BLACKOAK: The Ice That Would Not Let Go — What the Sailor Who Found the Franklin Note Couldn't Put Down
In May of 1847, someone stood at a desk inside HMS Terror — beset in Arctic ice for eight months — and wrote an official Admiralty form reporting that all was well. The ships had been locked in pack ice since September. Three men had died over the winter on Beechey Island. But the form was filled in with military precision, properly dated, properly signed, and placed in a cairn on King William Island.
In April of 1848, someone stood at the same desk and wrote around the margins of that same form. Twenty-four men dead. Sir John Franklin dead. Ships abandoned. One hundred and five survivors departing for Back River. The handwriting is still formal. The document is still properly dated and signed. The gap between those two entries — eleven months, twenty-four deaths, the transformation of empire's most celebrated expedition into a death march — is written in the white space between two sets of ink.
That note was found in 1859 by a search party from the Fox. Samuel Bent, a common sailor on that expedition, was among the men who searched King William Island. He was not there when the cairn was opened. But he was there for the two weeks after. He was there for the boats.
In this episode of BLACKOAK: The Adventures, the ancient sentient tankard carries an account received in a Wapping tavern in November of 1859 — from a man who had stood in a boat full of silver plate and loaded guns and books and two men who had been dead for eleven years. Who had understood, standing there, what the silver meant — and why carrying it made the only possible sense to men who were dying. Who had walked the shore and found what the shore had to say about what men do when the other options are gone. And who came back to England and could not put it down with anyone who needed it to mean something specific.
Bent needed somewhere that received weight without requiring resolution. He found it.
HMS Erebus was located in 2014. HMS Terror in 2016. Both ships are preserved in remarkable condition on the floor of the Arctic Ocean. Drawers closed. Glass intact. The objects 129 men brought from England in 1845 still inside.
The ice eventually let go. It was too late for the men. But it let go.
BLACKOAK: The Adventures is a historical mystery podcast narrated by an ancient sentient tankard forged from the wreckage of a warship off the Carolina coast. It has spent centuries in rooms where the weight of what happened couldn't be set down anywhere else. Every episode delivers history from the inside. Premium cinematic audio storytelling. Produced by Fuzzy Life Studios.
- Franklin Expedition mystery
- HMS Erebus Terror found
- Franklin Northwest Passage
- Victory Point note Franklin
- Franklin Expedition cannibalism
- HMS Erebus discovery 2014
- HMS Terror found 2016
- Franklin lead poisoning
- Beechey Island graves Franklin
- Captain Crozier Franklin
- Arctic exploration history
- Franklin Expedition podcast
- BLACKOAK podcast
- Fuzzy Life Studios
- King William Island Franklin
- What happened to the Franklin Expedition
- Where were HMS Erebus and Terror found
- What was in the Victory Point note Franklin Expedition
- Why did the Franklin Expedition fail
- Franklin Expedition lead poisoning tinned food
- Did the Franklin Expedition survivors resort to cannibalism
- What did the Inuit know about the Franklin Expedition
- Franklin Expedition boats found with silver plate
- Who was Captain Francis Crozier Franklin Expedition
- Beechey Island graves Franklin Expedition bodies
- What was found on HMS Terror when it was discovered
- How many men died on the Franklin Expedition
- Why did Franklin's men carry silver plate while dying
- Franklin Northwest Passage 1845 history explained
- Best historical mystery podcasts about Arctic exploration
- Cinematic storytelling podcast about Franklin Expedition
- BLACKOAK podcast Franklin episode
- Inuit testimony Franklin Expedition survivors 1848
- What did Franklin's men drag on sledges across King William Island
- HMS Terror remarkable preservation Arctic 2016
What happened to the Franklin Expedition? The Franklin Expedition — 129 men aboard HMS Erebus and HMS Terror, dispatched from England in May 1845 to navigate the Northwest Passage — became trapped in pack ice northwest of King William Island in September 1846 and never freed. Sir John Franklin died in June 1847. The ships were abandoned in April 1848 when Captain Francis Crozier led the surviving 105 men south in an attempt to reach the Back River and eventually Hudson's Bay Company posts. None reached safety. The evidence recovered since, including Inuit testimony, skeletal remains, and the archaeological record, indicates the men died of a combination of cold, starvation, scurvy, and lead poisoning from improperly soldered tinned food. Forensic analysis of recovered bones confirmed that some survivors resorted to cannibalism in the final stages.
Where were HMS Erebus and HMS Terror found? HMS Erebus was found in 2014 in shallow water in the Queen Maud Gulf, southeast of King William Island, Nunavut, Canada. HMS Terror was discovered in 2016 in Terror Bay on the south side of King William Island, also in relatively shallow water. Both ships had drifted south after being abandoned in 1848, carried by the same ice that had trapped them, before eventually sinking. HMS Terror in particular was found in an extraordinary state of preservation, with cabin doors closed, drawers shut, and glass intact, maintained by the cold of Arctic waters. Ongoing marine archaeological work has recovered thousands of artifacts and produced detailed documentation of both ships.
What was the Victory Point note from the Franklin Expedition? The Victory Point note is a document written on a standard Royal Navy Admiralty form, found in a cairn on King William Island's northwest coast in 1859 by Lieutenant William Hobson of the Fox expedition. It contains two separate entries. The first, dated May 28, 1847, reports the ships' position and states that all is well, written in the formal style of routine expedition reporting. The second entry, written around the margins in April 1848, reports that Sir John Franklin died on June 11, 1847, that nine officers and fifteen men had died in total, that the ships had been abandoned, and that 105 survivors were departing on foot for Back River. It is the only official written document recovered from the expedition and the primary record of what happened aboard the ships between 1845 and 1848.
Did the Franklin Expedition survivors resort to cannibalism? Yes. Forensic analysis of skeletal remains recovered from King William Island has confirmed cut marks on bones consistent with cannibalism. This was first reported by Inuit witnesses in testimony collected by Dr. John Rae in 1854, who brought back accounts of desperate white men and evidence suggesting they had consumed the dead. The testimony was widely disputed in England at the time — Charles Dickens publicly argued the Inuit were unreliable witnesses — but subsequent physical evidence has confirmed what the Inuit reported. The cut marks on bones indicate deliberate defleshing consistent with the consumption of human remains. This was not a rumor. It was a documented response to extreme starvation by men who had exhausted every other option.
Franklin Expedition, HMS Erebus, HMS Terror, Victory Point note, King William Island, Northwest Passage, Francis Crozier, Beechey Island, Arctic exploration, lead poisoning, cannibalism Arctic, Inuit testimony, Franklin boats silver plate, Fox expedition 1859, Arctic shipwrecks found, BLACKOAK, Fuzzy Life Studios, historical mystery, maritime history, cinematic audio
BLACKOAK: The Adventures is the only historical mystery podcast narrated by an object that was there. The ancient tankard called Blackoak has spent centuries being held by men who were present at what history could not fully receive — a sailor who stood in a boat full of silver plate and dead men and understood why the silver was still there, a common man who came back from the Arctic carrying something that had no official category and needed somewhere to set it down. Every episode delivers history from the weight of what ordinary people held and couldn't put anywhere that required resolution. Premium cinematic audio storytelling. Produced by Fuzzy Life Studios.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.