The rings are on, but the date isn't set. Today on Arguing Ever After, we’re debating the "forever engagement." Taking a page out of the Broadway classic Guys and Dolls, we ask: Are you living a real-life version of Miss Adelaide and Nathan Detroit’s 14-year stalemate?

Is a decade-long engagement a romantic choice or a massive red flag? We break down the psychology of the "permanent fiancé" and when it's time to finally "Sit Down, You're Rockin' the Boat."

Engage with us:

1. Vote in our Spotify poll: How many years is too many?

2. Follow for weekly relationship deep-dives.

3. Rate us 5 stars if you love the show!

4. Share this episode with your friends or (maybe) too long term fiancé.

Ever wondered what it’s actually like to live under the sea? In Episode 38, we’re diving deep into the ultimate aquatic debate: Dolphin vs. Octopus.

We break down the pros and cons of high-speed mammal life versus the genius, camouflaging world of the eight-armed cephalopod. Whether you’re team "Echolocation" or team "Ink Cloud," this episode explores marine biology with a hilarious twist.

In this episode, we discuss:

• The intelligence of bottlenose dolphins vs. giant Pacific octopuses.

• Which creature has the better "superpowers"?

• Our personal picks for an underwater reincarnation.

Cast your vote! Check our Spotify poll below to let us know which you’d rather be.

Love the show?⭐ Rate us 5 stars on Spotify.🔔 Follow so you never miss an episode.📲 Share this episode with a friend who loves the ocean!

Do you consider fish a culinary delight or a hard pass at the dinner table? In our (very first) 37th episode, we’re diving deep into the great swimming supper debate. From the delicate textures of fresh sushi to the meaty profile of grilled swordfish, we break down whether fish truly deserves the title of "the other (other) white meat."

Whether you’re a fish food friend or a denier, join us for a mix of culinary banter and hilarious antics that might just change how you view your next meal!

Top o’ the morning! In this festive 36th episode of Arguing Ever After, we’re diving into the luck of the Irish to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day. Whether you’re wearing green or just here for the history, join us as we explore how a religious feast day transformed into a massive global celebration.

In this episode, we discuss:

• The History of St. Patrick: Separating the myths from the legends of Ireland’s patron saint.

• A Global Celebration: How St. Paddy's Day is celebrated from Dublin to Chicago and beyond.

• The Ultimate Irish Folklore Debate: Which would you rather be—a mischievous leprechaun or a magical fairy?

We’re breaking down the traditions, the symbols, and our own personal takes on the holiday. Does the pot of gold outweigh the wings? You decide!

Join the Conversation:Don't forget to Listen, Vote, Rate, and Share! Your support helps our community grow. Subscribe on Spotify so you never miss a weekly debate.

#StPatricksDay #ArguingEverAfter #IrishFolklore #PodcastLife #HolidayTraditions #LeprechaunVsFairy #RelationshipDebates #StPaddysDay2026

Welcome back to Arguing Ever After! In Episode 35, we’re hopping into the time machine and heading to Ancient Greece. We’re breaking down our favorite legendary figures and pitting the world’s most famous monsters against its greatest heroes.

The Main Event: A "Battle of the Ages" featuring Medusa vs. Hercules. Can the strength of a demigod overcome the stone-cold gaze of the Gorgon? 🐍💪

In this episode, we explore:

• Top Greek Mythology Characters: From the wisdom of Athena to the chaos of the Olympians.

• Medusa’s Redemption: Is she a villain or a victim?

• The Labors of Hercules: Which feat was actually the most impressive?

• Modern Retellings: Why we are still obsessed with these myths in 2026.

Scroll down on your Spotify app to participate in our Live Poll: Who wins in a fight—Medusa or Hercules?

Enjoying the chaos?Please Rate us 5 stars, Follow for weekly debates, and Share this episode with your favorite history buff or mythology nerd!

🗳️ Join the Battle:Scroll down on your Spotify app to participate in our Live Poll: Who is more iconic—Medusa or Hercules?

Looking for a podcast with a married couple who has fun banter? Look no further! We can show you how a simple argument doesn't have to mean trouble in paradise! Check out our sometimes hilarious married couple banter and see how a little humor can go a long way.

Is a house cat’s life of luxury better than the literal bird’s-eye view of an apex predator? In the 34th episode of Arguing Ever After, we’re diving deep into the animal kingdom to settle the debates you didn’t know you needed.

We kick things off with the internet legend "Punch the Monkey"—breaking down the chaos and the comedy behind one of the most bizarre pop culture moments. Then, the gloves come off for our main event: The Epic Battle of Animals.

• Domestic Bliss vs. High-Altitude Freedom: Would you rather be a pampered House Cat (infinite naps and zero rent) or a majestic Eagle (master of the skies and ultimate hunter)?

• The "Punch the Monkey" Phenomenon: A look back at the viral madness and why it still lives rent-free in our heads.

• Survival Instincts: Which animal actually has the better deal in the wild (or on the sofa)?

Whether you're Team Feline or Team Feather, this episode is packed with our signature banter, questionable logic, and a whole lot of heart.

Listen now and decide: Which side are you on?

Vote, follow, rate and share!

Looking for a podcast with a married couple who has fun debates? Look no further! We can show you how a simple argument doesn't have to mean trouble in paradise! Check out our some hilarious marriage insights and couple banter and see how a little humor can go a long way.

Can a "regular person" actually compete in the Olympics? In Episode 33, we’re diving into the Olympics. We debate the thrill of big-market sports like Ice Hockey and Figure Skating versus the grit of smaller disciplines like Curling and the Olympic debut of Ski Mountaineering (Skimo).

We also look back at the viral sensation Raygun from Paris—did she change the "smaller sport" game forever?

In this episode, we discuss:

• Our personal favorite Olympic moments and sports.

• The Great Debate: Which Olympic sport could we actually qualify for?

• Why "niche" sports often have the most chaotic drama.

• Your thoughts on Raygun and the future of creative sports in the Games.

Interact with us below! 👇Check out the Poll and Q&A right here on the Spotify app to cast your vote and tell us which sport you’d enter under!

Don't forget to Rate, Follow, and Share! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Looking for a podcast with a married couple who has fun debates? Look no further! We can show you how a simple argument doesn't have to mean trouble in paradise! Check out our some hilarious marriage insights and couple banter and see how a little humor can go a long way.

In this, our very 32nd episode, we’re diving deep into the galaxy far, far away to break down every saga, from the high-stakes politics of the Prequels to the legendary heroics of the Original Trilogy and the polarizing paths of the Sequels. We’re not just talking plot points; we’re debating the merits, the pitfalls, and the "What were they thinking?" moments of every film.

In our very 31st episode, we dive deep into the complexities of relationships, love languages, and the commercial pressure of Valentine’s Day. We tackle the "forever" dilemma: If you’ve been together for years, is it still necessary to "show off" your love?

We debate whether spending money on grand gestures and public declarations of affection is essential for maintaining spark—or if the security of a long-term partnership makes the holiday redundant.

Can you really win a Chili Cookoff using a can opener? 🥘 This week, we celebrate 30 episodes by settling the score on canned chili vs. homemade. Join the conversation as we discuss contest-winning tips and culinary shortcuts. Don't forget to vote in the poll!

Enjoying the show?

⭐ Rate us 5 stars if you love the heat!

• ✅ Follow for weekly fun debates.

• 📲 Share this with your favorite foodie.

Looking for a podcast with a married couple who has fun debates? Look no further! We can show you how a simple argument doesn't have to mean trouble in paradise! Check out our some hilarious marriage insights and couple banter and see how a little humor can go a long way.