In this episode of The Niall Boylan Podcast, Niall is asking: Is wanting children a reason to leave your partner? A listener emailed in to share his heartbreaking dilemma—he loves his wife of four years but wants to leave her because she has made it clear she doesn’t want children. He’s torn between staying in a loving marriage or pursuing his lifelong dream of becoming a father.

Some callers think absolutely he’s right to leave. Wanting children isn’t a small issue—it’s a core life value. If his wife doesn’t want the same future, staying together will only cause pain and regret. They believe that love alone isn’t enough when your hopes for family life are fundamentally incompatible.

While other callers feel leaving over this is too extreme. They argue that relationships are built on compromise and that people can change. Some say he should be patient and focus on the love they share—perhaps there are other ways to build a fulfilling life together, such as fostering, adoption, or focusing on other shared dreams.

Niall reflects on the emotional weight of the discussion, acknowledging how difficult it is when love and life goals are at odds. He reminds listeners that no relationship is perfect and decisions like this require deep thought, open communication, and honesty—not just with your partner, but with yourself.