He left the Amish faith—but took something far darker with him.There has only ever been one recorded serial killer who identified as Amish and that was a man named Eli Stutzman.

Eli Stutzman’s path from a closeted Amish youth to a suspected serial killer left a chilling trail across the American Midwest. He’s linked to multiple deaths, including that of his own child, and the clues he left behind only deepen the mystery. Queer identity, religion, and murder collide in this haunting true crime story.

This episode peels back the layers on a killer shaped by repression—and driven by something even darker.

Hosted by Jordi and Brad, Beers With Queers brings chilling crimes, queer stories, and twisted justice to light—all with a cold one in hand.

Press play, grab a drink, and join us as we uncover the darkest corners of LGBTQ+ history.