Young mother Filomena Garay-Chavez is missing. It’s a long night for those in the house on State Road 29 in Immokalee, Florida.  Deputies are called out twice to investigate.

Early the next morning, Detective Kevin O’Neill takes the case. He outlines how the investigation begins and reviews the initial evidence gathered.

What evidence is left at the scene? Senior Crime Scene Investigator Alicia Craig analyzes the physical evidence in the case and elaborates on the challenges it poses for detectives.

In 2022, the cold case is turned over to Detective Derek Holden. He provides his insights on cold cases and discusses his perspective on where the Filomena Garay-Chavez case stands today.

Andrea Jones from the Collier County Sheriff’s Office recounts the details of a 15-year-old cold case concerning the murder of a women in a small Florida town.