Story #1 - Lady streaked at an 8th grade football practice

Story #2 - Guy was left alone in a patrol car and stole it

Story #3 - Couple was arrested for assaulting each other with spaghetti 

Does 'Less history, more mystery' apply to concert set lists? Where the heck is the line between 'Your money to do what you want' and 'Probably ought to be responsible'? AJ & McCall are a little stuck in the middle of one listener's email. McCall is not paid by any nose strip company, but the time has come for her to make the pitch for the rest of America to get on board. Is AJ just paranoid or do guys not coordinate on proposal stuff? After none of his friend group talked to each other about getting an engagement ring, none will likely talk about their window of proposing. Also, how do you manage the relationship siblings for the Debate At 8? We maybe found a slight hang up in the 'driving a stick shift is attractive' plea.

Is it just AJ's friends, or do guys not really communicate with each other about proposal stuff? First, several friends in the group looked/bough engagement rings without consulting each other and now there's the possible proposing around the same window. McCall says it's no big deal. What do you do with relationship siblings? How do you go about dealing with and possibly being friends with them?

Story #1 - Guy filed 745 tax returns in 45 years

Story #2 - Waffle House waitress pulled a gun on a guy for complaining about his eggs

Story #3 - Lady was arrested for using bad checks to purchase $50,000 in postage stamps

AJ is hoping Ajay will support him on his annual case to move Halloween. How can states in middle of country have shark attacks?! Is the ability to drive a stick shift an attractive trait? Apparently it needs to be on your dating profile and resumes. TikTok trends can not be fun for teachers, but everyone did stupid stuff in school. AJ confesses to a lot to start Cache Valley Secrets before someone says they love short guys and how do you not notice the bottom of your wife's foot for 10 years?! Venting helps for the Debate At 8. How do three guys that are close friends not talk to each other about buying engagement rings?

TikTok has some...interesting challenges that have arisen and are definitely going to get kids in trouble at school. That's not to say Ajay and especially AJ didn't do dumb things in school. Family scared Ajay but AJ took things, 'vandalized' and took quite the tour of the school. Cache Valley Secrets collectively clear the conscious but why does AJ get a talking to at all the weddings he goes to and HOW do you not notice the bottom of your wife's foot after 10 years?

Story #1 - Man caught stealing needs to buy meth to see his imaginary girlfriend

Story #2 - Woman attacks man with an axe, but then he marries her to keep her out of jail

Story #3 - On neighborhood has a 20 foot knife built there and now needs to take it down

It has been confirmed AJ is the DUMBEST person on the planet and Ajay is mad it cost him a day off. How adventurous are AJ and Ajay? Would they take a random flight if it was cheap? Always important as well, how far is too far to road trip? How do you respond to the statement "Having reverse is just a luxury." There's no denying that houses expensive, but a work around has made itself known. Would you buy a house with friends? AJ and Ajay get into the conversation about being roommates and it doesn't go well for the Debate At 8. Ajay was kind enough to share his nickname 'Crasher' story so he gets to rag on Park Narcs.

The housing market is outrageous but apparently a work around has made itself known, pooling money with your friends and buying a house. Now, AJ and Ajay get a house, but they have to do it together. Would they get along? AJ talks about some of his roommate experiences and Ajay has no doubt AJ would be the worst ever. Why? Would AJ and Ajay work together as roommates?

Story #1 - An official city wizard who has served for over 20 years was fired

Story #2 - A shoplifting man has steaks fall out of his pants and strips naked as he tries to get away

Story #3 - Three shoplifters were thwarted by a manual transmission, an MMA fighter and a K-9