It’s time for our annual review of the highs and lows of a bunch of movies picked by a random number generator.  And it turns out that this system really paid off this year, bringing us a truly eclectic list of memorable, challenging, and occasionally delightful Criterion films.  But which of these select few will go home with a coveted Randy award?

If you’d like to watch ahead for next week’s film, we will be kicking off season 4 with Wim Wenders’ Buena Vista Social Club (1999).