In December 1982, 21-year-old waitress Debbie Carter was found brutally murdered inside her Ada, Oklahoma apartment, leaving behind a staged crime scene filled with cryptic messages written in ketchup and nail polish. For 11 long years, the small-town justice system focused its crosshairs on two innocent men—Ron Williamson, a mentally ill former baseball prospect sent to death row, and his friend Dennis Fritz, sentenced to life—based on junk hair science and jailhouse rumors. But as Ron sat just five days away from execution, revolutionary DNA testing shattered the prosecution's case, exposing that the star witness who sent them away was the actual killer walking free all along. Step inside this haunting true crime documentary to explore the terrifying blind spots of the justice system, the fight for exoneration, and the tragic 17-year delay in finding real justice for Debbie Carter.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.

On a cold March afternoon in 1959, 9-year-old Campfire Girl Candy Rogers stepped out of her Spokane home carrying seven small boxes of mints—and vanished into thin air, leaving a terrified community searching for answers. Sixteen days later, her body was found hidden under pine boughs in a remote quarry, launching a 62-year cold case hunt that claimed the lives of three searchers in a tragic helicopter crash and pointed at the wrong serial killer for four decades. Step inside this landmark true crime investigation to discover how a simple glass Mason jar sealed by an unknown 1959 detective preserved the vital DNA needed for modern genetic genealogists to finally unmask the true predator buried just yards away from his victim

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

On an April night in 2005, 25-year-old mother and former university soccer star Janet Abaroa was found stabbed to death inside her North Carolina home, while her 6-month-old infant slept unharmed in the next room. Her husband, Raven, claimed he returned home from a late-night soccer game to find an open front door and his wife shot by an unknown burglar—a story riddled with missing laptops, intact jewelry, and a newly taken $500,000 life insurance policy. For five years the case sat cold, until a relentless detective uncovered one tiny detail sitting right in front of them: Janet’s open contact lens case on the bathroom counter. Step inside this haunting true crime documentary to explore the groundbreaking forensic exhumation, a dramatic hung jury, and the frustrating plea deal that ultimately freed a killer

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

In November 1987, 18-year-old Tanya Van Cuylenborg and her 20-year-old boyfriend Jay Cook left Vancouver Island for a routine overnight trip to Seattle—only to vanish into the dark roads of the Pacific Northwest. Days later, their bodies were discovered 60 miles apart in two different Washington counties, bound with zip ties and brutally murdered in completely different ways, leaving behind a cold case that haunted two nations for over three decades. For 31 years, the killer lived as a complete ghost with no felony record or online presence—until a genetic genealogist uploaded a crime scene DNA profile to a public database and traced his family tree in just two hours. Step inside this historic true crime documentary to uncover how a discarded paper coffee cup, a landmark DNA trial, and a high-stakes Supreme Court battle finally brought justice to two grieving families

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.

On a quiet August night in 2016, 5-year-old Elena Erdle was tucked safely into bed with her favorite Elsa blanket in her small-town Watkins, Minnesota home. By morning, she was gone—along with her father's pickup truck and Zachary Anderson, a trusted friend and softball teammate sleeping under their roof who had no forced entry to overcome. A frantic statewide Amber Alert led investigators 90 miles north to a remote Cass County cabin, where K-9 units discovered the stolen truck tucked in a ravine and Anderson standing knee-deep in a swamp. Step inside this heartbreaking true crime documentary to uncover how a chilling past of unheeded warning signs, a frantic swamp search, and airtight forensic evidence brought down a predator and sentenced him to life without parole

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.

On a July morning in 1981, six-year-old Adam Walsh begged his mother to let him watch older boys play an Atari video game inside a crowded Sears store at the Hollywood Mall in Florida. In a matter of minutes, an untrained security guard ejected the boys through a back exit, casting young Adam into an unfamiliar parking lot where a predator was waiting. Two weeks later, a horrifying discovery in a remote drainage canal ignited one of the most frustrating, error-plagued murder investigations in American history, entangled in the conflicting confessions of drifter Ottis Toole and serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer. Step inside this landmark true crime investigation to uncover how a family's unimaginable tragedy shattered national complacency, birthed America's Most Wanted, and created a safety legacy that has saved over 360,000 missing children

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.

"Step inside two of the most heartbreaking and frustrating cold cases in American history that took decades for modern forensic science to finally solve. In 1989, 16-year-old Fawn Cox was brutally assaulted and murdered inside her own Kansas City bedroom while her family slept downstairs—unaware that the monster who snuck through her unlocked window was a relative who would sit at their dinner table for 31 years. Decades earlier in 1980, 18-year-old Michelle 'Missy' Jones vanished after a Fourth of July celebration, only to be found dead in a South Fontana citrus grove, leaving behind a 45-year mystery that baffled investigators. Discover how advanced genetic genealogy, preserved crime scene DNA, and the relentless determination of grieving families finally exposed two hidden predators who thought they had gotten away with murder.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

On a summer night in 1999, 17-year-old best friends J.B. Beasley and Tracy Howlett got lost in Ozark, Alabama, stopping at a gas station to call home and ask for directions. They never made it back; the next afternoon, their abandoned car was discovered with both girls shot to death inside the trunk, leaving behind cash, jewelry, and a baffling crime scene. For two decades, the case went cold as false confessions and dead-end leads tormented their families, while the real killer lived just a mile away—preaching at a local church, raising a family, and walking free without a criminal record. Step inside this haunting true crime investigation to discover how a breakthrough in forensic genealogy finally unmasked local pastor Coley McCraney, ending a 24-year wait for justice.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

Between 1978 and 1983, quiet civil servant Dennis Nilsen preyed upon vulnerable young men and boys across London, luring them to his flats before committing a series of chilling murders and horrific acts of necrophilia. Known as the Muswell Hill Murderer, Nilsen evaded suspicion for years while concealing the remains of at least twelve victims right under his neighbors' noses. Step inside one of the most infamous dark chapters in British true crime history to discover how a blocked drain unveiled a monster, leading to a trial that shocked the world and put London's coldest predator behind bars for life.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

On a warm May evening in 1994, four-year-old Kali Anne Poulton rode her pink and white Big Wheel outside her Rochester, New York apartment, promising her mother she wouldn't leave the sidewalk. Within 20 minutes, Kali vanished without a trace, leaving behind an entire community in panic and a grieving mother whose instincts immediately pointed to a friendly 24-year-old neighbor named Mark Christie. For two agonizing years, Christie walked free—passing lie detector tests and even joining volunteer search parties—while hiding a horrific secret in a 30,000-gallon industrial water tank. Step inside this haunting true crime investigation to discover how a detective's quiet persistence, a marital confession, and decades-late DNA breakthroughs ultimately brought a hidden serial predator to justice

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/after-the-crime--6599771/support.