Coffee and a Case Note

Abod v Kingston Finance [2019] NSWSC 242


Listen Later

So, when is your loan agreement void for uncertainty?  When are a contract's terms so vague that the Court can't find any real agreement between the parties?  The NSW Supreme Court  considered a loan agreement obliging the borrower to pay interest "at such times, for such periods and at such rate or rates as shall be determined by the lender from time to time": [6].  Generally, when confronted with a knotty term, Courts the Court will try to preserve the contract if possible: [9].  The term above put the "times" and "periods" when interest was to be paid - as well as the rate itself - completely in the control of the lender.  Seemingly: there's no interest unless the lender says so!  Despite this obscurity, the Court found (bearing in mind the agreement related to unsecured loans in a family trust context) the term was sufficiently certain to be enforceable: [14].  In coming to that conclusion the Court - in my respectful view, wisely - noted the likelihood that parties to a contract of this sort might "sit down with (their) accountant" to work out the interest payments on the basis of reasonableness.  We find, perhaps as always: accountants to the rescue!


Hope you get some value from this episode!

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Coffee and a Case NoteBy James d'Apice

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

2 ratings


More shows like Coffee and a Case Note

View all
Law Report by ABC

Law Report

25 Listeners

Hamish & Andy by LiSTNR

Hamish & Andy

1,119 Listeners

Conversations by ABC

Conversations

852 Listeners

All In The Mind by ABC

All In The Mind

795 Listeners

The Economy, Stupid by ABC

The Economy, Stupid

25 Listeners

Politics Now by ABC News

Politics Now

88 Listeners

If You're Listening by ABC

If You're Listening

322 Listeners

Unravel by ABC

Unravel

815 Listeners

Full Story by The Guardian

Full Story

172 Listeners

What's That Rash? by ABC

What's That Rash?

254 Listeners

The Front by The Australian

The Front

49 Listeners

How Do They Afford That? by Michael Thompson and Canna Campbell

How Do They Afford That?

7 Listeners

15 Minutes with the Boss by The Australian Financial Review

15 Minutes with the Boss

11 Listeners

The Fin by Australian Financial Review

The Fin

19 Listeners

The Case Of by ABC

The Case Of

272 Listeners