In this episode of the Ask TMFG Podcast, Carlo Cansino and John Iaconetti unpack a common assumption many Canadians make: that contributing to an RRSP is always the right move. They explain why that strategy can backfire for people with a defined benefit pension, where guaranteed retirement income can stack with RRSP withdrawals and quietly push retirees into higher tax brackets.
Using a Canadian-specific lens, they walk through how RRSPs actually work, contributions reduce taxable income today, investments grow tax-deferred, and every dollar withdrawn in retirement is taxed as income. For pension holders, this can create unintended consequences, including higher lifetime taxes, reduced Old Age Security benefits, and limited flexibility once withdrawals begin.
The conversation highlights where RRSPs still make sense, typically for high earners today who expect to be in a lower tax bracket in retirement. But for Canadians with strong workplace pensions or lower future income changes, alternatives like TFSAs may provide more flexibility and tax efficiency.
A key moment in the episode introduces a simple decision framework: compare your tax rate today to your expected tax rate in retirement. If your current rate is higher, an RRSP contribution may help. If it’s similar or lower, especially with a pension, contributing blindly could cost thousands over time.
The conclusion: retirement planning isn’t just about saving more, it’s about choosing the right account based on your future income picture. For Canadians with pensions, the difference between RRSPs and TFSAs can significantly shape how much of their retirement income they actually keep.
👉 Watch the full video episode on YouTube to learn how pensions and RRSPs interact - and how to avoid unnecessary taxes:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dva6raI850I
Question for our listeners:
If you have a workplace pension, have you evaluated whether RRSP contributions are still the best strategy, or are you contributing out of habit?
If you’d like help reviewing how your pension, RRSP, and TFSA fit together, we’re offering a free portfolio analysis 👉 https://tmfg.ca/portfolio-analysis/
Follow us on our social channels:
LinkedIn: The McClelland Financial Group
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/tmfg.ca
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/themcclellandfinancialgroup_