A Toast to Horror

Is Kathy Bate's Annie Wilkes one of the best villains ever?? Listen up and decide for yourself! This week we talk classic horror movie, Misery and wow does it still hold up. In this Rob Reiner/Stephen King classic, we're constantly at the edge of our seat with the suspense! Paired with a Dirty Bird cocktail.

Rate! Review! Follow!

Follow us on Instagram @toastyhorror

Check out our website toasttoromcoms.com

Email us at [email protected]

We are starting the new year off with a bang with Weapons! Check out the reason why Amy Madigan won Best Supporting Actress for Gladys, a character so evil, we wouldn't be surprised to see her pop up on top ten lists soon. This 2025 standout had plenty of jumpscares and a unique storyline that'll keep you guessing. Listen up as we discuss this new horror classic and how every single character is SO bad at stakeouts. Paired with a Vanishing Hour cocktail.

Rate! Review! Follow!

Follow us on Instagram @toastyhorror

Email us at [email protected]

Check out our website toasttoromcoms.com

Welcome to round two of our 2025 holiday specials! This week, we are discussing Christmas Bloody Christmas, which was a pleasant surprise. This little-known movie is unique, with great chemistry between the main characters. We loved this persistent FMC and her never-say-die attitude and really hope she has great insurance. We hotly debated who the real villain is in this movie--be sure to comment who you think it is!

Paired with a Bad Santa cocktail.

Rate! Review! Follow!

Follow us on instagram @toastyhorror

Check out our website toasttoromcoms.com

Email us at [email protected]

It's that special time of year where we try to rack our brains for a fun holiday special! This movie proved to be lackluster, but it's Christmas-y! This episode we talk about 2007's P2 and man, there were some choices made. From bad small talk to psychopaths to surprise gore, this movie is one weird choice after the next. You can always we tell we're not fans when we try to talk about anything but the movie. Paired with a P2 cocktail.

Rate! Review! Follow!

Follow us on Instagram @toastyhorror

Check out our website toasttoromcoms.com

Email us movie suggestions and cocktail suggestions at [email protected]

We've discussed some wild movies during our tenure as horror podcast hosts, but 1981's Possession takes the cake. This movie is unlike anything we've ever seen, and we could barely string a coherent plot out of it. Having said that, we could not look away from this movie and all the wtf moments in it. We confidently say this movie isn't for everyone, but everyone should watch it--even if it is to take a selfie toward the end to see what face you make when the climax hits. Paired with a Rocking Chair cocktail.

Rate! Review! Follow!

Follow us on Instagram @toastyhorror

Email us at [email protected]

Check out our website at toasttoromcoms.com

Welcome to A Toast to Horror: Crapshoot Edition. In the episode, much like the movie we discuss, what can go wrong will go wrong. We start off with sound quality issues and Allison forgets her notes, and everyone hates the movie. Listen to some polarizing opinions with some poor sound quality on The Monkey. This movie was lacking in everything, but imaginative deaths. Paired with a Drunken Monkey cocktail -- the drink is the best thing about this episode!

Rate (not based on this episode please)! Review (not based on this episode please)! Follow!

Check out our website toasttoromcoms.com

Follow us on Instagram @toastyhorror

Email us at [email protected]

For Devil's Night, we are releasing the OG Evil Dead. This is totally a childhood trauma movie, and one of us may be over it, while one of us is definitely not. Besides the multiple eye close-ups, the filming techniques hit, and here is where we disagree--the makeup is unsettling. We may not agree with every aspect of this movie, but there are 2 things we 100% do: Scott sucks and we totally would have survived this movie!

Rate! Review! Follow!

Check out our website toasttoromcoms.com

Email us at [email protected]

Follow us on Instagram @toastyhorror

Get your Halloween candy ready, and keep the jack-o-lanterns lit, because we are discussing Trick 'r Treat! This multi-story movie is quickly becoming a Halloween classic. It's a fun take on the different stages of Halloween people go through as they age, complete with cautionary tales. Listen up as we talk about how cute lil Sam is and how much we love when people get their comeuppance. Most importantly, make sure you show your Halloween spirit or Sam will get you!

Paired with a Magic Bus cocktail.

Rate! Review! Follow!

Follow us on Instagram @toastyhorror

Email us at [email protected]

Check out our website toasttoromcoms.com

Next up in our Halloween month is the 1980s classic, Poltergeist. Listeners, this is the OG Insidious with a better dad. Yes, we know that by current standards, the parents make mistakes, but hey, it was the 80s! It was completely normal to send your kid off in a taxi while standing on your porch waving goodbye! This movie has great scares and still holds up today - a true can't-miss horror movie! Paired with a Poltergeist Potion cocktail.

Rate! Review! Follow!

Email us at [email protected]

Follow us on Instagram @toastyhorror

Check out our website toasttoromcoms.com

Our Halloween posting spree continues with A24's Talk to Me. This movie begins with a bang, and the special effects are on point. This movie is chock full of creepy imagery, jump scares, and unfortunately for our main characters, awful decisions. But what do you expect? Their frontal lobes aren't developed! Listen up as we discuss just who the main villain is and why it's not good to listen to ghosts. Paired with a Little Brother cocktail.