Haley presents Maddie with some behind-the-scenes conspiracy theories about some of today's sports legends.

Haley and Maddie pick some highly debated Reddit threads and question their already questionable ethics.

Haley and Maddie talk about the creepy 1800s murders by the first serial killer family in America.

Haley and Maddie discuss the bizarre, unsolved missing persons case of Maura Murray.

Maddie and Haley are talking about checking their ex's phones, personal confessions, and their MySpace profile song as they play We're Not Really Strangers - a game about connection.

Haley and Maddie talk about friendship – what they've learned, what they've gained, and the friends they think of when they're singing True Friend by Hannah Montana.

Haley teaches Maddie about America's royal family and all the reasons they might be cursed.

Haley and Maddie take you back to your high school ethics class to discuss the moral dilemmas that have haunted them for years.

Haley teaches Maddie about the missing person's case of Laci Peterson and its death row case.

Haley and Maddie psychoanalyze some of history's greatest personalities.