Criminal Empire: Mafia Mysteries & Serial Killers

Arnold Rothstein: The Mastermind Who Invented the American Mafia


Listen Later

Dive deep into the shadowy world of Arnold Rothstein, the man who transformed organized crime in America. Known as "The Brain," Rothstein was more than just a gambler; he was a visionary who saw opportunity where others saw risk. From manipulating odds and fixing games to amassing a fortune before the age of 30, his brilliance lay in always staying one step ahead.
In this episode, we unravel the infamous 1919 World Series scandal, where Rothstein orchestrated the biggest fix in sports history by bribing Chicago White Sox players to throw the series. Despite national outrage and a government investigation, he walked away unscathed, showcasing his uncanny ability to manipulate not just games but the justice system itself.
But Rothstein's influence didn't stop there. He became the mentor to a new generation of gangsters—names like Meyer Lansky, Lucky Luciano, and Dutch Schultz—teaching them to run crime like a business. Under his guidance, these proteges learned to blend into high society, emphasizing intelligence and sophistication over brute force, laying the groundwork for modern organized crime.
As Prohibition gripped the nation, Rothstein saw another golden opportunity. He established a bootlegging empire, importing high-quality Scottish whiskey and distributing it nationwide. His operation was meticulous, turning the chaos of illegal liquor trade into a well-oiled machine catering to the wealthy and powerful.
Not one to rest on his laurels, Rothstein diversified into labor racketeering, collaborating with ruthless figures like Louis "Lepke" Buchalter to control unions and exert pressure on businesses. He also foresaw the lucrative potential of the narcotics trade, leveraging his smuggling networks to pioneer organized drug trafficking in the United States.
However, ambition breeds conflict. Rothstein's relationships with volatile associates like Dutch Schultz highlighted the risks of his high-stakes game. As he aimed to expand his empire globally, seeking partnerships to create an international drug cartel, Rothstein's story became a tale of ambition without bounds.
Join us as we delve into the life of Arnold Rothstein—a man whose intellect and audacity not only shook the foundations of America's favorite pastime but also redefined the underworld. His story is one of brilliance, corruption, and the relentless pursuit of power, offering unparalleled insights into the making of the American Mafia.
  • Early Success in Gambling (00:07-02:54): Rothstein, a brilliant gambler and self-made millionaire, manipulated odds by fixing games, always ensuring a winning edge. He became known as "The Brain" for his cunning approach and ability to rig the system.
  • 1919 World Series Scandal (06:26-11:57): Rothstein bribed Chicago White Sox players to throw the series, profiting massively from his bets. Although the scheme eventually unraveled, he evaded conviction by manipulating the legal system.
  • Rise in Organized Crime (12:49-16:10): Rothstein’s success in fixing games and evading justice inspired New York’s gangsters, turning him into a mentor for future crime figures like Meyer Lansky, Lucky Luciano, and Dutch Schultz. He structured crime like a business, laying the foundation for modern organized crime.
  • Bootlegging Empire (14:26-18:47): During Prohibition, Rothstein imported high-quality alcohol and established a national bootlegging operation. He hired top mobsters to manage distribution, transforming crime into a well-organized enterprise.
  • Mentorship and Influence (17:06-19:50): Rothstein shaped his proteges, teaching them refined tastes and how to blend in with high society. His approach emphasized intelligence and sophistication over brute force.
  • Labor Racketeering (26:02-27:46): Rothstein diversified into labor racketeering, collaborating with gangsters like Louis "Lepke" Buchalter to control unions and pressure businesses.
  • Conflict with Dutch Schultz (27:46-28:31): Rothstein faced challenges from proteges like Schultz, who became uncontrollable and sought larger control of the bootlegging empire, showcasing the risks of employing violent gangsters.
  • Entry into Drug Trade (29:34-31:13): Rothstein expanded into narcotics, leveraging his smuggling network from Prohibition to distribute heroin, setting the stage for organized drug trafficking in the U.S.
  • Global Ambitions (31:13-31:59): Near the end of his career, Rothstein aimed to expand internationally, seeking partnerships to create a global drug cartel, pushing organized crime to new heights.
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Criminal Empire: Mafia Mysteries & Serial KillersBy Charlie Outback

  • 3.7
  • 3.7
  • 3.7
  • 3.7
  • 3.7

3.7

22 ratings


More shows like Criminal Empire: Mafia Mysteries & Serial Killers

View all
Gangland Wire by Gary Jenkins: Mafia Detective

Gangland Wire

605 Listeners

Mafia by Audioboom Studios

Mafia

2,767 Listeners

Infamous America by Black Barrel Media

Infamous America

2,878 Listeners

Original Gangsters Podcast by Original Gangsters, a True Crime Talk Podcast

Original Gangsters Podcast

670 Listeners

Mobbed Up: The Fight for Las Vegas by Las Vegas Review-Journal | The Mob Museum

Mobbed Up: The Fight for Las Vegas

1,117 Listeners

The Underworld Podcast by The Underworld Podcast

The Underworld Podcast

790 Listeners

Our Thing with Sammy The Bull by Sammy "The Bull" Gravano

Our Thing with Sammy The Bull

5,025 Listeners

The Sit Down: A Crime History Podcast by Jeff Nadu

The Sit Down: A Crime History Podcast

1,488 Listeners

Game of Crimes by Game of Crimes

Game of Crimes

1,448 Listeners

The Gangland History Podcast: An Organized Crime & Mafia History Podcast by Jacob Stoops

The Gangland History Podcast: An Organized Crime & Mafia History Podcast

61 Listeners

Mind of a Monster: The Butcher Baker by ID

Mind of a Monster: The Butcher Baker

1,412 Listeners

The Connect- with Johnny Mitchell by Johnny Mitchell

The Connect- with Johnny Mitchell

508 Listeners

Underbelly: Killing Kurt by Entropy Media

Underbelly: Killing Kurt

291 Listeners

Inside the Life by The Mob Museum

Inside the Life

69 Listeners

Serial Killers: Real Life Documentaries by Peter Zahr

Serial Killers: Real Life Documentaries

12 Listeners