The Niall Boylan Podcast (They Told Me To Shut Up)

#599 Public Sector or Private Sector: Who’s the Laziest?


Listen Later

In today’s episode, Niall kicks off by talking about a tweet he recently put out stirring up debate on public-sector work and accountability:

“Reform UK say they want to encourage public-sector workers to report colleagues who aren’t ‘doing useful work’ or who aren’t productive.

Many people believe civil servants and public-sector workers have it easier and with strong job security and little risk of being fired, compared to the private sector.

So what do you think?

Would you report a lazy colleague to the boss?

And who really has it easier, the public sector or the private sector?

👉 Comments to WhatsApp 085 100 22 55”

Niall explores all sides of the argument, especially from an Irish perspective:

📌 What the tweet means — Why Reform UK’s suggestion has resonated and why it’s controversial, even outside the UK.

🇮🇪 Public-sector facts in Ireland — Ireland has around 408,000 people working in the public service, spanning health, education, civil service, justice, local authorities, and other agencies.

Wikipedia

💼 Job security vs accountability — Supporters of public-sector employment point out strong job protections and pensions, often arguing they help retain experienced staff. Critics say this can reduce incentives for performance.

📊 Public vs private sector workloads — Some argue public-sector roles are less pressured and secure, while others highlight that frontline public services (e.g., healthcare, education) are demanding and essential.

🤝 Work culture and reporting — Would you ever report a colleague for not pulling their weight, whether in a government department or a private company? What are the pros and cons of encouraging such reporting culture?

🧑‍💼 Economic context — With total employment in Ireland at nearly 2.8 million people, the public service represents a significant but not dominant share of the workforce.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Niall Boylan Podcast (They Told Me To Shut Up)By Niall Boylan

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

8 ratings


More shows like The Niall Boylan Podcast (They Told Me To Shut Up)

View all
Liveline by RTÉ Radio 1

Liveline

75 Listeners

The Last Word with Matt Cooper by Today FM

The Last Word with Matt Cooper

62 Listeners

The Pat Kenny Show by Newstalk

The Pat Kenny Show

59 Listeners

Opinions Matter with Adrian & Jeremy by GoLoud

Opinions Matter with Adrian & Jeremy

27 Listeners

The Hard Shoulder by Newstalk

The Hard Shoulder

11 Listeners

NIGHTTIME TALK WITH NIALL BOYLAN by Classic Hits

NIGHTTIME TALK WITH NIALL BOYLAN

11 Listeners

Today with David McCullagh by RTÉ Radio 1

Today with David McCullagh

37 Listeners

Crime World by Crime World

Crime World

255 Listeners

The Mario Rosenstock Podcast by Mario Rosenstock

The Mario Rosenstock Podcast

28 Listeners

The Indo Daily by Irish Independent

The Indo Daily

114 Listeners

Shattered Lives by Reach Ireland Podcasts

Shattered Lives

57 Listeners

Path to Power by Matt Cooper

Path to Power

31 Listeners

Ireland Crimes and Mysteries by GoLoud

Ireland Crimes and Mysteries

90 Listeners

Crime World Presents: Groomed by Sunday World

Crime World Presents: Groomed

33 Listeners