On this week’s Thumb War, we revisit the world of horny, doomed teens and ask the question: what if they were even dumber… and older?

Yes, it’s the legacy sequel to I Know What You Did Last Summer, and it’s back with the original cast, zero shame, and a whole lot of questionable decisions. We dive into why this movie exists, how it compares to Scream and Top Gun: Maverick, and whether legacy sequels are just nostalgia traps covered in blood (and denim).

Also:

Wicked looks incredible — even if the press tour made us want to eat glass

The Smashing Machine might break your heart and Dwayne Johnson

...and yes, we’re still mad about the soup-slurping Aronofsky trailer.

Join Our Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/c/isthisgood