Ben Shapiro, whatever you might think about him, is extremely intelligent. I’ve seen him provide what on the surface seem like valid arguments that back up his political leanings.
I say that it’s surface level genius, because with a little deeper probing, the fallacy in many of his arguments are reasonably apparent.
In this short video pulled directly from his YouTube channel, Ben says that the San Fran Gay Mens Choir did a song that was all about how they were going to take away your children, that they were going to endoctrinate them. He goes on to say that the proof is in the lyrics. He then refers to the line “We will convert your children.”
Here’s that video:
https://youtube.com/shorts/x9Zl8JKXbp8?feature=share
His initial claim: “they were going to take away your children, that they were going to endoctrinate them” is, in my opinion, potentially misleading.
Let’s put aside Ben’s view on homosexuality for this. I have learned a little bit about his philosophy (I don’t agree with it, but no matter) so I think I know better why he is saying this. However, I want to keep this rather simple and since his views often evoke lots of emotion, I’d rather just stick with commentary on this one video.
Now why do I say this short video is potentially misleading?
- The lyrics he’s referring do in fact say that they will convert your children. But upon pulling up the full lyrics, it’s clear the context is such that by “convert”, they simply mean they will show them that there’s nothing to fear from gay people and thus convert to become gay-friendly.
- Ben does not disclose the full content of the lyrics but rather leaves it to the viewer to make their own conclusion based on his commentary and a few seconds of the song.
- It’s my opinion that this scenario fits the definition of misleading if the video was edited with the full context having been known. The reason why I said the phrase “potentially misleading”, is because the only person that knows if Ben’s words were absolutely misleading is not anyone probably ever watching this video.
Summary
It’s because of fear-motivated content like this one by Ben and his organization, that I could imagine some individuals are feeling emboldened to take certain intolerable and in some cases violent actions. {maybe show scenes from homophobic violence}. And since I believe in unconditional love for others, I not only disagree with Ben’s assessment of a society wide evil conversion of your children to homosexuality, but I think his organization is sensationalizing intolerance. I don’t typically watch videos with Ben Shapiro talking, but every so often they make their way into my YouTube recommendation queue and so I get exposed to some of his content. I certainly don’t agree with his logic on most things and especially on this topic. I will continue to preach love over fear, and inclusion and connectedness over separateness. And this short-video is a violation of that basic principle that I wish to hold.