On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill solve a murder case that's been cold for nearly ninety years. When 19 year old Anna Cardile left her Pleasantville, New Jersey home on the evening of October 3rd, 1934, she didn't tell her family where she was going. The next time any of them saw her, it was to identify her body in a shallow, sandy grave. Police would follow every lead, collecting witness statements and evidence, but all was for naught. The crime would go cold, written off as another "American Tragedy." Listen now as Jen and Jill give voice to Anna and name her killer. Support Common Mystics on Patreon here: https://www.patreon.com/commonmystics and sign up for exclusive bonus content like the Detours from each episode.

*Please note that this episode contains discussion of murder, violence and sexual themes and may be triggering for sensitive audiences. Please take care while you listen.