They said the lake was beautiful. They didn't mention the church steeple you could see through the water, or the bell that still rang at midnight, calling the drowned to one last service.
Deep in the water, out there in the center of the lake, is the church for the old settlement of Buffalo. The cold, still water has preserved it. Its stained glass is still colored, and the pews sit upright, seats for only the fish to rest their fins. Locals say that at midnight, the church bell tolls, its sound muffled as the ghosts of Buffalo call the parishioners back for one last Sunday at church [citation:2].
But the lake's alluring surface hides more than just a flooded town. The Lodge On Lake Lure, built in 1938, is said to be haunted by a presence that has been noted in rooms 2 and 4. In one room, the ghost plays pranks, while in the other, a figure has been seen walking through the room by guests [citation:2]. There is a famous event where a young girl, frustrated she never saw the ghost, wished for it to do something, only to have a glass of wine fly across the room and smash on the far wall by itself [citation:2]. This is a story of a beautiful place built on a sunken past, where the lure of the lake is just a trap for the unwary.