AI-generated music, AI-written poetry, AI-produced images — the tools are everywhere, and Christians are asking whether any of it counts as real art. Michael and Wade argue that art is not just pattern or product but transmission — something passes from a human soul through a medium to another human soul — and that AI, by definition, cannot transmit what it does not have. They work through listener questions, the Tolkien sub-creator framework, and practical guidance for how to engage with AI art without losing the ability to recognize the real thing.

[00:11]  Intro — Speechify and AI voice tools

[07:08]  Listener question — is AI art moral?

[10:02]  Art as transmission between souls

[11:03]  The bucket analogy — creator to audience

[15:05]  Hard case — AI music from the Psalms

[17:00]  Aaron's garments — God prizes human craft

[22:12]  Antique Roadshow — why human origin matters

[25:01]  Image of God and sub-creation

[27:03]  Tolkien — man as sub-creator

[31:01]  The medical exception — AI tools that heal

[32:02]  Core concern — AI atrophies creative capacity

[40:04]  Pilgrim's Progress — art through human voice

[48:00]  Inspiration requires a human; AI cannot originate

[55:02]  Mutiny on the Bounty — bittersweetness only humans transmit

[62:00]  Can you consume AI art? Yes, with care

[66:05]  More algorithm, less received

[68:13]  Guitar pedal analogy — AI as tool, not artist

[70:08]  Closing — use AI with caution

For questions or comments, send us an email at [email protected].

Our church is Christ the King Church in Ft. Thomas, KY

The Current Reality Podcast is a resource of King's Domain

Resources mentioned in this episode

• Text of “On Fairy Stories” by J.R.R. Tolkien

  
  

 Follow us on Twitter

https://twitter.com/dmichaelclary

https://twitter.com/wadethomasjr

Michael's Book "God's Good Design" is now available everywhere

• God's Good Design: A Biblical, Theological, and Practical Guide to Human Sexuality

Follow Michael’s writings 

• www.dmichaelclary.com