The town of Lumberton, North Carolina experienced the unthinkable in 2017. Four women went missing within the span of a few months, three of whom turned up dead within close proximity to each other. Are they connected? Why hasn't this case made national headlines? Join us this week as we try to unravel what happened to Abby Patterson, Rhonda Jones, Kristin Bennett, and Megan Oxendine. 

On the first ever Criminally Basic Halloween special, we cover the tragic case of The DeFeo family murders and the haunting of Amityville.

Morgan Harrington, Hannah Graham, and an unnamed Jane Doe all got justice when killer and rapist Jesse Matthew Jr. was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. But what about the other missing and/or murdered women who could potentially be linked to him? Learn all about the three solved cases, as well as six unsolved cases, in this week's episode. 

On this weeks episode Hannah and Megan, discuss the disappearance of Shannon Matthew and the strange turn of events that followed.

Alexis Patterson was in first grade when she seemingly disappeared from her school's playground. Was it foul play? Or was it a runaway gone wrong? And, most importantly, how did a little kid slip through the cracks of the system meant to protect and educate her? 

This weeks episode Hannah and Megan, discuss the tragic murder of Nancy and Daniel Benoit, and the suicide of professional wrester Chris Benoit.

July 11th, 2006 began as a normal day for mother-daughter duo Mary and Susanna. Little did they know that the fateful hike they took that morning would lead to a double homicide that would remain unsolved to this day.