Amy Allwine was living a pious and simple life in Minnesota. Her husband, Pastor Stephen Allwine, was leading a double life, frequenting the infamous website for cheating, Ashley Madison, along with other dark web activities including searching for a hitman against his wife. When the hitman failed, Stephen took matters into his own hands. Savannah explores what led to a self-proclaimed religious man would murder his wife and attempt to stage it as a suicide, how Stephen was caught, and the many sordid details of Stephen's life that Stephen was desperate to keep hidden.

Get 15% off your first Aurate purchase when you go to AurateNewYork.com/killer and use promo code killer at checkout!

Become a member today by going to Feals.com/killer and you'll get 50% off your first order with free shipping!

For 50% off your first Care/of order, go to TakeCareOf.com and enter code killer50!

If you have any thoughts on this case or any other case, or just want to get in touch with Savannah about the show, email her at [email protected]. 

Follow Savannah on IG: @savannahbrymer 

Follow Savannah on Twitter: @savannahbrymer  

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices