May 20, 2026

Baseball Development Is Broken—Here’s Why

11 minutes

Send us Fan Mail

If baseball has more technology than ever, why are so many players training harder and developing slower? I’m Coach Ken Carpenter, and I want to dig into a problem I keep hearing after more than 200 conversations with high school, college, and pro coaches: we’re starting to confuse what we can measure with what we truly understand. Exit velocity, launch angle, bat speed, pitch velocity, and spin rate are useful, but when they become the whole plan, young athletes end up chasing numbers instead of building repeatable skills.

I pull a key lesson from College Hall of Fame coach Ray Birmingham: coach the player based on the player’s body type. A 5'9" second baseman trying to swing like Aaron Judge is not “modern,” it’s a mismatch. The best baseball player development is individualized coaching. It starts with how an athlete moves, creates force, handles timing, responds to fatigue, and competes when conditions are not perfect.

We also talk about what rarely gets marketed in youth baseball and travel ball: durability. Everyone shares clips of 100 mph fastballs and monster home runs, but where’s the training plan for staying healthy, repeating a delivery for years, and performing late in the season? The recruiting funnel is tight, and it doesn’t make sense to force every player to train like a tiny group of outliers at the top of the sport.

If you coach high school baseball, run a travel program, or you’re a parent trying to help your player, this one is a reset. Subscribe to Baseball Coaches Unplugged, share it with a coach, and leave a review if it helps. What’s one trend you want to stop copying right now?

Support the show