTok. They sued the Florida officials charged with enforcing S.B. 7072 under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging that the law's provisions (1) violate the social-media companies’ right to free speech under the First Amendment and (2) are preempted by federal law.

    The district court granted NetChoice’s motion for a preliminary injunction, concluding that the provisions of the Act that make platforms liable for removing or deprioritizing content are likely preempted by federal law, specifically 47 U.S.C. § 230(c)(2), and that the Act’s provisions infringe on platforms’ First Amendment rights by restricting their “editorial judgment.” The court applied strict scrutiny due to the Act's viewpoint-based purpose of defending conservative speech from perceived liberal bias in big tech. The court found that the Act does not survive strict scrutiny as it isn't narrowly tailored and doesn't serve a legitimate state interest. The State appealed, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed these conclusions.

    Question

    Do Florida S.B. 7072’s content-moderation restrictions comply with the First Amendment, and do the law’s individualized-explanation requirements comply with the First Amendment?

    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    Supreme Court Oral ArgumentsBy scotusstats.com

    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8

    4.8

    22 ratings


    More shows like Supreme Court Oral Arguments

    View all
    We the People by National Constitution Center

    We the People

    1,109 Listeners

    GLoP Culture by Ricochet

    GLoP Culture

    1,805 Listeners

    Amicus With Dahlia Lithwick | Law, justice, and the courts by Slate Podcasts

    Amicus With Dahlia Lithwick | Law, justice, and the courts

    3,488 Listeners

    U.S. Supreme Court Oral Arguments by Oyez

    U.S. Supreme Court Oral Arguments

    651 Listeners

    Cases and Controversies by Bloomberg Law

    Cases and Controversies

    153 Listeners

    The Remnant with Jonah Goldberg by The Dispatch

    The Remnant with Jonah Goldberg

    6,493 Listeners

    Strict Scrutiny by Crooked Media

    Strict Scrutiny

    5,672 Listeners

    Advisory Opinions by The Dispatch

    Advisory Opinions

    3,790 Listeners

    The Dispatch Podcast by The Dispatch

    The Dispatch Podcast

    3,214 Listeners

    The Ezra Klein Show by New York Times Opinion

    The Ezra Klein Show

    15,457 Listeners

    Amarica's Constitution by Akhil Reed Amar

    Amarica's Constitution

    372 Listeners

    Divided Argument by Will Baude, Dan Epps

    Divided Argument

    669 Listeners

    Honestly with Bari Weiss by The Free Press

    Honestly with Bari Weiss

    8,604 Listeners

    Shield of the Republic by The Bulwark

    Shield of the Republic

    463 Listeners

    Main Justice by MSNBC

    Main Justice

    7,031 Listeners