Across the multiverse a dark entity has been murdering the avatars of holiday cheer. But luckily the elite operatives known as the Cheer Squad are on the case. Join the sharpshooting granny with a grudge, Gam-Gam (Jasmine McFergus), cyberpunk elven technomancer from the darkest timeline, Dot (Sarah Lawrence), and Stan the munitions expert whose bombs and bald spot both sparkle with holiday menace (Jon Navarrete) as try to save Xmas in the Happiest Place on Earth.

Alejandro "deals" with Larry. Charlie goes to Delilah with questions, but the answers are not what she's expecting. Lenore is flummoxed by a new contact. And Jimmy finds information from an unexpected source.

Lenore, Charlie, Jimmy and Ochos regroup and compare notes. But one of the group is not like the others. Lenore goes hunting for her "cat," and Ochos discovers a shocking truth about his lost week.

Hunt 2 begins with a bang as Lenore, Alejandro, and Charlie awake to startling revelations and more than a few questions. Meanwhile, Jimmy is alone and in hot water. Will the Past Life Discoveries crew find out the truth about Charlie’s Well? What dark event must Ochos prevent from taking place? Will Jimmy ever get his phone back? And who mixed those darn margaritas anyway?

Life is hard when all that's left of civilization is confined to a town on the back of a giant manatee on a flooded world. Life is even harder when you're an anthropomorphic scavenger forced to live on humanity's trash. But Waffles the Goat Girl, Leonard the Half-Possum, Zeke the Foxkin, and Finkster the Ratboy have decided to crash the biggest human party on the manatee, John Carventer's Halloween Extravaganza Part XXIII.

Where did Jimmy get his magic coin? Why does Ochos know so much about monsters? How did Charlie end up in Texas? And when did Lenore become obsessed with the secrets of Hext? Let's flashback to our heroes' pasts to answer these questions and more.

The All My Hexes crew levels up their characters, discusses the campaign and answers questions after the completion of the first hunt.

All the clues lead the team back to Peg Leg Station to confront the creature. Alejandro reveals his secret identity to the group. Charlie plays with fire while Jimmy takes a swim. And Lenore finally gets some pie.

Jimmy's seeing things, but everyone sees the blood on the tracks. Trying to keep the rest of Past Life Discoveries away from the probably murder scene leads the gang to the hospital, and eventually...the morgue. What will they find lying on the slab? Or, who?

Strange happenings abound at Peg Leg Station. Can Lenore and Ochos escape before it consumes them? Meanwhile Charlie tries to unravel mysteries closer to home. And Jimmy gets volunteered for an unexpected side job.