On today’s phone-in show, Niall tackles a heartbreaking dilemma sent in by a listener. A woman has been keeping a secret for nearly a decade: her 9-year-old daughter is not biologically her husband’s child. After a heated breakup years ago, a one-night encounter led to a pregnancy. She later confirmed through a private DNA test that her husband is not the father—but she has never told him.

Now, she’s torn. Should she confess the truth, knowing it could shatter her marriage and family? Or should she take the secret to the grave to protect everyone involved?

Niall asks listeners to weigh in: what should she do—reveal the truth or keep silent?