A baby girl taken from her crib. A community in terror. And a defense rooted in pure hate.

In 1955, the horrific murder of 21-month-old Donna Sue Davis shattered the quiet town of Sioux City, Iowa. The case would become infamous not only for its unimaginable brutality—but for the defense strategy that followed. As public outrage soared, one suspect’s lawyer blamed a “homosexual panic,” twisting justice with a deeply prejudiced plea. Though no one was ever convicted, the case remains a haunting reflection of how queerness was criminalized—even when queerness had nothing to do with the crime.

This LGBTQ+ true crime podcast episode revisits a forgotten cold case that weaponized queer panic and left an entire town scarred, shedding light on the dark legal tactics used to distract from the truth.

Hosted by Jordi and Brad, Beers With Queers brings chilling crimes, queer stories, and twisted justice to light—all with a cold one in hand.Press play, grab a drink, and join us as we uncover the darkest corners of LGBTQ+ history.