This week on BYR, we admit it: we made a big mistake… by underestimating Big Mistakes on Netflix. 😅 What started as a “we’ll just try a few episodes” situation quickly turned into a full binge.

In this episode, we break down the new crime comedy from Dan Levy and Rachel Sennett, and why it surprised us in the best way. We talk about going in with low expectations and quickly getting hooked, Dan Levy’s performance as Nicky—a pastor who accidentally gets tangled up in crime—and why we loved seeing him in a role that feels like the total opposite but also homage to his iconic Schitt’s Creek era. We also dive into the chaotic sibling dynamics, the unexpected emotional depth of the family storyline, and how the show manages to balance crime, comedy, and heartfelt moments without losing its vibe.

Basically: this show made us laugh, made us care, and made us immediately hit “next episode.” Press play and come yap with us about the newest binge-worthy comedy on Netflix. 🎧

BYR average rating: 8/10

Number of episodes: 8 (~4h runtime)

Binge In Progress: Project Hail Mary, Shrinking, Your Friends & Neighbors, The Pitt