Supreme Court Oral Arguments

[22-381] Yegiazaryan v. Smagin


Listen Later

Yegiazaryan v. Smagin

Wikipedia · Justia (with opinion) · Docket · oyez.org

Argued on Apr 25, 2023.
Decided on Jun 22, 2023.

Petitioner: Ashot Yegiazaryan.
Respondent: Vitaly I. Smagin, et al. .

Advocates:

  • Vincent Levy (for the Petitioners)
  • Nicholas O. Kennedy (for the Respondents)
  • Facts of the case (from oyez.org)

    Vitaly Smagin, a Russian citizen who resides in Russia, sued Ashot Yegiazaryan, a Russian citizen who resides in California, and eleven other defendants, under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act. Smagin alleged that Yegiazaryan and the other defendants illegally attempted to avoid paying a judgment Smagin won against them in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California for engaging in a series of fraudulent transactions between 2003 and 2009 in to steal Smagin’s shares in a joint real estate investment in Moscow, Russia.

    The district court dismissed Smagin’s RICO claim, finding he did not suffer a domestic injury, which is a requirement for a RICO claim. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed and remanded, concluding that Smagin did allege a domestic injury.

    Question

    Does a foreign plaintiff with no alleged connection to the United States state a cognizable claim under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act when it suffers an injury to an intangible property?

    Conclusion

    A plaintiff alleges a “domestic injury” for purposes of filing a private civil suit under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, 18 U.S.C. § 1964(c), when the circumstances surrounding the injury indicate it arose in the United States. Justice Sonia Sotomayor authored the 6-3 majority opinion of the Court.

    The “domestic injury” requirement for private civil RICO suits comes from the Court’s decision in RJR Nabisco, Inc. v. European Community. However, the RJR Nabisco Court did not explicitly define a “domestic injury,” so the Court adopted a context-specific approach that considers the injury's circumstances—an approach consistent with that case. Applying this approach to Smagin’s case, the Court found his injury to be domestic. The majority of the alleged racketeering activities that prevented Smagin from collecting his judgment occurred in the U.S., targeting a California judgment. 

    Justice Samuel Alito authored a dissenting opinion, in which Justices Clarence Thomas, and Neil Gorsuch joined, arguing that the writ of certiorari should have been dismissed as improvidently granted.

    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    Supreme Court Oral ArgumentsBy scotusstats.com

    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8

    4.8

    22 ratings


    More shows like Supreme Court Oral Arguments

    View all
    We the People by National Constitution Center

    We the People

    1,107 Listeners

    GLoP Culture by Ricochet

    GLoP Culture

    1,801 Listeners

    Amicus With Dahlia Lithwick | Law, justice, and the courts by Slate Podcasts

    Amicus With Dahlia Lithwick | Law, justice, and the courts

    3,482 Listeners

    U.S. Supreme Court Oral Arguments by Oyez

    U.S. Supreme Court Oral Arguments

    652 Listeners

    Cases and Controversies by Bloomberg Law

    Cases and Controversies

    153 Listeners

    The Remnant with Jonah Goldberg by The Dispatch

    The Remnant with Jonah Goldberg

    6,492 Listeners

    Strict Scrutiny by Crooked Media

    Strict Scrutiny

    5,674 Listeners

    Advisory Opinions by The Dispatch

    Advisory Opinions

    3,790 Listeners

    The Dispatch Podcast by The Dispatch

    The Dispatch Podcast

    3,218 Listeners

    The Ezra Klein Show by New York Times Opinion

    The Ezra Klein Show

    15,470 Listeners

    Amarica's Constitution by Akhil Reed Amar

    Amarica's Constitution

    372 Listeners

    Divided Argument by Will Baude, Dan Epps

    Divided Argument

    669 Listeners

    Honestly with Bari Weiss by The Free Press

    Honestly with Bari Weiss

    8,606 Listeners

    Shield of the Republic by The Bulwark

    Shield of the Republic

    463 Listeners

    Main Justice by MSNBC

    Main Justice

    7,031 Listeners