The "Coexist" bumper sticker has become an iconic symbol in our culture – a clever arrangement of religious symbols spelling out a message of tolerance. But does this well-intentioned call for harmony align with biblical truth?

In this thought-provoking episode, Cody and Caitlin dissect each symbol within this popular bumper sticker and examine why religious pluralism fundamentally contradicts Christianity's core claims. From the crescent moon of Islam to the yin-yang of Eastern philosophies, they explore how each represented belief system makes mutually exclusive truth claims that cannot logically coexist with Jesus's declaration: "I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me."

What makes this conversation particularly compelling is how they balance unwavering biblical conviction with genuine compassion. The hosts tackle challenging objections head-on: Is claiming Christianity as the exclusive path to salvation arrogant? What about people who've never heard of Jesus? Their responses draw from Scripture while acknowledging the cultural discomfort these exclusive claims often create.

Listeners will gain clarity about why Christians cannot compromise on Christ's exclusivity while still treating neighbors of different faiths with dignity and respect. The discussion challenges believers to examine whether they've been influenced by cultural pressure to water down biblical truth in the name of tolerance.

Whether you've puzzled over this bumper sticker yourself or struggled to articulate why Christianity makes exclusive claims in our pluralistic world, this episode offers biblical grounding and practical wisdom. The conversation culminates in a powerful call to share the gospel boldly yet lovingly – recognizing that true compassion means offering the life-changing truth of salvation through Christ alone.

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!

That "inspirational" phrase you keep seeing on Instagram might be leading you astray. In this thought-provoking episode, Cody and Caitlin examine what they call "bumper sticker theology" - those catchy, shallow spiritual sayings that sound good but lack biblical foundation.

The hosts dive deep into one of today's most popular mantras: "You are enough." While seemingly empowering, this message fundamentally contradicts scripture's teaching about our dependence on God. Through personal stories and biblical analysis, they explain why this self-focused worldview gives false comfort while robbing us of the true peace that comes from resting in Christ's sufficiency.

"When we believe we're enough on our own, we get stuck," Caitlin shares from her parenting struggles. "I'd try handling things myself, fail repeatedly, and end up in tears because I couldn't do it alone." This practical example illuminates why acknowledging our insufficiency actually opens the door to experiencing God's power.

The conversation tackles why these simplistic sayings gain traction, especially in our self-help culture, and offers a more biblical alternative: instead of "I am enough," embrace "God's grace is enough." This shift transforms our approach to challenges - seeking God first through prayer and Scripture, then taking action in His strength rather than our own.

Whether you've questioned these popular phrases or found yourself repeating them, this episode will challenge you to examine the theology behind the bumper stickers and rediscover the freedom that comes from dependence on Christ. Subscribe now and join us next week as we examine another piece of bumper sticker theology: "Coexist."

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!

The resurrection of Jesus Christ stands as the cornerstone of Christian faith—yet in our culture, Easter often receives less attention and celebration than Christmas. In this heartfelt conversation, Cody and Caitlin explore this surprising imbalance and make a compelling case for why Easter deserves greater emphasis in Christian homes.

Drawing from 1 Corinthians 15, they discuss how the resurrection serves as the pivotal moment that validates everything about Christianity. "Without the resurrection, Christmas doesn't matter," Cody explains, highlighting that while Christ's birth was necessary, it's his victory over death that provides the foundation for our faith. The conversation weaves through scriptural insights, including fascinating cultural context about the folded burial cloth that signaled "I'm coming back" in Jewish tradition.

What makes this episode particularly valuable are the practical ideas for making Holy Week meaningful for families. From creating cross-stained glass windows with painter's tape and paint to holding intimate family feet washing ceremonies, Cody and Caitlin share traditions that have created powerful memories with their children. Their suggestions range from simple (Easter worship playlists) to more involved (resurrection gardens), offering options for families at every stage.

Whether you're looking to deepen your own appreciation of Easter or create meaningful traditions with your children, this episode provides both theological grounding and practical inspiration. The resurrection isn't just another religious event—it's the defining moment that makes Christianity distinct from every other faith. How will you celebrate it this year?

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!

What happens when a career-driven professional with a love for measurable achievements and quiet office space suddenly transitions to homeschooling four children? After years of planning, Caitlin found herself making this dramatic life change in just six days when her husband landed a new position. Now, one year into her journey, she's opening up about the beautiful and brutal realities that no one warned her about.

The stark contrast between professional and home life hit immediately. At work, Caitlin could close an office door, complete projects with tangible results, and receive affirmation for jobs well done. At home, she discovered the endless cycle of dishes, the impossibility of bathroom privacy, and the challenge of teaching multiple grade levels while managing a curious toddler who puts shoes in the refrigerator.

Most profound has been the spiritual transformation. While career obstacles could often be solved through self-reliance, homeschooling has driven Caitlin to her knees in prayer, sometimes literally asking God to help her through the next hour. Scripture verses like John 3:30 ("He must increase, but I must decrease") and Galatians 6:9 ("Let us not grow weary of doing good") have become daily lifelines rather than Sunday platitudes.

This raw conversation strips away Instagram-perfect homeschooling illusions while still affirming the profound worth of the journey. As Caitlin candidly shares, "Any bad day at home is better than a good day at work." For parents considering homeschooling or those already in the trenches, this episode offers both validation for the struggles and encouragement for the path ahead. When children see not just our successes but how we handle our failures, we provide them with something far more valuable than a perfect homeschool day—we show them authentic faith in action.

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!

We reunite after a year-long hiatus to share the whirlwind of changes our family has experienced. From career transitions and education milestones to homesteading adventures and parenting revelations, we reflect on how our carefully planned future compressed into rapid, transformative action.

• Transitioning from a two-year plan to a two-week reality when Cody took a teaching position
• Completing a master's degree and starting a doctoral program in history
• Beginning our homesteading journey with 40 chickens, fruit trees, and garden plans
• Switching homeschooling responsibilities and adjusting to new family dynamics
• Converting our garage into a bedroom to accommodate our growing family
• Surviving memorable parenting moments including an oven fire and toddler mishaps
• Finding a church community and celebrating our children's spiritual milestones
• Balancing the paradox of wanting little ones to grow while cherishing older children's stages

We're excited to be recording regularly again, creating both a family time capsule for our children and sharing our journey with listeners. Join us as we navigate faith, family, and the unexpected twists of life together.

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!

Cody and Caitlin discuss secular Christmas culture and Santa!

Disclaimer: Do not listen with children who believe in Santa! 

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!

Special guests John and Danyelle Himes join us to discuss and debate which Christmas movies should make the Top 5 list! 

Did your favorite Christmas movie make the list? 

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!

In honor of Veteran's Day, we have very special guests. 

• Mark Castellani, Cody's Father, Coast Guard
• Kevin Taylor, Caitlin's Gather, Air Force
• Travis Taylor, Caitlin's Uncle, Air Force 

Please join us in honoring our veterans them by listening to the stories they share. 

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!

In honor of Veteran's Day, we have very special guests. 

• Mark Castellani, Cody's Father, Coast Guard
• Kevin Taylor, Caitlin's Gather, Air Force
• Travis Taylor, Caitlin's Uncle, Air Force 

Please join us in honoring our veterans them by listening to the stories they share. 

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!

In honor of Veteran's Day, we have very special guests. 

• Mark Castellani, Cody's Father, Coast Guard
• Kevin Taylor, Caitlin's Gather, Air Force
• Travis Taylor, Caitlin's Uncle, Air Force 

Please join us in honoring our veterans them by listening to the stories they share. 

Follow us on social media:

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100095048198434
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/arrowsinthemaking/?next=%2F

Email us questions, content suggestions and prayer requests at [email protected]

Be blessed!