In this compelling episode of the Worldview Legacy podcast, Joel Settecase steps into the hot seat on the "Real Atheology, a Philosophy of Religion Podcast," hosted by Benjamin Blake Speed Watkins. The conversation centers around one of the most profound questions in moral philosophy: Does Objective Morality Require God?

Join Joel and Ben as they engage in a rigorous and respectful dialogue, exploring their contrasting views on the nature of morality and meta-ethics. Ben presents his case for ethical non-naturalism, arguing that objective moral values can exist independently of God. Joel counters by grounding moral truths in the very nature of God, asserting that without a divine being, objective morality lacks a coherent foundation.

Key Topics Covered:

The distinction between moral values and moral obligations.

Ethical non-naturalism vs. theistic moral realism.

The relationship between general and special revelation in understanding morality.

The coherence (or incoherence) of abstract moral propositions without a divine mind.

Joel’s challenge to atheism and the implications of God’s necessary existence for morality and knowledge.

The episode concludes with a thought-provoking challenge from Joel, inviting listeners to consider the Christian worldview and its robust answers to the moral questions that shape our lives.

🚀 Takeaways:

Gain a deeper understanding of the debate on objective morality.

Learn about different perspectives on the source of moral truths.

Explore the philosophical and theological implications of a godless morality vs. a theistic moral framework.

Don't miss this engaging episode that tackles one of the most debated questions in the philosophy of religion!

🔗 Resources Mentioned:

Real Atheology, a Philosophy of Religion Podcast: https://www.youtube.com/@UCQa6mPLOE2yuMCrDjRio_nA

The Think Institute website: https://thethink.institute

🎧 Listen to the full episode now!

----

Take your learning further with the Hammer & Anvil Society, our men's learning fellowship. Learn more at https://thethink.institute/society.

Chapters:

00:00 Introduction and Guest Introduction

01:58 Discussing Moral Philosophy

04:32 Christian Perspective on Moral Obligations

11:01 Epistemology and Abstract Entities

27:11 Exploring the Problem of the One and the Many

29:18 The Triune God and Metaphysical Mysteries

31:24 Philosophical Debates on God's Existence

44:19 Final Thoughts and Reflections