
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


For Jimmy, the murder of 16-year-old Cheryl Lee Fergeson and the wrongful conviction of Clarence Brandley aren't just stories from the past. They're part of the history of his hometown.
Growing up in Cut N Shoot and attending Conroe High School in the late 1970s, Jimmy walked the same hallways, knew the backstage areas, and remembers seeing Clarence Brandley and other custodians working at the school. Years later, he would return to that same auditorium to watch his own daughters participate in school programs.
In this deeply personal final episode of Murder at the High School, Jimmy steps away from the investigation to reflect on his memories of Conroe, the racial tensions of the time, and the devastating consequences of prejudice and injustice.
As a father of five, including three daughters and two Black children, Jimmy shares how this tragedy has shaped his thoughts about justice, racism, parenthood, and the world he hopes his children will inherit.
Two families suffered unimaginable pain. A young girl lost her life. An innocent man lost years of his freedom. And decades later, questions remain.
This isn't just a reflection on a murder. It's a reflection on a community, a justice system, and our responsibility to future generations.
We cannot change yesterday. But we can demand a better tomorrow.
Episode 10: A Personal Reflection — the emotional conclusion to Murder at the High School, a Behind The Pine Curtain series.
Listen at PineCurtainPod.com
Hashtags:
#BehindThePineCurtain #MurderAtTheHighSchool #APersonalReflection #CherylLeeFergeson #ClarenceBrandley #ConroeTexas #CutNShootTexas #MontgomeryCountyTX #TrueCrimeTexas #WrongfulConviction #JusticeForCheryl #RacialInjustice #InnocentUntilProvenGuilty #CriminalJusticeReform #TexasTrueCrime #TrueCrimePodcast #ConroeHighSchool #RememberCheryl #PineCurtainPod
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic, Criminal tension by Soundridemusic
After nearly ten years on death row and two scheduled execution dates, Clarence Brandley walked out of prison in January 1990. But his freedom came with a warning: his capital-murder indictment remained active, Texas was still fighting to restore his conviction and Montgomery County could place him on trial for a third time.
In the series finale of Murder at the High School, Jimmy follows Brandley’s journey from the prison gates to the final dismissal of the charge—and examines everything freedom could not restore. There was no apology, no compensation and no answer for Cheryl Dee Fergeson’s family.
Then, decades later, trial exhibits from the case were discovered inside the private garage of a former Conroe police chief. The discovery reopened Cheryl’s murder investigation and raised troubling new questions.
What was inside the box? Why had official evidence been stored in a garage? Could modern DNA testing finally identify Cheryl’s killer? And after so many years of missing evidence, unreliable testimony and lost opportunities, was the truth still recoverable?
Clarence Brandley died in 2018 without receiving compensation or learning whether the recovered evidence could clear his name through science. Cheryl’s murder remains unresolved.
One young life was stolen inside a school. Another was nearly taken by the justice system.
Murder at the High School: A Behind The Pine Curtain Limited Series.
Content advisory: This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a sixteen-year-old girl, racial injustice, capital punishment, wrongful conviction and allegations involving people who were never convicted in connection with Cheryl Fergeson’s murder. Listener discretion is advised.
#MurderAtTheHighSchool #FreeButNotCleared #TheBoxInTheGarage #SeriesFinale #BehindThePineCurtain #CherylFergeson #ClarenceBrandley #ConroeTexas #TexasTrueCrime #WrongfulConviction #DeathRow #DeathPenalty #ColdCase #UnsolvedMurder #TrueCrimePodcast
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic, Criminal tension by Soundridemusic
►FOLLOW: / @soundridemusic
The witnesses had changed their stories. Evidence had been withheld, lost or left untested. A judge had concluded that the investigation was shaped by racial prejudice, intimidation and a predetermined focus on Clarence Brandley.
But overturning a death sentence would require the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to confront not only the failures of the investigation—but its own earlier decision affirming Brandley’s conviction.
In Episode Eight of Murder at the High School, Jimmy examines the divided legal battle over Brandley’s fate. Some judges concluded that the cumulative effect of suppressed evidence, unreliable testimony and improper investigative methods had denied him due process and a fundamentally fair trial. Others strongly disagreed, arguing that the new testimony did not establish Brandley’s innocence.
On December 13, 1989, the court set aside Brandley’s conviction.
But the decision did not declare him innocent, dismiss the indictment or immediately set him free. The State of Texas could still seek another trial—and prosecutors were not ready to let the case go.
After nearly a decade on death row, Clarence Brandley was closer to freedom than ever before.
But the court was divided, the murder charge remained active and the fight was not over.
Murder at the High School: A Behind The Pine Curtain Limited Series.
Content advisory: This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a sixteen-year-old girl, racial injustice, capital punishment, alleged police misconduct and wrongful conviction. Listener discretion is advised.
#MurderAtTheHighSchool #TheCourtDivides #EpisodeEight #BehindThePineCurtain #CherylFergeson #ClarenceBrandley #ConroeTexas #TexasTrueCrime #WrongfulConviction #DeathRow #DeathPenalty #DueProcess #CriminalJustice #TrueCrimePodcast
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic
Link to Video: • No Copyright Cinematic Cello Music / Wrath...
Detective Investigation - Dark Knight
►FOLLOW: / @soundridemusic
Clarence Brandley remained on death row, but the witnesses whose testimony helped convict him were no longer telling the same story.
In Episode Seven of Murder at the High School, Jimmy examines the testimony that emerged during Brandley’s post-conviction hearings. John Sessum admitted that he had committed perjury. Gary Acreman acknowledged speaking with Cheryl Dee Fergeson shortly before she disappeared and admitted that he had not remained with the other custodians throughout the critical period. Henry Peace described alleged threats, physical intimidation and racial language used during the investigation.
Another witness revealed that she had reported seeing two white men hurrying through the school shortly after Cheryl vanished—information that was never properly investigated or disclosed to Brandley’s defense.
The new testimony did not conclusively identify Cheryl’s killer. But it challenged the foundation of Brandley’s conviction and exposed a very different story from the one presented to the jury.
After years of silence, the witnesses were finally talking.
The question was whether the courts would listen.
Murder at the High School: A Behind The Pine Curtain Limited Series.
Content advisory: This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a sixteen-year-old girl, racial prejudice, alleged police misconduct, witness intimidation and allegations involving people who were never charged with Cheryl Fergeson’s murder. Listener discretion is advised.
#MurderAtTheHighSchool #TheWitnessesTalk #EpisodeSeven #BehindThePineCurtain #CherylFergeson #ClarenceBrandley #ConroeTexas #TexasTrueCrime #WrongfulConviction #DeathRow #WitnessTestimony #PoliceMisconduct #CriminalJustice #TrueCrimePodcast
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic
Link to Video: • No Copyright Cinematic Cello Music / Wrath...
Detective Investigation - Dark Knight
►FOLLOW: / @soundridemusic
For years, the case against Clarence Brandley rested on a seemingly straightforward story: Cheryl Dee Fergeson entered a restroom, Brandley followed her upstairs and the other custodians remained together—leaving him as the only man with the opportunity to commit the crime.
Then the witnesses began telling different stories.
In Episode Six of Murder at the High School, Jimmy examines the recantations, recorded statements and startling admissions that transformed Brandley’s case. One witness declared on videotape that Brandley was innocent before withdrawing his account. Another admitted committing perjury at the first trial. Details omitted for years suddenly emerged, including a conversation with Cheryl and a thirty-minute gap in another custodian’s timeline.
The testimony did not conclusively identify Cheryl’s killer. But it exposed something the juries had never been told: the prosecution’s central timeline was neither independent nor reliable.
As Clarence Brandley remained on death row, the story that put him there was beginning to collapse.
Murder at the High School: A Behind The Pine Curtain Limited Series.
Content advisory: This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a sixteen-year-old girl, racial prejudice, alleged witness intimidation and allegations involving people who were never charged with Cheryl Fergeson’s murder. Listener discretion is advised.
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic
Link to Video: • No Copyright Cinematic Cello Music / Wrath...
Detective Investigation - Dark Knight
►FOLLOW: / @soundridemusic
Clarence Brandley had been convicted of murdering sixteen-year-old Cheryl Dee Fergeson and sentenced to death. To the State of Texas, the case was closed.
But the evidence did not fit as neatly as prosecutors claimed.
In Episode Five of Murder at the High School, Jimmy examines the growing doubts surrounding Brandley’s conviction. Witness statements conflicted. Timelines shifted. Physical evidence failed to conclusively connect Brandley to the crime, while potentially important testing was never completed. Information that could have challenged the prosecution’s story was overlooked, withheld or eventually lost.
As Brandley waited on death row, attorneys and supporters began taking a closer look at the case—and discovered that the story presented to the jury was beginning to fall apart.
If Clarence Brandley did not kill Cheryl, who did?
And how many people knew that things simply did not fit?
Murder at the High School: A Behind The Pine Curtain Limited Series.
Content advisory: This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a sixteen-year-old girl, racial prejudice, capital punishment and allegations involving people who were never charged with Cheryl Fergeson’s murder. Listener discretion is advised.
#MurderAtTheHighSchool #ThingsDontFit #EpisodeFive #BehindThePineCurtain #CherylFergeson #ClarenceBrandley #ConroeTexas #TexasTrueCrime #WrongfulConviction #DeathRow #CriminalJustice #TrueCrimePodcast
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic
Link to Video: • No Copyright Cinematic Cello Music / Wrath...
Detective Investigation - Dark Knight
►FOLLOW: / @soundridemusic
Clarence Brandley’s first trial ended with eleven jurors voting to convict and one refusing to surrender his doubt. The mistrial should have forced prosecutors to confront the weaknesses in their case.
Instead, the State of Texas tried again.
In Episode Four of Murder at the High School, Jimmy examines Brandley’s second trial, the prosecution’s renewed circumstantial case and a courtroom atmosphere shaped by race, fear and the demand for a conviction.
The witnesses remained largely the same. The physical evidence still did not conclusively identify Brandley as Cheryl Dee Fergeson’s attacker. But this time, there would be no holdout juror.
Clarence Brandley was convicted of capital murder. The jury then answered the questions that allowed the court to impose the ultimate punishment.
Death.
How did a case without a confession, a murder weapon or conclusive physical evidence place a man on Texas death row?
Murder at the High School: A Behind The Pine Curtain Limited Series.
Content advisory: This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a sixteen-year-old girl, racial prejudice, capital punishment and disturbing allegations presented during a murder trial. Listener discretion is advised.
#MurderAtTheHighSchool #EpisodeFour #Death #BehindThePineCurtain #CherylFergeson #ClarenceBrandley #ConroeTexas #TexasTrueCrime #WrongfulConviction #DeathPenalty #DeathRow #TrueCrimePodcast
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic
Link to Video: • No Copyright Cinematic Cello Music / Wrath...
Detective Investigation - Dark Knight
►FOLLOW: / @soundridemusic
The State of Texas charged Clarence Brandley with the rape and murder of sixteen-year-old Cheryl Dee Fergeson. The case offered no confession, no eyewitness to the killing and no physical evidence conclusively identifying Brandley as Cheryl’s attacker.
What prosecutors did have was a circumstantial story built around a restroom, a set of keys, a white towel, Brandley’s knowledge of the school—and testimony from custodians whose accounts would later change.
In Episode Three of Murder at the High School, Jimmy examines Brandley’s first trial, the disputed physical evidence and the allegations used to portray him as a dangerous man. The prosecution asked jurors to believe that Brandley was the only person who had the opportunity to kill Cheryl.
Eleven jurors accepted that story.
One did not.
The result was a deadlocked jury, a mistrial—and the beginning of the State of Texas’ second attempt to convict Clarence Brandley and send him to death row.
Murder at the High School: A Behind The Pine Curtain Limited Series.
Content advisory: This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a sixteen-year-old girl, racial prejudice and disputed allegations presented during a murder trial. Listener discretion is advised.
#MurderAtTheHighSchool #ElevenToOne #BehindThePineCurtain #CherylFergeson #ClarenceBrandley #ConroeTexas #TexasTrueCrime #WrongfulConviction #DeathRow #TrueCrimePodcast #CriminalJustice
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic
Link to Video: • No Copyright Cinematic Cello Music / Wrath...
Detective Investigation - Dark Knight
►FOLLOW: / @soundridemusic
Five custodians were working inside Conroe High School on the morning sixteen-year-old Cheryl Dee Fergeson was murdered. Within six days, investigators arrested Clarence Brandley—the only Black member of the custodial crew.
In Episode Two of Murder at the High School, Jimmy examines the shifting statements, missing details and disputed timelines surrounding the men who became the prosecution’s most important witnesses.
One witness admitted committing perjury. Another recorded statements declaring Brandley innocent before taking them back. A former custodian who was not scheduled to work was later acknowledged to have been inside the school. Meanwhile, an investigative walk-through conducted after Brandley’s arrest may have helped transform conflicting accounts into a single story.
How did five custodians’ movements become the foundation of the case against Clarence Brandley—and why had investigators already selected their suspect before conducting the critical reconstruction?
Murder at the High School: A Behind The Pine Curtain Limited Series.
Content advisory: This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a sixteen-year-old girl, racial prejudice and allegations involving people who were never charged with Cheryl Fergeson’s murder. Listener discretion is advised.
#MurderAtTheHighSchool #FiveCustodians #BehindThePineCurtain #CherylFergeson #ClarenceBrandley #ConroeTexas #TexasTrueCrime #WrongfulConviction #DeathRow #TrueCrimePodcast
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic
Link to Video: • No Copyright Cinematic Cello Music / Wrath...
Detective Investigation - Dark Knight
►FOLLOW: / @soundridemusic
On August 23, 1980, sixteen-year-old Cheryl Dee Fergeson arrived at Conroe High School with the Bellville High School volleyball team. Before the tournament was over, Cheryl vanished. Her body was later discovered hidden above the school’s auditorium stage.
In the opening episode of Murder at the High School, host Jimmy reconstructs Cheryl’s final morning, the search through the school and the discovery that transformed a volleyball tournament into a murder investigation.
Attention quickly turned toward the school’s custodial crew—and particularly Clarence Brandley, the only Black custodian working that morning. Within six days, Brandley was arrested. He would eventually be convicted and sentenced to death, even though no physical evidence conclusively identified him as Cheryl’s attacker.
This is where the tragedy began—and where the pursuit of justice started going terribly wrong.
Murder at the High School: A Behind The Pine Curtain Limited Series.
Content advisory: This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a sixteen-year-old girl. Listener discretion is advised.
#MurderAtTheHighSchool #BehindThePineCurtain #CherylFergeson #ClarenceBrandley #ConroeTexas #TexasTrueCrime #WrongfulConviction #TrueCrimePodcast #ColdCase #JusticeForCheryl
Credits:
Music: Wrath by Soundridemusic
Detective Investigation - Dark Knight
@soundridemusic
From the publisher's feed
Behind the Pine Curtain is a true-crime podcast exploring the murders, disappearances, cold cases, and mysteries of Montgomery County, Texas.
Behind the growing communities…
Each episode takes a detailed look at a real local case, using law-enforcement records, court documents, archived reporting, and other documented sources to separate fact from rumor while keeping the victims and their stories at the center.
From Conroe and Willis to Montgomery, Magnolia, Porter, New Caney, The Woodlands, and the back roads in between, these are the stories that happened closer to home than you might think.
Behind the Pine Curtain True Crime from Montgomery County, Texas.
Behind the pines are stories waiting to be told.
#BehindThePineCurtain #MontgomeryCountyTX #ConroeTX #TexasTrueCrime #TrueCrimePodcast #ColdCase #ColdCaseSolved #MontgomeryCounty #TexasCrime #TrueCrime #DNA #ForensicScience #Conroe