We're talking about Minutes 51-52 of Muppet Treasure Island, in which Mr. Arrow takes a boat trip and everyone is sad about it. With special guest Katilyn Miller!

PLUS: Bald eagles can't swim! Another delightful Tim Curry moment! Does Long John really think Mr. Arrow is dead? We like Polly Lobster more than we thought! An important Star Trek question! And what's the movie where a couple smooches in the crashing waves?

Hosted by Anthony Strand & Ryan Roe

Guest Katilyn Miller

Produced & Edited by Ryan Roe

Logo by Morgan Davy